You just pulled a sixty-hour week. You’re exhausted, your feet hurt, and you’ve basically forgotten what your living room looks like, but hey, the overtime pay is going to be massive. Then the direct deposit hits. You look at the stub and feel that immediate, hot flash of annoyance. It looks like the government took almost half of your extra earnings. Honestly, it feels like a punishment for working hard. You start wondering if those extra shifts are even worth it if the IRS is just going to scoop up the lion’s share.
Does overtime get taxed at a higher rate than your regular hours? The short answer is no, but the long answer is why everyone gets so confused every Friday.
Tax laws in the United States don’t actually have a separate "overtime tax." There is no secret line item in the Internal Revenue Code that says "money earned after 40 hours shall be taxed at a premium." Your income is just income. Whether you earned it at 2:00 PM on a Tuesday or 2:00 AM on a Sunday, the IRS views it all as the same pile of taxable cash at the end of the year. However, your employer’s payroll software doesn’t see it that way. That’s where the "overtime tax myth" comes from, and it's rooted in how withholding works.
The Withholding Trap: Why Your Check Looks Wrong
When you receive a paycheck, your employer isn't actually "taxing" you. They are withholding money on behalf of the government based on what they think you’ll owe at the end of the year. Payroll systems are notoriously literal-minded. They are essentially math robots.
If you usually make $1,000 a week, the computer assumes you make $52,000 a year. It calculates your withholding based on that $52,000 bracket. But if you work a ton of overtime and pull in $2,000 in a single week, the payroll software panics. For that one specific pay period, the computer thinks, "Oh wow, this person is actually making $104,000 a year!"
It then bumps you into a higher withholding bracket for that specific check.
It’s an aggressive estimation. Because the U.S. uses a progressive tax system—where higher chunks of income are taxed at higher percentages—the software takes a bigger bite out of that $2,000 check than it would a $1,000 check. You aren't actually being taxed more in the long run, but your immediate "take-home" pay feels the sting of that higher projection.
Progressive Brackets vs. Flat Rates
Think of tax brackets like a series of buckets. According to the IRS 2025/2026 tax tables, the first bucket of money you earn is taxed at 10%. Once that bucket is full, the next chunk goes into the 12% bucket, then the 22% bucket, and so on.
- $0 to $11,925 (for singles): 10%
- $11,926 to $48,475: 12%
- $48,476 to $103,350: 22%
If your regular pay keeps you safely in the 12% bucket, but your overtime pushes your "projected annual income" into the 22% bucket for that week, the software will withhold at that 22% rate. It’s annoying. It sucks. But—and this is the part people forget—you usually get that money back in the form of a tax refund when you file your returns in April. The government is essentially taking an interest-free loan from you because your payroll department played it safe.
The Marginal Tax Rate Misconception
Most people hear they are in the "24% tax bracket" and assume the government takes 24 cents of every single dollar they earn. That is totally wrong.
Only the money within that specific bracket is taxed at that rate. If you earn one dollar over the threshold into a higher bracket, only that single dollar is taxed at the higher rate. Your overtime isn't "taxed more" in a way that reduces the value of your previous hours. You are always making more money by working more, even if the "marginal" return on that last hour feels a bit smaller because of the bracket jump.
Working overtime will never result in you taking home less total money than if you hadn't worked it. The "it's not worth it because of taxes" argument is a mathematical fallacy.
🔗 Read more: JBS Meatpacking Workers in Iowa: What’s Actually Changing on the Factory Floor
FICA and the Hidden Flat Taxes
While federal income tax varies, other taxes are incredibly consistent. Social Security and Medicare taxes (FICA) are flat.
Social Security is 6.2% and Medicare is 1.45%.
These don't care about your brackets. They take the same percentage from your first hour as they do from your fiftieth hour. If you’re seeing a massive drop in your overtime check, it’s almost always the Federal Income Tax withholding or potentially state taxes if you live in a place like California or New York where state brackets are also progressive and aggressive.
Can You Fix the Withholding?
You actually have some control here. If you know you’re going to be working a massive amount of overtime for a specific season—maybe you’re a retail worker during the holidays or an accountant in the spring—you can adjust your W-4.
The W-4 form tells your employer how much to take out. If you find your refunds are massive every year, you're over-withholding. You can use the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator to figure out how to balance your "allowances" so your paycheck stays more consistent.
But be careful. If you under-withhold to keep more overtime money now, you might end up owing the IRS a check in April. Nobody wants that surprise.
Bonus Pay vs. Overtime Pay
Sometimes people confuse overtime with "supplemental wages." Supplemental wages are things like bonuses, commissions, or back pay.
The IRS actually allows employers to tax supplemental wages at a flat "aggregate" rate of 22%. If your overtime is processed as a "bonus" (which is rare but happens in some odd payroll setups), it might be hit with that flat 22% immediately. Again, this is just withholding. The year-end math remains the same.
The Impact of Local Taxes
If you live in a city with its own income tax (looking at you, Philly and NYC), overtime can feel even heavier. Local taxes often don't have the same nuanced brackets as federal taxes. They just take their cut. When you add up federal, state, local, and FICA, you might see 35% to 40% of your overtime check vanish before it hits your bank account.
📖 Related: Is There Tax on Overtime Now? What Most People Get Wrong
It feels like a gut punch.
Actionable Steps for the Overtime Worker
Don't let the "tax man" scare you away from those extra hours if you need the cash. You are still coming out ahead. To manage the "sticker shock" of your tax bill and maximize your take-home pay, consider these moves:
- Check your W-4: If you consistently get a $3,000 refund every year, you are letting the government hold your overtime pay for free. Update your W-4 to reduce withholding and get that money in your weekly check instead.
- Increase 401(k) Contributions: If you’re worried about overtime pushing you into a higher tax bracket, dump some of that extra cash into a traditional 401(k). This reduces your "taxable income." You’re essentially hiding that overtime money from the IRS while building your own future.
- Track Your Total Annual Income: Don't look at your pay check-to-check. Look at the big picture. Use a simple tax calculator to estimate your total tax liability for the year based on your expected total earnings.
- Review Pay Stubs for Errors: Sometimes payroll departments misclassify overtime as "supplemental," which can trigger higher withholding. Make sure your "time and a half" is being calculated correctly before taxes are even applied.
The reality is that does overtime get taxed more is a question of perspective. On paper, at the end of the year, it's just regular income. On your Friday pay stub, it looks like a robbery. Understanding the difference between withholding and actual tax liability is the key to staying sane when you're grinding out those extra hours. Work the hours, take the money, and just be ready to claim what’s yours when tax season rolls around.