You’re standing in the middle of a crowded Costco warehouse, dodging oversized carts and trying to remember if you actually need that 40-pack of toilet paper. Your kid’s birthday is in two days. Or maybe you just have a massive craving for that specific crunch of chocolate cookies sandwiched between layers of frozen dairy. You head toward the bakery, eyes scanning for those iconic white boxes. But then you pause. Does Costco have ice cream cakes, or are you just remembering a fever dream from a 1990s birthday party?
It’s a common point of confusion. Honestly, the answer depends entirely on what you define as an "ice cream cake" and which country you’re standing in. If you are looking for the classic, custom-decorated sheet cake made of sponge and frosting, Costco is the undisputed king. But the frozen, creamy, Carvel-style treat? That is a whole different story.
The short answer is no—Costco’s legendary bakery does not bake or assemble ice cream cakes in-house. You won't find a "Costco Brand" Kirkland Signature ice cream cake sitting next to the rotisserie chickens. However, that doesn't mean you're walking out empty-handed. Most warehouses stock name-brand options in the freezer section that might actually be better than what you were originally looking for.
The Truth About the Costco Bakery and Frozen Desserts
People get tripped up because the Costco bakery is so famous. We’ve all seen the massive half-sheet cakes. They are cheap. They are huge. They feed about forty people for the price of a fancy lunch. Because these cakes are so ubiquitous, shoppers often assume the bakery handles the frozen stuff too.
They don't.
The bakery staff works with ovens, not industrial freezers. Their specialty is flour, sugar, and heavy buttercream. If you ask a bakery associate for an ice cream cake, they’ll likely point you toward the very back of the store, past the bags of frozen peas and the giant boxes of pizza rolls.
The Reign of the Dairy Queen Contender: Rich’s Carvel Cakes
In the United States, if you’re asking does Costco have ice cream cakes, you’re almost certainly going to find the Carvel Game Ball Ice Cream Cake or the Celebration Whale Cake. These aren't Costco products. They are manufactured by Rich Products Corporation, which owns the Carvel brand.
👉 See also: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong
These cakes are staples. You know the ones—layers of vanilla and chocolate ice cream with those addictive "crunchies" in the middle. At most warehouses, a large Carvel cake will run you significantly less than it would at a grocery store like Kroger or Publix. We're talking maybe $15 to $18 for a cake that serves 10 to 12 people.
But here is the catch. Availability is seasonal and regional. During the summer or around major holidays like the Fourth of July or Father's Day, you might see the "Game Ball" (football-shaped) cake. In the spring, it might be a generic "Celebration" round cake.
Why the Kirkland Signature Ice Cream Cake Doesn't Exist
It’s actually a bit of a mystery why Costco hasn't jumped on this. They have the Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream, which is widely considered one of the best high-fat ice creams on the market. It’s dense. It’s rich. It’s basically begging to be turned into a cake.
Retail experts suggest it comes down to logistics. To make a high-quality ice cream cake at the scale Costco requires, you need a specialized "cold chain" production line that the current bakery setups just aren't built for. Moving a cake from a 350-degree oven to a -10-degree freezer in the same workspace is a food safety and quality control nightmare.
Instead, Costco sticks to what it does best: volume and value through third-party partnerships. By bringing in Carvel or Häagen-Dazs (which occasionally pops up with frozen bars or mini-cake sets), they offload the manufacturing risk while still giving you a bargain.
The International Exception: Australia and Canada
If you’re reading this in Sydney or Toronto, your experience might be different. Costco Australia has been known to carry the Cadbury Ice Cream Cake or regional brands that don't make it to the States.
✨ Don't miss: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessing Over Maybelline SuperStay Skin Tint
In Canada, the selection often leans toward Dairy Queen partnerships or local frozen dessert manufacturers. It’s always worth checking the "Endcap" freezers—those are the displays at the very end of the aisles. That’s where the seasonal "surprise" items live. If a new ice cream cake is going to appear, it’ll be there, not buried in the middle of the frozen fruit section.
What about the Frozen Yogurt?
A common "hack" people talk about is using the food court's frozen yogurt. Back in the day, when Costco sold chocolate and vanilla swirl froyo, people would buy several cups, mash them into a springform pan, and freeze them.
Don't do this.
Modern Costco soft serve (which is now real ice cream in many locations) has a high air content. When you refreeze it at home, it turns into a rock. It loses that creamy mouthfeel and becomes icy and crystalline. It’s a waste of five dollars and a perfectly good afternoon.
How to "Costco-Hack" a Real Ice Cream Cake
Since the warehouse doesn't sell a custom ice cream cake, the pros do it themselves. This is actually the secret to getting a "human-quality" dessert that looks like it cost $60 for about $15.
- Buy the Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream. It comes in a two-pack. You’ll only need one.
- Grab a pack of the Kirkland Chocolate Chip Cookies from the bakery.
- Get the fudge sauce. You basically let the ice cream soften for 10 minutes, crush the cookies, and layer them in a 9x13 pan. Freeze it for four hours. Boom. You have an ice cream cake that tastes significantly better than the pre-packaged Carvel ones because the ingredients are higher quality.
Common Misconceptions About Costco Bakery Orders
I’ve seen people try to fill out the "Special Order" cake slips and write "ICE CREAM" in the notes section. Please, don't be that person. The bakery staff will just call you and tell you they can’t do it.
🔗 Read more: Coach Bag Animal Print: Why These Wild Patterns Actually Work as Neutrals
The order slips are strictly for:
- White Cake with Vanilla Cheesecake Mousse
- Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Mousse
- Specific designs (flowers, rainbows, dinosaurs)
If you need a cake that won't melt in 20 minutes, stick to the bakery. If you absolutely must have that frozen texture, head to the freezer section and look for the blue and red Carvel box.
The Logistics of Transporting Your Frozen Find
If you do find an ice cream cake at Costco, remember that these warehouses are massive. If you pick up the cake at the start of your trip, it’s going to be a puddle by the time you hit the checkout line—especially if you spend thirty minutes looking at the new electronics or trying samples of toasted ravioli.
Pro tip: The freezer section should always be your last stop. Better yet, bring an insulated "green bag" (those thermal bags Costco sells for a few bucks). These cakes aren't packed with dry ice. They are just in a cardboard box. In a warm car, you have about 15 to 20 minutes before the structural integrity of the "crunchy" layer begins to fail.
Final Verdict: What to Do Next
So, does Costco have ice cream cakes? Yes, but they aren't Costco cakes. They are name-brand frozen items found in the freezer aisles, not the bakery.
If you're planning a party and need to make a move, here is your checklist:
- Call your local warehouse. Ask for the "Freezer Lead" and ask if they currently have Carvel cakes in stock. They can check the "item on hand" count in seconds.
- Check the price. Usually, they are around $15.99, which beats the $25+ you'll pay at a standard grocery store.
- Look for the "Game Ball." It's the most common version and usually has the best ratio of ice cream to chocolate bits.
- Clear freezer space first. These boxes are bigger than you think. You don't want to get home with a melting cake only to realize your freezer is full of frozen chicken breasts.
If you really want that high-end, custom experience, your best bet is still heading to an actual Baskin-Robbins or Dairy Queen. But for a budget-friendly crowd-pleaser that you can grab while buying a gallon of maple syrup? Costco's freezer section has you covered.
Make sure to check the "Best By" date on the side of the box. Because these are seasonal items, they sometimes sit in the back of the industrial freezer longer than the milk or bread. A fresh ice cream cake shouldn't have any visible ice crystals on the outside of the frosting. If you see "snow" inside the plastic wrap, put it back and grab the one from the bottom of the stack.