You’re staring at the ceiling. The clock says 2:14 AM. You’ve flipped the pillow to the cool side three times already, but your brain is still running a marathon about that email you forgot to send or that weird thing you said in 2014. Naturally, you think about the fluffiest solution in the book. You start visualizing a white fence. One sheep jumps. Two sheep jump. Three sheep... and suddenly you're wondering if sheep actually like jumping or if their knees hurt.
Does counting sheep work, or have we been sold a pastoral lie for centuries?
The truth is a bit messy. While the image of woolly jumpers is the go-to trope for insomnia in cartoons and children's books, modern sleep science suggests that for most of us, it’s actually a terrible way to catch some Zs. In fact, if you’ve been struggling to drift off, counting might be the very thing keeping your brain in "active mode" instead of letting it slide into the theta waves of early sleep.
The Oxford Study That Ruined the Sheep Myth
Back in 2002, researchers at Oxford University decided to put this old wives' tale to the test. They took a group of people with insomnia and split them into three groups. One group was told to imagine a relaxing, tranquil scene—think waterfalls or a quiet beach. The second group was told to do the classic sheep-counting routine. The third group was the control; they were left to their own devices.
The results were pretty staggering.
The people visualizing the "tranquil scenes" fell asleep about 20 minutes faster than they did on nights they didn't use the technique. But the sheep counters? They actually took longer to fall asleep than they did when they weren't trying any technique at all.
Why? Because counting sheep is boring, but it's also laborious.
Dr. Allison Harvey, who led the study, noted that the task is simply too mundane to occupy the mind enough to keep worrying thoughts away, yet just taxing enough to keep the brain engaged in a rhythmic, active task. It’s a weird middle ground where you aren't relaxed, but you aren't distracted from your anxieties either. You're just doing math in the dark.
✨ Don't miss: Shiatsu Neck and Shoulder Massager Wireless or Wired: What Most People Get Wrong
The Cognitive Shuffle: A Better Way to Trick Your Brain
If you really want to shut your brain down, you need to stop being a mathematician and start being a dreamer. The problem with does counting sheep work as a strategy is that it’s linear. 1, 2, 3, 4. Your brain knows exactly what is coming next. This allows a "background track" of anxiety to keep playing. You can count sheep and still worry about your mortgage at the same time.
Enter the "Cognitive Shuffle," a technique popularized by Dr. Luc Beaudoin.
The goal here is to scramble your thoughts. Sleep happens when the brain moves from logical, linear thinking to nonsensical, fragmented imagery. By forcing your brain to jump between unrelated concepts, you mimic the state of "micro-dreams" that occur right before you pass out.
Try this tonight instead of sheep:
Pick a word, like "BEDTIME."
Take the first letter, B. Imagine a Bear. Then a Balloon. Then a Banjo.
Once you run out of B words, move to E. Elephant. Eagle. Egg.
The key is to visualize the item for a few seconds. See the banjo. What color is the wood? By the time you get to D or T, most people are already under. It’s hard for your brain to maintain a "worry loop" when you are busy trying to think of a word starting with M that isn't "Mortgage."
✨ Don't miss: Why State of Consciousness 2022 Was the Year We Finally Stopped Ignoring Our Brains
Why the Sheep Legend Stuck Around Anyway
It’s actually a bit of a historical mystery. Some scholars point back to old shepherd tales from Islamic culture or even medieval Britain. Imagine a shepherd who had to count his flock every night to make sure none were stolen or lost to wolves. It was a repetitive, necessary task that probably led to some accidental naps in the hay.
Over time, this shifted from a chore into a suggested mental exercise for the masses. But we aren't shepherds anymore. Our stress isn't about stray ewes; it's about dopamine hits and blue light and the 24-hour news cycle. Our brains are much more overstimulated than a medieval peasant's.
The "Over-Effort" Trap
There is a psychological concept called "Performance Anxiety" that applies to sleep. When you focus too hard on the question of does counting sheep work, you are essentially putting pressure on yourself to perform the act of sleeping.
Sleep is one of the few things in life where the harder you try, the less likely you are to succeed. Counting sheep turns sleep into a goal with a progress bar. If you get to sheep number 427 and you’re still awake, you start to get frustrated. That frustration spikes your cortisol. Now you’re stressed because the sheep aren't working.
🔗 Read more: Is 140/80 Blood Pressure Really That Bad? Here is What the New Guidelines Actually Mean
You’ve turned your bed into a boardroom.
What Actually Works (According to Sleep Specialists)
If you’re ditching the flock, what should you actually do? It’s not just about what you think about while lying there; it’s about the environment you’ve built.
1. The 15-Minute Rule
If you have been lying in bed for more than 15 or 20 minutes and you feel restless, get out of bed. Seriously. Go to another room. Keep the lights dim. Read a physical book (nothing with a screen). Only go back to bed when you feel that heavy-lidded "I’m about to drop" feeling. You want your brain to associate the bed with sleep, not with wrestling with imaginary farm animals.
2. Muscle Relaxation
Progressive Muscle Relaxation (PMR) is far more effective than counting. Start at your toes. Tense them as hard as you can for five seconds, then release. Feel the blood flow back in. Move to your calves. Your thighs. Your stomach. By the time you reach your jaw, your body has received a physical signal that it is time to power down.
3. The "Brain Dump"
Often, we can't sleep because we are afraid we will forget something important tomorrow. Keep a notebook (not a phone!) by your bed. Write down the three things you’re worried about. Once they are on paper, your brain feels it has permission to stop "holding" those thoughts.
The Verdict on the Flock
So, does counting sheep work? Honestly, for about 90% of the population, no. It’s too boring to distract you from real stress but too active to let you drift off. It’s a relic of a simpler time.
If you find it soothing, keep doing it. There's no harm in it. But if you’re one of the millions who find themselves frustrated by sheep number 100, give yourself permission to stop.
Actionable Steps to Take Tonight:
- Switch to Imagery: Instead of counting, visualize a familiar path, like a walk through your childhood home or your favorite park. Focus on the details: the smell of the grass, the texture of the front door.
- Try the 4-7-8 Breath: Inhale for 4 seconds, hold for 7, exhale loudly for 8. This physically forces your nervous system out of "fight or flight" and into "rest and digest."
- Lower the Temp: Your body needs its core temperature to drop to initiate sleep. 65°F (18°C) is generally considered the sweet spot.
- Ditch the Clock: Turn your alarm clock around so you can't see the numbers. Knowing it's 3:00 AM does nothing but trigger a panic response.
Forget the sheep. They’re busy anyway. Focus on relaxing your body and scrambling your thoughts, and you’ll find that sleep comes much more naturally than a forced tally ever allowed.