Everyone thinks they've got the 2024 class figured out by now. You see the same names at the top of every single dynasty mock draft 2024 simulation. Caleb, Marvin, Jayden, Malik. It feels like a script. But if you’ve been playing dynasty for more than a minute, you know the script usually gets shredded by Week 4.
The 2024 rookie class is weirdly top-heavy. It’s a Ferrari engine strapped to a lawnmower frame. You have these elite, generational-type prospects at the top—guys like Marvin Harrison Jr. and Caleb Williams—and then a cliff that feels much steeper than usual once you hit the late second round.
Honestly, the "safe" picks aren't always where the league-winning value hides.
The 1.01 Dilemma: Caleb vs. Marv
In a Superflex dynasty mock draft 2024, the conversation starts and ends with Caleb Williams. You’ve heard the Patrick Mahomes comparisons. It’s almost a cliché at this point. Williams went to a Chicago Bears situation that is—uniquely for a number one overall pick—actually good. He’s got DJ Moore. He’s got Keenan Allen. He’s got Rome Odunze. That’s a lot of mouths, but it’s also a massive safety net.
But here is what people miss.
In 1QB leagues, Marvin Harrison Jr. is the undisputed king. He’s the most "pro-ready" receiver we’ve seen since maybe Amari Cooper or AJ Green. He landed in Arizona with Kyler Murray, a guy who loves to hyper-target his WR1. If you're sitting at the 1.02 in a Superflex draft and Caleb goes first, you aren't "settling" for Marv. You're getting a guy who could legitimately put up 1,200 yards as a rookie.
👉 See also: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
Expert Note: Don't let the "boring" pick fool you. Harrison’s floor is essentially a perennial WR1 finish. He’s the guy you draft if you want to sleep soundly at night.
Why Jayden Daniels Is the Real 1.01 Upside
Look, Caleb is the better real-life prospect. I get it. But Jayden Daniels is a fantasy cheat code. We’ve seen this movie before with Lamar Jackson and Anthony Richardson. Rushing yards are worth more than passing yards. It’s basic math.
Daniels ran for over 1,100 yards in his final season at LSU. Even if he’s a league-average passer in Washington, his legs give him a Top 5 ceiling every single week. In a dynasty mock draft 2024, taking Daniels over Caleb isn't crazy; it's a bet on the rushing floor. The risk? He’s thin. He takes hits. If he can’t slide, his career might look more like Robert Griffin III than Lamar.
The Malik Nabers vs. Rome Odunze Debate
This is where the mocks get spicy.
- Malik Nabers (NYG): He’s a "stone-cold baller," as many analysts put it. He’s going to vacuum up targets because, frankly, who else is Daniel Jones going to throw to? Wan'Dale Robinson? Nabers has the explosiveness of Ja'Marr Chase. The only thing holding him back is the Giants' offensive environment.
- Rome Odunze (CHI): He might be the better "pure" receiver than Nabers, but he’s buried. He’s the WR3 on his own team to start the year. In a dynasty startup or a rookie mock, you have to decide: do you want the immediate production of Nabers or the long-term elite profile of Odunze?
Most people are leaning Nabers for the immediate dopamine hit of 10 targets a game. I don't blame them.
✨ Don't miss: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
The Great Running Back Desert
If you need a running back in 2024, I’m sorry. It’s grim.
Jonathon Brooks is the consensus RB1, but he’s coming off an ACL tear and playing for a Carolina Panthers team that struggled to move the ball past the 50-yard line last year. Then you have Trey Benson in Arizona. Benson is fast—like, 4.39-fast—but he’s stuck behind James Conner for at least a year.
In most of my dynasty mock draft 2024 runs, the first RB doesn't go until the late first or early second round. That’s a massive shift from the Bijan Robinson/Jahmyr Gibbs era of 2023. If you’re rebuilding, this is a great year to just ignore the RB position entirely and load up on the deep WR class.
Sneaky Value in the Middle Rounds
While everyone is fighting over the QBs and elite WRs, the middle of the second round is where you win your league.
- Ladd McConkey (LAC): He’s a route-running technician. With Keenan Allen and Mike Williams gone, Jim Harbaugh needs a reliable target. Ladd is that guy. He could easily lead all rookies in receptions.
- Keon Coleman (BUF): He’s polarizing. His 40-time was slow (4.61), but his playing speed is different. He’s in Buffalo with Josh Allen. That’s enough for me to take a swing at the 2.02.
- Brock Bowers (LV): People are fading Bowers because he went to the Raiders. Stop it. He’s a generational tight end prospect. If he’s falling to the 1.07 or 1.08 in Superflex, you stop the slide.
What Really Happened with the Late-Round Sleepers?
Once you get into the third round of a dynasty mock draft 2024, you’re throwing darts at a moving board.
🔗 Read more: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
Ben Sinnott, the tight end from Kansas State who went to Washington, is a name I’m seeing move up boards. He’s athletic, versatile, and has a clear path to playing time. Another name? Bucky Irving. He’s small, and his testing was mediocre, but the guy just produces. He’s the type of back who could steal the goal-line role in Tampa Bay if Rachaad White falters.
Actionable Strategy for Your Draft
Don't just follow the ADP (Average Draft Position). Dynasty is about market inefficiency.
If you are in a "Win Now" window, trading your 2024 1.10 for a veteran like Mike Evans or Davante Adams might actually be the smarter move than drafting a rookie receiver who might take two years to pop. This class is hyped, which means rookie picks are at an all-time high value.
Next Steps for Your Dynasty Team:
- Check your league's settings: If it’s a TEP (Tight End Premium) league, Brock Bowers should be a top-5 pick, period.
- Target the "Tier Breaks": There is a clear drop-off after the top 7 players (Caleb, Daniels, Maye, MHJ, Nabers, Odunze, Bowers). If you have the 1.08, try to trade up into that top tier or trade back for multiple second-rounders.
- Don't reach for RBs: This isn't the year to "get your guy" at running back in the first round. Wait for the value in the second or third.
- Embrace the "Bust" potential: Drake Maye and J.J. McCarthy have high ceilings but low floors. If you take them, pair them with a safe veteran QB so you aren't left stranded if they sit for a year.
The 2024 class will define dynasty rosters for the next half-decade. Whether you go with the rushing upside of Daniels or the safe hands of Harrison, make sure you aren't just drafting based on a spreadsheet. Watch the tape, look at the depth charts, and don't be afraid to be the "wrong" person in the draft room if it means getting the guy you actually believe in.