You’ve seen the wig. You’ve seen the yellow cardigan. You definitely know the mantra. "I’m good enough, I’m smart enough, and doggone it, people like me." It’s one of the most enduring catchphrases in the history of Saturday Night Live, birthed from the mind of Al Franken during a time when self-help culture was just starting to get weird. But here’s the thing: what started as a biting parody of the 12-step movement and Affirmation Culture has somehow morphed into a weirdly sincere touchstone for the modern internet.
Franken didn't just stumble into this. He was actually attending Al-Anon meetings at the time—not because he had a drinking problem, but to support friends and family. He started noticing the specific, often repetitive language of recovery. The pauses. The sighs. The aggressive "owning" of emotions. He took those observations and created Stuart Smalley, a man who was constantly "in a shame spiral" but trying his hardest to "stop shoulding on himself."
It was funny because it was uncomfortable. It’s still funny because, honestly, we’ve all become Stuart Smalley now.
The Origin of the Daily Affirmation
Stuart Smalley first appeared on SNL in 1991. The character was presented as the host of a public-access cable show called Daily Affirmations with Stuart Smalley. Unlike the high-energy characters played by Chris Farley or the sharp political impressions of the era, Stuart was soft. He was fragile. He was "highly codependent."
Franken’s genius was in the specificity of the jargon. He used terms like "adult child," "denial," and "enabler" with a precision that only someone who had actually sat in those folding chairs could manage. When Stuart would look into the mirror and say, "Doggone it, people like me," he wasn't just telling a joke. He was portraying a man desperate to believe his own PR while his inner monologue was screaming that he was a failure.
The sketch worked because it tapped into a burgeoning American obsession with self-improvement. The 1990s were the decade of Tony Robbins, The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People, and John Gray’s Men Are from Mars, Women Are from Venus. We were a nation obsessed with fixing our broken parts, and Stuart Smalley was our funhouse-mirror reflection.
Why the Humor Was Actually Hard-Hitting
A lot of people think Stuart Smalley was just a guy in a bad sweater talking to himself. It was deeper. The comedy came from the gap between the affirmations and the reality of Stuart’s life. He would host celebrities—everyone from Michael Jordan to Milton Berle—and instead of interviewing them, he’d force them into his neuroses.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Remember the Michael Jordan episode? It's legendary. Here is the greatest athlete on the planet, a man whose confidence was literally his brand, sitting next to a guy who is terrified of his own shadow. Stuart tries to get Jordan to admit that he doesn't have to be a great basketball player to be liked. Jordan just looks at him, bewildered. It highlighted the absurdity of applying "participation trophy" psychology to world-class excellence.
But it also showed Stuart’s humanity. We’ve all had those moments where we try to talk ourselves into a confidence we don't actually feel. When he’d stumble over a word and immediately start berating himself—"I’m a loser! I’m a fat, incompetent jerk!"—before catching himself and saying, "That’s just stinkin' thinkin'," it felt real. It was a 1991 version of a Twitter thread about "imposter syndrome."
The Failed Movie and the Character's Death
In 1995, Paramount released Stuart Saves His Family. It was directed by Harold Ramis—the guy behind Groundhog Day and Caddyshack. On paper, it should have been a massive hit. It had a great pedigree. It had a solid supporting cast, including Vincent D'Onofrio.
It bombed. Hard.
It’s actually one of the lowest-grossing films ever based on an SNL character. Why? Because the movie was actually too good at being a drama about a dysfunctional family. It wasn't a wacky comedy like Wayne’s World. It was a dark, often painful look at alcoholism, obesity, and the way families tear each other apart. People went in expecting "Doggone it, people like me" and left feeling like they needed a therapy session.
Franken himself has spoken about the movie's failure with a mix of pride and sadness. In his book Al Franken, Giant of the Senate, he notes that the film is actually used in some recovery programs today because it depicts the dynamics of an alcoholic family so accurately. It’s a cult classic now, but at the time, it effectively killed the character’s mainstream momentum.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
The Cultural Pivot: From Parody to Reality
Fast forward to the 2020s. We live in the age of the "Self-Care Industrial Complex." Instagram is littered with pastel-colored squares telling us that we are "enough." TikTok is full of creators giving "daily affirmations."
The irony is that Stuart Smalley was meant to be a cautionary tale about the vapidity of these phrases. But today, the phrase "Doggone it, people like me" is often used without a hint of irony. We have become a culture that communicates almost exclusively in the jargon Franken was making fun of.
Think about it.
Stuart Smalley talked about "boundaries" before it was a buzzword on Hinge.
He talked about "toxic" people before it was a standard adjective for an ex-boyfriend.
He was the pioneer of the "it’s okay to not be okay" movement, even if he was doing it for laughs.
What Most People Get Wrong About Stuart
The biggest misconception is that the character was mocking people in recovery. He wasn't. Franken has been very clear that he has a lot of respect for the 12-step process. The joke wasn't the program; the joke was the performance of the program.
Stuart was the guy who learned the vocabulary but hadn't quite mastered the emotional maturity. He used affirmations as a band-aid for deep-seated trauma. When he said those famous words, he was trying to bypass the hard work of actually liking himself.
That’s a nuance that gets lost in the memes. If you actually watch the old sketches, Stuart is often on the verge of a total nervous breakdown. The comedy is in the tension. It’s the sound of a man whistling past the graveyard of his own self-esteem.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
How to Actually Use Affirmations (Without Being a Stuart)
If you’re actually looking to improve your self-talk, you can take a page out of the Stuart Smalley playbook—just maybe don't do it in a yellow cardigan. Psychologists have actually studied the efficacy of affirmations, and there’s a catch.
According to a study published in Psychological Science, positive affirmations can actually backfire for people with low self-esteem. Why? Because when you say something like "I am a lovable person" but you don't believe it, your brain immediately pushes back with all the reasons why that isn't true. This creates "cognitive dissonance."
To make affirmations work—to truly feel like "doggone it, people like me"—you have to make them believable. Instead of "I am perfect," try "I am working on being better." It’s less catchy, but it’s more effective.
Actionable Steps for Better Self-Talk
If you find yourself in a "shame spiral" like our friend Stuart, here’s how to actually dig out:
- Identify the "Stinkin' Thinkin'": Catch yourself when you use absolutes. Words like "always," "never," and "everybody" are usually lies. "Everybody hates me" is a Stuart Smalley line. "I feel lonely right now" is a reality.
- Neutralize the Affirmation: If "I'm smart enough" feels like a lie, try "I have the capacity to learn." It’s much harder for your brain to argue with a neutral fact than a positive platitude.
- Watch the 1991 Michael Jordan Sketch: Seriously. It’s a masterclass in comedic timing and a great reminder not to take your own self-improvement journey too seriously.
- Own the Mistakes: Stuart’s biggest flaw was his fear of being "wrong." In reality, admitting you messed up is the fastest way to stop a shame spiral.
- Check the Cardigan: Sometimes, you just need to laugh at how ridiculous the human condition is. Stuart Smalley was a mirror. If you don't like what you see, change the reflection, not just the mantra.
The legacy of "Doggone it, people like me" isn't just a punchline from a 35-year-old sketch show. It's a reminder that the struggle to be "good enough" is universal, messy, and occasionally hilarious. We are all Stuart Smalley, sitting in front of our digital mirrors, trying to convince ourselves that we’ve got it all figured out. And that’s okay. Because, doggone it, we’re trying.