Finding a show that doesn't feel like it was churned out by a corporate algorithm is rare. Honestly, that’s why Dwight in Shining Armor hit different. It was weird. It was quirky. And it had this specific brand of "wholesome but chaotic" energy that usually only comes from indie passion projects. If you've spent any time in the fictional town of Woodside, you know exactly what I'm talking about.
The Dwight in Shining Armor cast wasn't just a group of actors hitting their marks; they felt like a bizarre family that actually liked each other. You had a pacifist teen, a gothic warrior princess, and a court magician who looked like he’d rather be anywhere else. It shouldn't have worked. But it did.
Sloane Morgan Siegel as Dwight: Not Your Typical Hero
Sloane Morgan Siegel didn't just play Dwight; he embodied the ultimate "Gen Z pacifist." Most shows would have made the lead character suddenly become a master swordsman. Not Dwight. He’s the guy who tries to solve a dragon problem with a well-organized spreadsheet or a polite conversation about feelings.
Before he was falling into underground chambers and accidentally kissing princesses, Sloane was already a heavy hitter in the "smart kid" TV world. You might remember him as the lead in Gortimer Gibbon's Life on Normal Street. He brought that same grounded, sincere vibe to Dwight.
Sloane has often mentioned in interviews how he grew up on a rescue farm. That background actually tracks with Dwight’s character—someone who is naturally compassionate and patient with creatures (even the ones trying to eat him). By the time the show wrapped its fifth season in 2021, Dwight had evolved from a kid who literally shrieked at danger to someone who would jump in front of it, even if he was still using a non-confrontational approach.
Caitlin Carmichael: Why Princess Gretta Isn't a Fairy Tale
If you went into this show expecting a "damsel in distress," you probably got a reality check in the first five minutes. Caitlin Carmichael played Gretta as a "gothic war zone" survivor. She isn't interested in being rescued. She's interested in swinging a heavy sword and maybe understanding why people in the 21st century are so obsessed with "selfies."
📖 Related: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Caitlin has been acting since she was four. Seriously. She’s been in everything from Criminal Minds to The Mick. But Gretta was her breakout moment as a lead. She played the character with this intense, deadpan stoicism that made her fish-out-of-water moments actually funny rather than cutesy.
One of the coolest things about the Dwight in Shining Armor cast is how involved they were. Caitlin and Sloane actually co-wrote the story for the Season 2 episode "Truthberry Cobbler." That's not something you see every day on a family sitcom.
The Magic (and Grumpiness) of Baldric and Hexela
Joel McCrary is a legend. If he looks familiar, it’s probably because you’ve seen him as Prime Minister Motaz in The Princess Diaries. In Dwight, he plays Baldric, the court magician whose magic is... let's say "hit or miss."
Baldric is basically the tired parent of the group. He’s fiercely protective of Gretta but has zero patience for Dwight’s modern-day nonsense. The chemistry between McCrary and Danielle Bisutti, who plays the witch Hexela, is arguably the best part of the show.
Danielle Bisutti’s Hexela
Bisutti is a powerhouse. Most people know her as the voice of Freya from the God of War games, which is a massive contrast to the glam-witch Hexela.
👉 See also: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
- The Vibe: She starts as a semi-antagonist obsessed with her own youth.
- The Pivot: She eventually becomes the team’s secret weapon.
- The Connection: Her "complicated" past with Baldric (they’re former lovers) adds a layer of adult snark that keeps the show from being too "kiddy."
Evan Hofer: The Prince Who Stole the Show
We have to talk about Chlodwig. Evan Hofer played Gretta's former fiancé (and later, her cousin—it’s a long story) with so much earnestness that you couldn't help but love him. He’s the "brave" knight who is remarkably clumsy.
Hofer’s career took a sharp turn after the show ended. He went from the medieval antics of Woodside to the high-stakes drama of General Hospital as Dex Heller. Seeing him go from a bumbling knight to a soap opera heavy-hitter is wild, but it speaks to how much range the Dwight in Shining Armor cast actually had.
Why the Woodside Ensemble Worked
The show was created by LeeAnne H. Adams and Brian J. Adams. They didn't want a "perfect" cast. They wanted people who could handle the physical comedy of a medieval brawl one minute and a heartfelt conversation about anxiety the next.
The production was based in Utah, far away from the standard Hollywood machine. This isolation probably helped the cast bond. They’ve talked about how they became a real-life family, often hanging out off-set and supporting each other's projects long after the series finale aired in May 2021.
Some Fun Facts You Might Not Know:
- The Casting: Sloane Morgan Siegel was cast as Dwight before they even did chemistry reads with other actors. He was the "anchor."
- The Improv: A lot of the banter between Baldric and Dwight was encouraged by the directors to feel more natural.
- The Stunts: Caitlin Carmichael did a significant amount of her own stunt work, emphasizing Gretta’s warrior background.
The Legacy of the Cast
It's been a few years since the show ended, but the fandom is still surprisingly loud. You’ll see them on social media asking for a reunion movie or a Season 6. While that's unlikely given how everyone has moved on to bigger projects, the impact remains.
✨ Don't miss: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
The Dwight in Shining Armor cast managed to create a show that didn't talk down to kids and didn't bore adults. That’s a tightrope walk that most big-budget streamers fail at every single day.
If you're looking to keep up with the crew, here's what to do:
- Follow Sloane Morgan Siegel on social media; he’s often talking about his new writing projects and voice acting.
- Catch Evan Hofer on the soap circuit if you need a dose of that "Chlodwig" charm (though he's much more serious now).
- Look for Danielle Bisutti in basically every major video game—she's become one of the most sought-after voice and mocap actors in the industry.
Woodside might be a fictional place, but the chemistry that these actors brought to the table was 100% real.
Practical Next Steps
If you're missing the show, the best way to support the cast is to check out their recent work. You can find Sloane Morgan Siegel's voice work in various animated series, and Caitlin Carmichael continues to star in independent films that showcase her range beyond the "warrior princess" trope. For a deep dive into the making of the show, seek out "The Sunken Kingdom" podcast, where the creators and cast share behind-the-scenes stories from all five seasons.