New York City is a place of rules, yet it is also a place where everyone basically ignores them until a cop or an MTA worker gives them the side-eye. But there is one rule that has birthed a whole subculture of creativity, frustration, and honestly, some of the funniest photos on the internet. We’re talking about the infamous MTA Section 1050.9. It’s the rule that says you can't bring an animal into a station or on a train unless it’s "enclosed in a container."
The wording is key. It doesn't say "small dog." It doesn't specify a weight limit. It just says the animal has to be in a container.
So, naturally, New Yorkers being New Yorkers, they started stuffing 80-pound Huskies into IKEA blue bags. They cut holes in the bottom of canvas totes so a Pitbull's legs could poke through. It’s chaos. If you’ve spent any time on the L train or the Q, you’ve probably seen a Golden Retriever looking remarkably calm while hanging from its owner's shoulder in a modified hiking pack. This is the reality of dogs bags nyc subway life. It’s not just a suggestion; it’s a survival tactic for pet owners who can't afford a $60 Uber Pet every time they want to take their dog to Central Park or a vet in another borough.
What the MTA Actually Says (And What They Ignore)
The official Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) Rules of Conduct state that no person may bring any animal on or into any conveyance or facility unless it’s enclosed in a container and carried in a manner which would not annoy other passengers. This is the legal foundation.
But look, "annoy" is subjective.
A Great Dane in a massive duffle bag might annoy a commuter during rush hour at Union Square, but it might be the highlight of someone else's day. Generally, the NYPD and MTA staff are looking for safety. If your dog is secured and not barking its head off or biting people, you’re usually fine. The problem is that "enclosed" is doing a lot of heavy lifting. Does the head have to be inside? Technically, yes. In practice? Most conductors aren’t going to kick you off if a snout is poking out to get some air.
👉 See also: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
I’ve seen people try to use a mesh grocery bag. Don't do that. It’s flimsy, it’s dangerous for the dog, and it’s the quickest way to get a summons. A summons for an animal violation in the subway can run you about $25. It’s not the end of the world, but it’s a headache you don't need.
The Evolution of the "Subway Dog" Bag
Back in the day, if you had a big dog, you just didn't take the subway. Simple. Then, the "IKEA bag hack" went viral around 2017. People realized that the $0.99 large blue Frakta bags from IKEA were surprisingly sturdy. They’re basically indestructible. If you cut four holes in the bottom, you have a makeshift harness.
However, the market caught up. Companies like K9 Sport Sack started making heavy-duty backpacks specifically for this purpose. These aren't just bags; they are engineered pieces of gear with cooling vents and lumbar support for the human. Because let’s be real, carrying a 50-pound Lab on your back while navigating the stairs at the 4th Ave-9th St station in Brooklyn is basically a CrossFit workout you didn't sign up for.
Why the Bag Matters More Than You Think
It isn't just about the rules. The subway is loud. It’s screechy. It’s crowded.
A bag provides a "safe space" for a dog. Even a confident dog can get spooked by the gap between the train and the platform. When they are in a bag, they are contained. They aren't going to bolt. They aren't going to get their paws stuck in the escalator (which, please, never let your dog walk on an escalator—it’s a nightmare of injuries).
- Hard-sided carriers: Great for cats and Chihuahuas, but a nightmare for navigating a crowded 6 train.
- Soft-sided duffels: These are the gold standard for medium dogs. Brands like Sherpa are classic for a reason.
- Backpacks: Essential for the big boys. If your dog is over 30 pounds, your shoulder will give out in a tote bag.
Real Talk: The Etiquette of Dogs Bags NYC Subway
You've got the bag. You've got the dog. Now you have to actually get on the train.
✨ Don't miss: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
First off, rush hour is a no-go. Honestly. If you try to bring a Samoyed in a bag onto a packed E train at 8:30 AM, you are going to be the most hated person in New York. People are stressed. They are late. They don't want fur on their work clothes. Wait until 10:00 AM or travel on weekends.
Secondly, watch the tail. If your dog’s tail is wagging outside the bag, it’s a tripping hazard. I’ve seen people accidentally step on tails, and the resulting yelp is heartbreaking. Keep everything tucked in.
Third, read the room. If someone looks terrified of dogs, don't stand right next to them. Not everyone thinks your "good boy" is a gift to humanity. Some people have phobias, and in a moving metal tube with no escape, those phobias are amplified.
Training Your Dog for the Bag Life
You can't just shove a dog into a bag and expect them to be chill. It takes weeks of "bag training" at home.
Start by putting treats in the bag. Let them sniff it. Then, have them sit in it while it’s on the floor. Gradually lift it up for five seconds, then ten.
Most NYC dogs are remarkably well-adjusted. They’ve seen it all: the breakdancers, the "Showtime" kids, the guy eating a full rotisserie chicken with his bare hands. A bag is nothing to them. But if your dog has high anxiety, the subway might just be too much, bag or no bag.
🔗 Read more: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong
The Legal Gray Area and Famous Workarounds
The most famous "workaround" happened when someone put their dog in a literal burlap sack. It was technically a container. Another person used a rolling suitcase with air holes. The MTA doesn't actually define what a "container" is, which is the loophole big dog owners live in.
But remember, the MTA is a "common carrier." This means they have a high duty of care for passengers, but they also have the right to refuse service. If an officer thinks your "bag" is unsafe—like if the bottom looks like it’s about to blow out—they will stop you.
Actionable Steps for New York Dog Owners
If you're planning to navigate the city with your pup, here is exactly what you need to do to stay on the right side of the law and the commuters:
- Measure your dog's length and height while sitting. Most people buy bags that are too small, leading to a cramped, grumpy dog.
- Invest in a bag with a solid base. If the bottom of the bag sags, it puts pressure on the dog’s spine. Look for bags with a removable wooden or plastic baseboard.
- Carry "distraction" treats. The subway has weird smells and loud noises. A high-value treat (think freeze-dried liver) can keep a dog focused on you rather than the rattling train doors.
- Check your path for elevators. Carrying a bagged dog up three flights of stairs at a deep station like 191st St is brutal. Use the MTA's "Elevator and Escalator Status" page or the MYmta app.
- Clean up immediately. If your dog has an accident in the bag or—heaven forbid—on the platform, you must have poop bags and wipes ready. Leaving a mess is the fastest way to get the NYPD involved.
New York is a dog city. We love them. We treat them like children. But the subway is a shared space. Respecting the bag rule isn't just about avoiding a ticket; it's about making sure that the city stays "pet-friendly" for everyone.
The moment a dog bites someone or causes a major delay because they weren't properly contained is the moment the MTA might decide to crack down and tighten the rules. For now, the "if it fits, it sits" era of dog travel is a weird, wonderful part of NYC life. Keep your dog secure, keep your bag sturdy, and maybe stay off the L train during the Saturday night rush.