It was time. Everyone knew it. Watching Michigan basketball last season felt like watching a slow-motion car crash where the driver was still trying to convince you the engine just needed a quick tune-up. It didn't. The Juwan Howard era, despite the early Elite Eight run and the Big Ten title, had curdled into something unrecognizable. Last place in the conference? That’s not supposed to happen in Ann Arbor.
Now, we have Dusty May.
People see the hire and they think "FAU guy" or "Final Four run." They think it’s just about shooting more threes. Honestly, it’s a lot deeper than that. The transition from the heavy post-up, isolation-reliant schemes of the previous regime to what May is installing is a total shock to the system. It’s a complete identity swap.
Why the Michigan Basketball Identity Had to Break
You can’t talk about where this team is going without acknowledging how ugly it got. Michigan finished the 2023-24 season with an 8-24 record. Read that again. Eight wins. For a program with the resources of the University of Michigan, that’s statistically difficult to achieve.
The problem wasn't just losing; it was the way they lost. The defense was porous. Transition defense was basically non-existent. There were games where it looked like the players weren't even sure where they were supposed to stand on a simple pick-and-roll coverage. The culture had fractured. When you see a head coach involved in multiple physical altercations and a roster that seems to stop playing for each other by February, you don't just need a new coach. You need a vacuum.
Dusty May didn't just walk in and ask for the keys. He changed the locks.
The Dusty May Philosophy: It’s Not Just "Run and Gun"
There’s this misconception that May just wants to play fast. That’s a oversimplification that ignores the actual "why" behind his success at Florida Atlantic. At FAU, his teams were elite because they maximized every single possession through spacing and decision-making.
He hates stagnant offense.
If a player holds the ball for more than two seconds without making a move or a pass, the system breaks. It’s "read and react" on steroids. This is why the transfer portal haul was so specific. He didn't just go for the highest-rated guys; he went for guys with high "basketball IQ" who can pass, dribble, and shoot at every position.
Look at the addition of Vlad Goldin. Most people see a 7-foot-1 center and think "back to the basket." Not in this offense. Goldin is there to provide gravity. Because he’s such a lob threat and a massive screen setter, he forces the defense to collapse. That opens up the perimeter for guys like Roddy Gayle Jr. and Tre Donaldson.
📖 Related: The Truth About the Memphis Grizzlies Record 2025: Why the Standings Don't Tell the Whole Story
Gayle is an interesting one. Coming over from Ohio State, he’s a guy who can get his own bucket, but he struggled with consistency in a more rigid system. May is betting that in a wide-open floor, Gayle becomes a pro.
The Transfer Portal Strategy: A New Blueprint
The days of recruiting four or five freshmen and hoping they develop by their junior year are dead. Or at least, they’re on life support. Michigan basketball is the poster child for the "Portal Age" right now.
May flipped almost the entire roster in a matter of weeks.
- Danny Wolf (Yale): This is the "unicorn" play. A 7-footer who can bring the ball up the floor and hit trailing threes. It sounds like a gimmick until you see him play.
- Tre Donaldson (Auburn): He brings that SEC physicality. Michigan was soft last year. Donaldson isn't soft.
- Rubin Jones (North Texas): A defensive specialist who knows the "mid-major" grind. He’s the glue guy every championship team needs.
Wait, let's talk about the Yale kid for a second. Danny Wolf chose Michigan because he wanted to play in a system that didn't box him into the "big man" category. If May can successfully play Wolf and Goldin at the same time—the "Twin Towers" look—it’s going to be a nightmare for Big Ten coaches who are used to smaller, more traditional lineups.
It’s a gamble. If you play two bigs, you risk getting burned on the perimeter. But May isn't running a traditional 2-3 zone or a sagging man-to-man. He wants his guys 94 feet away from the basket.
The Pressure of Ann Arbor
Let's be real. The Michigan fan base is exhausted. They’ve seen the football team win a National Championship and then had to watch the basketball team fall into a dark hole. The expectations for Dusty May aren't just "be better than last year."
The expectation is the NCAA Tournament. Immediately.
Is that fair? Probably not. You’re asking a guy to take 10 strangers and make them a cohesive unit in six months. But that’s the price of the job. The NIL (Name, Image, Likeness) collective at Michigan, Champions Circle, stepped up big time to get these transfers in the door. When the boosters spend that kind of money, they don't want to hear about "building for the future."
They want to see the jump hook. They want to see the ball movement. They want to see the Crisler Center actually loud again.
👉 See also: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
Defensive Regression vs. Offensive Progression
Last year, Michigan’s defense was ranked near the bottom of the country in effective field goal percentage allowed. It was a layup line.
Dusty May’s FAU teams weren't exactly defensive juggernauts in terms of blocks or steals, but they were incredibly disciplined. They didn't beat themselves. They didn't give up "stupid" fouls.
The biggest challenge for this new Michigan roster isn't scoring 80 points. They’ll do that easily. The challenge is stopping someone when the shots aren't falling in a cold gym in Madison or East Lansing in January.
Will Cheddar is a name people forget. He’s a holdover who actually fits the new style. He’s gritty. He’s the kind of guy who will dive into the front row for a loose ball. May needs about four more of him.
Recruiting the "New" Way
May hasn't ignored high school recruiting, but he’s being surgical. Landing Justin Pippen (yes, Scottie’s son) was a statement. It showed that Michigan still has the brand power to attract elite talent even after a disastrous season. Pippen is a late-bloomer who fits the "multi-positional" mold.
But the reality is that Michigan basketball is now a year-to-year proposition. The "one-and-done" era has evolved into the "one-year-contract" era. You recruit a roster, you play the season, and then you do it all over again in April. It’s exhausting for fans to keep track of, but it’s the only way to stay competitive in the current Big Ten.
What to Watch for This Season
If you're heading to Crisler or watching on TV, don't just look at the score. Look at the "pace of play."
If Michigan is walking the ball up the floor, they’re losing.
If they’re taking shots early in the shot clock, don't scream at the TV. That’s the plan. May wants "gravity" players—guys who have to be guarded even when they don't have the ball. When Danny Wolf pops to the top of the key, he pulls a defender out of the paint. That creates a lane for Tre Donaldson to drive.
✨ Don't miss: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
It’s basic math. More space equals more efficient shots.
The "John Beilein" Comparisons
People keep trying to compare Dusty May to John Beilein. It’s natural. Beilein is the gold standard for Michigan basketball. He turned a dormant program into a powerhouse with "The System."
But May isn't Beilein.
Beilein’s offense was based on intricate cuts and very specific patterns. May’s is more fluid. It’s more about empowering players to make their own reads. Beilein was a teacher; May is more of a conductor. Both work, but the "Dusty Way" is arguably better suited for the modern player who wants more freedom.
Actionable Insights for Michigan Fans
If you want to actually understand how this season is going to go, stop looking at the AP Poll. It doesn't matter in November. Instead, focus on these three things:
- Effective Field Goal Percentage (eFG%): If Michigan is in the top 30 nationally here, they are a lock for the tournament. May’s systems live and die by shot quality.
- Defensive Rebounding Rate: This is the red flag. With a smaller, faster lineup, can they actually finish a defensive possession? If they give up 15 offensive rebounds to Big Ten bruisers, they're in trouble.
- Rotation Consistency: By mid-December, May needs to have his 8-man rotation set. If he’s still shuffling guys in and out like a hockey team, it means the chemistry hasn't clicked.
Don't expect a 30-win season right out of the gate. Expect volatility. There will be nights where they hit 15 threes and look like the best team in the country. There will be nights where they look like five guys who just met in the parking lot.
The goal for Michigan basketball this year isn't a trophy. It’s relevance.
It’s about making the program a place where players want to be and fans want to watch. If they can get back to the tournament and win a game or two, the Dusty May era will be off to a flyer.
Keep an eye on the injury report for the bigs. In this system, if Goldin or Wolf goes down, the whole "spacing" experiment gets a lot harder to execute. But for now, for the first time in a few years, there is actually a reason to be optimistic in Ann Arbor.
The "basement" is gone. Now we see how high the ceiling really is.