The thing about the Dune universe is that everyone is lying. Always. If you've been keeping up with Dune: Prophecy on HBO, you probably realized by now that the Bene Gesserit—or the "Sisterhood" as they’re still mostly called in this era—aren't exactly the heroes. They’re more like the galaxy's most dangerous HR department. By the time we hit Dune: Prophecy Season 1 Episode 3, the slow-burn political tension finally shifts into something much more visceral and, honestly, a little terrifying.
If episode two was about setting the board, this third installment is where the pieces start getting knocked over.
We’re 10,000 years before Paul Atreides. There’s no spice-induced prescience saving anyone here. Instead, we have Valya Harkonnen, played with a sort of chilling, sharp-edged desperation by Emily Watson, trying to keep a grip on a master plan that is clearly fraying at the edges. The episode, titled "Sisterhood Above All," dives deep into the messy overlap between personal vendettas and the supposed "greater good" of the Sisterhood.
The Desmond Hart Problem Just Got Real
Let’s talk about Travis Fimmel for a second. His portrayal of Desmond Hart is weird. It’s twitchy, it’s unpredictable, and in this episode, it becomes genuinely lethal. Most of us spent the first two episodes wondering if he was just a religious zealot or something more supernatural. Now, we're seeing the "something more."
Hart’s influence over Emperor Javicco Corrino isn't just political advice; it’s a psychological hijacking. He’s positioning himself as the only one who can "save" the Imperium from the "witches." In this episode, we see the fallout of the horrific events at the end of the previous chapter. The Emperor is grieving, he’s unstable, and Hart is right there to whisper in his ear. The dynamic here is fascinating because it flips the usual Dune trope. Usually, the Bene Gesserit are the ones pulling the strings in the shadows. Here, they’re being outmaneuvered by a man who seems to have walked out of a nightmare with powers they don't fully understand yet.
It’s messy. It’s violent.
📖 Related: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
The scene where Hart confronts one of the Sisters is a standout. It highlights the vulnerability of the Order. They aren't the all-powerful Truthsayers of the Frank Herbert novels yet. They are a startup. A dangerous, secretive startup, but one that can still be bled.
Valya Harkonnen and the Burden of the Voice
Valya is a character defined by her trauma. That’s the core of it. We get more glimpses into her past here, specifically how the Harkonnen name—which at this point in history is basically dirt—fuels her every move. She isn't just building a school; she’s building an army to ensure her family is never humiliated again.
In Dune: Prophecy Season 1 Episode 3, we see the toll the "Voice" takes. It’s not a magic trick. It’s a physical and mental strain. The sound design in these scenes is incredible—it feels like a vibration in your own skull. But what’s more interesting is the ideological split within the Sisterhood itself. Valya’s sister, Tula, is starting to show cracks. While Valya is focused on the long game and the survival of their lineage, Tula is clearly struggling with the morality of what they’re doing.
Basically, the Sisterhood is a pressure cooker. You’ve got young acolytes who are terrified, leaders who are obsessed with power, and an outside force in Desmond Hart who wants to burn the whole thing down.
The Reckoning on Salusa Secundus
Politics in Dune usually involves people standing in grand halls and talking in riddles. This episode gives us a lot of that, but the stakes feel higher because the Corrino throne is so precarious. Princess Ynez is caught in the middle. She wants to be a leader, but she’s also being groomed by the Sisterhood.
👉 See also: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
The relationship between Ynez and her mentor is one of the more grounded parts of the show. It’s a classic coming-of-age story, if that age involved learning how to manipulate entire planetary systems. But when the Emperor makes a move that directly contradicts the Sisterhood’s wishes—pushed by Hart—the alliance starts to crumble.
What really stands out in this episode is the "Great Schools" conflict. We often forget that Dune: Prophecy is based on Sisterhood of Dune by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson. It’s an era where the Butlerian Jihad—the war against "thinking machines"—is still a fresh memory. People are terrified of technology, but they’re also terrified of what humans are becoming to replace that technology.
Hart represents that fear. He’s the personification of the anti-tech, anti-evolution sentiment that almost destroyed humanity.
Why This Episode Changes the Stakes
Honestly, the middle of a season is usually where shows sag. Not here. Episode 3 moves with a frantic energy because the secrets are coming out. The "prophecy" part of the title starts to feel less like a religious promise and more like a threat.
We see the introduction of several subplots involving the different Great Houses that might feel overwhelming if you aren't paying attention. The key is to watch the eyes. In this show, what people don't say is usually more important than the dialogue. The subtle nods, the forced smiles at court, the way a Sister flinches when Valya enters the room—that’s where the real story is.
✨ Don't miss: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
One of the biggest misconceptions about this show is that it’s just a "prequel" to the movies. It’s not. It’s a political thriller that happens to be set in space. If you go in expecting Paul Atreides-level heroics, you’ll be disappointed. This is a story about the villains, the survivors, and the people who would eventually become the myths we know.
Key Takeaways from Episode 3:
- Desmond Hart’s Power: He isn’t just a human. There is something fundamentally wrong with him that the Sisterhood can’t categorize.
- The Harkonnen Rift: Valya and Tula are not on the same page, and that gap is widening.
- Imperial Instability: The Emperor is losing control of his court, making him more dangerous, not less.
- The Voice: It’s being used as a weapon of last resort, showing the Sisterhood’s growing desperation.
What to Watch for Next
The ending of this episode leaves a lot of blood on the floor, literally and figuratively. If you’re trying to keep track of where this is going, focus on the acolytes. The younger generation of the Sisterhood is where the real rebellion will come from. Valya is so focused on the Emperor and Desmond Hart that she might be missing the rot inside her own walls.
To get the most out of the coming episodes, keep these actions in mind:
- Re-watch the flashbacks: The clues to Valya’s true endgame are hidden in those brief glimpses of her childhood.
- Track the "Gift": Pay attention to which characters are showing signs of the abilities that will eventually define the Bene Gesserit. It’s not just about the Voice; it’s about body control and observation.
- Watch the background: The set design on Salusa Secundus is packed with Easter eggs regarding the various Great Houses.
The conflict isn't just about who sits on the throne. It’s about who controls the human mind. And right now, in the wake of episode 3, it looks like nobody has a firm grip on that. The "prophecy" is messy, and it’s only going to get darker from here.