You know that feeling when you're flipping through cable channels on a rainy Sunday and you stumble upon a movie that's so fundamentally wrong, yet so incredibly watchable? That is the essence of Double Jeopardy, the 1999 smash hit starring Ashley Judd and Tommy Lee Jones. It’s a movie that basically everyone has seen once, usually during a long flight or a hotel stay, but it’s also a movie that keeps law professors awake at night.
The premise is kinda brilliant in its simplicity. Libby Parsons, played by a peak-era Ashley Judd, is framed for the murder of her husband, Nick, during a sailing trip. She goes to prison, loses her son, and eventually realizes—thanks to a phone call—that Nick isn't actually dead. He’s living it up under a new identity with Libby's former best friend and her son. While behind bars, a fellow inmate (who apparently missed a few classes in law school) tells Libby that because she was already convicted of murdering Nick, she can kill him for real in the middle of Times Square once she’s out and the government can’t do a thing about it.
That’s the "Double Jeopardy" hook. It’s high-octane revenge. But honestly, as a legal strategy? It's absolute nonsense.
The Legal Myth That Sold Millions of Tickets
Let’s get the big thing out of the way: if you actually tried what Libby Parsons does in the movie, you’d go straight back to prison for life. Probably without a cool Tommy Lee Jones figure to track you down. The Double Jeopardy Clause in the Fifth Amendment is designed to stop the government from harassing you with multiple trials for the same specific act.
It does not give you a "get out of murder free" card for future crimes.
Think about it this way. If I get convicted of stealing a blue Ford Mustang on a Tuesday, and then I get out of jail and steal that same car on a Friday, the Friday theft is a new crime. Same victim, same car, different day. Different crime. If Libby kills Nick in New Orleans after serving time for a "murder" in Washington State, those are two distinct events. Prosecutors would have a field day with her.
👉 See also: Why the Marvel Avengers movie 2012 still works when modern blockbusters fail
Despite this massive plot hole, the movie was a juggernaut. It raked in over $177 million worldwide. Why? Because we love a "wronged woman" narrative, and Ashley Judd was the undisputed queen of the mid-to-late 90s thriller.
Why Tommy Lee Jones is the Secret Weapon
If you’ve seen The Fugitive, you’ve basically seen Tommy Lee Jones’s performance here. He plays Travis Lehman, a cynical, whiskey-sipping parole officer who has to track Libby down after she skips town to find her husband.
It’s a role he can do in his sleep. He’s gruff. He’s relentless. He has that "I’m too old for this" energy that makes him the perfect foil for Judd’s desperate, high-energy lead.
- The Vibe: Dark, moody, and surprisingly scenic.
- The Locations: We go from the rainy Pacific Northwest to the colorful, humid streets of New Orleans.
- The Fashion: Minimalist 90s chic. Lots of turtlenecks and practical jackets.
What’s interesting is how the movie treats Lehman’s character. He isn't just a villainous lawman. He’s a guy with his own baggage—a failed marriage and a drinking problem—which makes his eventual realization that Libby might be telling the truth feel earned. It’s a classic "hunter becomes the ally" trope, and honestly, nobody does it better than Jones.
The Production Drama You Didn't Know About
Getting Double Jeopardy to the screen wasn't exactly smooth sailing. Before Ashley Judd took the lead, the role was offered to Meg Ryan and Brooke Shields. Both turned it down. Can you imagine Meg Ryan in this? It would have been a totally different movie—likely softer, less "I’m going to bury you alive" and more "I’m very disappointed in you, Nick."
The budget was roughly $40 million (though some reports put it closer to $70 million including marketing), which was a decent chunk of change in 1999. Director Bruce Beresford, who did Driving Miss Daisy, brought a certain level of prestige to what could have been a trashy B-movie.
He focused on the tension. The scene where Libby is trapped in a coffin in a New Orleans cemetery? Pure nightmare fuel. It’s one of those moments that sticks with you long after the credits roll, mostly because it taps into a universal phobia.
A Quick Reality Check on the Cast
- Ashley Judd (Libby Parsons): At the time, she was coming off Kiss the Girls. She was the face of the thinking person's thriller.
- Tommy Lee Jones (Travis Lehman): He was basically playing a variation of his Oscar-winning Sam Gerard character.
- Bruce Greenwood (Nick Parsons): He is perfectly slimy. You want to see him get caught from the very first frame.
- Annabeth Gish (Angie): The "friend" who betrays Libby. She plays the guilt-ridden-but-complicit role perfectly.
The Cultural Legacy of a Legal Lie
It's funny how movies can bake false information into the public consciousness. To this day, if you ask a random person what "double jeopardy" means, there’s a good chance they’ll describe the plot of this movie. It’s similar to how people think you have to wait 24 hours to report a missing person (you don't) or that you're entitled to exactly one phone call in jail (it depends).
But the film's inaccuracy doesn't actually hurt the experience of watching it. In fact, it kind of helps. The "legal loophole" gives Libby a sense of righteous empowerment. It turns a standard revenge story into something that feels—at least within the logic of the film's universe—justified.
Critics at the time were mixed. Roger Ebert gave it two and a half stars, noting the logic gaps but praising the performances. He famously said the movie was "made for the weekend, not the ages." And yet, here we are, decades later, still talking about it.
What You Should Do If You're Planning a Rewatch
If you’re going to dive back into the world of Libby Parsons and her quest for justice, do it with open eyes.
First, appreciate the cinematography. The shift from the cold, blue tones of the island in Washington to the warm, suffocating yellows of Louisiana is gorgeous. Second, watch for the smaller performances. Roma Maffia as Libby’s friend in prison is a standout, even with limited screen time.
Most importantly, don’t take the law lessons to heart.
If you're looking for a double feature, pair this with The Fugitive. It’s fascinating to see Tommy Lee Jones play the same archetype in two different contexts. In one, he's the hero's main obstacle; in the other, he's the only person who can actually help her.
Actionable Insights for Movie Lovers:
📖 Related: Did She Mention My Name: Why Gordon Lightfoot’s Forgotten Classic Still Stings
- Check out the Paramount Presents 4K Ultra HD release if you want to see those New Orleans scenes in high fidelity.
- Don't quote the movie in a courtroom. Ever.
- If you like this style, look for other 90s "woman-in-peril" thrillers like The Net or Copycat.
The movie is a time capsule. It represents a period where Hollywood could sell a film on a single high-concept hook and two dependable stars. It doesn't need a cinematic universe or a CGI finale. It just needs a woman who was wronged and a man with a badge who eventually decides to look the other way.