Dying Light 2 Aitor Quest: What Really Happens If You Kill Him

So you’ve made it to the Central Loop. You’re finally on the PK Floating Fortress, feeling like a big deal, and suddenly Aitor—the guy who spent half of Old Villedor trying to make your life miserable—is wheeled in looking like a piece of chewed gum. He’s dying. Waltz absolutely wrecked him in the tunnels.

Now, the game puts his life directly in your hands. It’s one of those classic Techland moments where you’re standing over a guy’s bed, holding a handful of weeds, wondering if you should be a saint or a cold-blooded killer. Honestly, the Dying Light 2 Aitor quest is less about medicinal herbs and more about whether you can forgive a man who, let’s be real, was kinda a jerk to you for ten hours.

How to Trigger the Aitor Side Quest

You can't just stumble into this one. It’s actually pretty easy to miss if you aren't paying attention to your dialogue choices. When you first get to the Fish Eye and meet Jack Matt, he’s going to ask you what happened back in Old Villedor.

You have to tell Jack Matt the truth about Aitor. If you lie or blow it off, the quest might not even pop up. If you tell him, the "Aitor" side quest triggers automatically during the "Welcome on Board" main mission. You’ll find him in the makeshift medbay on The Missy (the giant PK ship).

The Healer on Culvert Island

The ship's doctor, Steven, is basically out of ideas. He tells you about a "witch" named Margaret who lives on Culvert Island. This is where things get messy. When you go see Margaret, you find out the Peacekeepers—specifically Aitor—didn't treat her very well. In fact, they burned her eyes out because some PKs died after not following her instructions.

It’s a revenge setup. Margaret tells you to go find Recluse flowers in the toxic sludge at night. She gives you very specific instructions: use the small petals to heal, big petals to kill. ## Small Petals vs. Big Petals: The Choice

📖 Related: Free Poker Games Download: What Most People Get Wrong About Playing for Zero Dollars

This is the peak of the Dying Light 2 Aitor quest. You get back to the ship, and Aitor’s wife, Patricia, is losing her mind. She hates Margaret and thinks you’re trying to poison her husband. You’ve got the flowers. You’ve got a timer ticking down. What do you do?

• The "Good" Choice (Small Petals): You give him the small petals. Aitor survives. He stays in the medbay for a while, but eventually, he recovers.
• The "Vengeance" Choice (Big Petals): You give him the big petals. Aitor dies instantly in a pretty gruesome way. Patricia goes ballistic.
• The "Coward" Choice (Refuse): You don't give him anything. He stays in a permanent coma.
• Radio Lawan: If you’re unsure, you can call Lawan. She’ll confirm that Margaret is telling the truth and that small petals are indeed the medicine.

Why You Should Actually Save Him

Look, I get it. Aitor wasn't your best friend. But saving him is objectively the "best" path for rewards. If you save Aitor, he eventually shows up later in the game at the Fish Eye Canteen.

He’ll be there with his son, looking a lot more human and a lot less like a fascist soldier. If you talk to him, he thanks you and gives you The Lazarus. These are the legendary brass knuckles you saw him wearing at the start of the game. They are high-tier, fast, and honestly just look cool. If he's dead? You get nothing but a grumpy widow.

📖 Related: Why How to Turn Your Joins On in Roblox Still Matters for Your Community

The Secret Consequence Nobody Tells You

There is a massive ripple effect to this quest that involves Margaret. If you give Aitor the big petals and he dies, the Peacekeepers don't just shrug it off. They go to Culvert Island and murder Margaret.

Why does this matter? Because much later in the game, during the quest "Breakthrough," a major character (Frank) gets poisoned. Margaret is the only one who knows how to save him. If she’s dead because you decided to troll Aitor with some big petals, Frank is basically toast. You’ll be locked out of the "best" ending for the City because you couldn't play nice with a side quest in the mid-game.

Finding the Recluse Flowers Without Dying

A quick tip for the actual gathering part: don't hang around. The area is north of the All Saints Bridge, and it’s a toxic dump.

1. Wait for night. The flowers don't even show up during the day.
2. Use your Survivor Sense. The flowers glow like crazy (bright white/yellow).
3. Ignore the Biters. There are Howlers and Spitters everywhere. Just parkour in, grab three plants, and get out. You don't need to fight anything.
4. Don't worry about "small" or "big" yet. You just pick the "Recluse" plant. The choice of which part to use happens in the cutscene back at the ship.

Is the Aitor Quest Bugged?

A lot of people have reported that the flowers don't appear or they can't interact with Aitor. Usually, this happens if you progress too far in the main story. This quest is missable. Once you finish the "Cathedral" or "The Lost Sight" missions, the Aitor quest usually fails or disappears. If you want those knuckles, do this quest as soon as it appears.

If you’re at the flower bed and can't pick them up, try sleeping until the next night or restarting the game. Sometimes the prompt just gets stuck in the floor.

Actionable Next Steps:
Head to the Wharf district and check the PK ship. If you’ve already talked to Jack Matt about Old Villedor, the quest marker should be right there in the medbay. Just remember: Small petals for the "Good" ending and the Lazarus knuckles. If you want to watch the world burn and lose Frank later, go ahead and pick the big ones. But don't say I didn't warn you.