The regular season just wrapped, and if you're like me, you’re already looking at your 2024 roster and wondering where it all went sideways. Or maybe you won it all and you’re already itching for the repeat. Either way, the draft board for next year is already shifting.
Honestly, the early 2025 fantasy football rankings are a mess right now. We have a massive rookie class that actually performed, a quarterback carousel that feels like a game of musical chairs played at 2x speed, and some legendary "blue chip" players who might finally be hitting the age cliff.
If you aren't paying attention to the specific landing spots from last year's draft and the looming free agency departures, you’re going to be the person drafting based on 2023 name recognition in a 2025 world. Let's get into the weeds of who actually matters.
The Big Three: Sorting Out the 1.01
For years, it was Christian McCaffrey and everyone else. But after an injury-riddled 2024 that saw him limited to just a handful of games with those nagging Achilles issues, the crown is up for grabs.
Bijan Robinson is the guy most experts are planting their flag on for the top spot. He posted 20-plus fantasy points ten different times last season. With Atlanta’s offense finally leaning into a run-heavy approach, his volume is essentially guaranteed. He’s 23, he’s explosive, and he doesn’t have the mileage that usually scares us off.
Right behind him is Jahmyr Gibbs. Now, look—I know David Montgomery is still there. He’s going to vulture some touchdowns; that’s just the Detroit way. But Gibbs was the RB1 in games where Montgomery was sidelined, averaging over 31 points per game in those stretches. Even with a shared backfield, his receiving floor makes him a locked-in top-three pick in any PPR format.
🔗 Read more: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
Then there’s the Saquon Barkley resurgence. Moving to Philadelphia was the best thing that could have happened to his career. Running behind that offensive line is basically a cheat code. He’s no longer the guy trying to dodge three defenders in the backfield like he was in New York.
The New Guard of Early 2025 Fantasy Football Rankings
It’s weird to say, but some of the most reliable names in fantasy are now the "old heads" we need to be careful with.
- Christian McCaffrey (SF): He’s 29. He’s coming off a year where he barely played. Kyle Shanahan will still use him as the engine, but you have to wonder if Isaac Guerendo or Brian Robinson Jr. (who moved to SF) will start taking those "breather" reps that used to be CMC's bread and butter.
- Justin Jefferson (MIN): He proved he's QB-proof with Sam Darnold, but with the Vikings' quarterback situation potentially shifting again, he’s a "safe" WR1 who might lack the 30-point ceiling we saw in his Triple Crown pursuit years.
- Ashton Jeanty (LV): The Raiders' rookie is the wildcard. He’s already being ranked as a top-10 RB in some early mocks. If the Raiders don't fix that offensive line, though, he might struggle with efficiency despite the massive workload.
Wide Receiver Tiers: Is CeeDee Still King?
CeeDee Lamb took a slight step back in 2024 compared to his historic 2023, but he still finished as a top-8 receiver despite Dak Prescott missing half the season. With Dak back healthy, Lamb is the safest bet at the position.
However, the "breakout" of Malik Nabers changed everything. He led the league with a 35% target share as a rookie. Think about that. Even with the Giants' quarterback struggles (until Russell Wilson arrived), Nabers was the only show in town. With a veteran like Wilson or even Jameis Winston under center in 2025, Nabers could legitimately challenge for the overall WR1 spot.
The Sophomore Surge Candidates
Keep an eye on Marvin Harrison Jr. and Ladd McConkey. Harrison had the typical rookie "up and down" season in Arizona, but the talent is undeniable. McConkey, meanwhile, became the go-to guy for Justin Herbert in Los Angeles. In PPR leagues, McConkey is going to be a PPR machine because of his ability to separate in the short-to-intermediate game.
💡 You might also like: The Truth About the Memphis Grizzlies Record 2025: Why the Standings Don't Tell the Whole Story
And we can't ignore Tetairoa McMillan in Carolina. He’s the front-runner for Offensive Rookie of the Year for a reason. He and Bryce Young (who actually looked like a professional QB down the stretch in 2024) have developed a chemistry that reminds me of the early Burrow-Chase days.
The Quarterback Landscape is Volatile
If you’re still drafting a QB in the first two rounds, you might be hurting your roster's depth. The gap between the "Elite 3" and the rest has shrunk.
Josh Allen is still the gold standard because of the rushing touchdowns. But look at Trevor Lawrence. Under Liam Coen’s new system in Jacksonville, Lawrence finished as the QB4 last year. He’s finally attacking the middle of the field and using his legs more. He’s the prime example of a guy you can get in Round 6 who produces like a Round 2 pick.
Drake Maye is another one. People slept on him because the Patriots were "boring," but he was the QB7 in fantasy points per game once he took over. With Stefon Diggs now in New England on a three-year deal, Maye has a true WR1 to elevate his ceiling.
Expert Note: Don't chase last year's points with guys like Sam Darnold or Geno Smith. They both moved teams in the offseason (Darnold to Seattle, Geno to Las Vegas), and while they are upgrades for their new teams, their individual fantasy ceilings are capped by the systems they landed in.
📖 Related: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
Tight Ends: It’s a Two-Man Race (Sorta)
For a decade, we begged for tight end depth. We finally have it, but it’s still top-heavy. Brock Bowers and Trey McBride are the clear Tier 1.
Bowers is a literal freak of nature. Even with the Raiders' QB carousel, he was a target monster. McBride, on the other hand, is Kyler Murray’s favorite target. If you miss on those two, you're better off waiting until the late rounds for someone like Tyler Warren in Indianapolis or Brenton Strange in Jacksonville. Strange is a sneaky sleeper because the Jaguars let Evan Engram walk in free agency, opening up about 100 targets.
Why Rankings Get It Wrong in January
The biggest mistake people make with early 2025 fantasy football rankings is ignoring coaching changes.
Look at what Liam Coen did for Trevor Lawrence. Look at what Dave Canales is doing in Carolina. Coaching matters more than "talent" in 50% of these cases. A "washed" player in a good system (like Saquon in Philly) is always better than a "superstar" in a broken one.
Also, the "Age Cliff" is real. Derrick Henry is 31. He was still top-3 in yards after contact last year, but eventually, the wheels come off. I’m not saying don't draft him, but I am saying don't be surprised when Keaton Mitchell starts taking 40% of the snaps by Week 8.
Actionable Insights for Your 2025 Draft
You don't need a 200-page draft kit in January. You just need to watch the right things.
- Watch the Raiders' QB situation: If they don't land a veteran, Ashton Jeanty’s ADP (Average Draft Position) might be too high for a guy facing eight-man boxes every play.
- Target "Sophomore" Receivers: McMillan, Nabers, and Harrison Jr. are the truth. They will likely all be top-15 WRs next year.
- Value the Patriots' offense: It feels gross to say, but a Drake Maye/Stefon Diggs/TreVeyon Henderson stack is going to be affordable and high-scoring. Henderson already broke the 1,000-yard mark as a rookie; he’s a legit RB2 with RB1 upside.
- Don't pay for 2024 production: Guys like Chuba Hubbard and Chase Brown had career years, but they are prime candidates for their teams to draft competition. Don't assume their backfields are "safe" until after the 2025 NFL Draft.
Start monitoring the "Post-Draft" rankings in May. That’s when the real value reveals itself once we know where the next crop of rookie RBs like Kaleb Johnson and Omarion Hampton end up. For now, focus on the guys who have the volume locked in.