You probably remember the sound of it. That rhythmic, slightly monotone drone of thirty kids reciting the same thirty-one words while staring at a nylon flag in the corner of the room. It’s a staple of American childhood. But honestly, if you haven’t been in a public school building lately, you might wonder if that tradition survived the cultural shifts of the last decade. Do schools still do the pledge of allegiance in an era of heightened political division and legal challenges?
The short answer is yes. Most of them do. But the "how" and the "why" have become incredibly complicated.
It’s not just a matter of tradition anymore. It’s a messy intersection of state law, Supreme Court rulings, and local school board politics. While you might assume the practice is fading away in "blue" states or doubling down in "red" ones, the reality on the ground is a lot more nuanced than the headlines suggest.
The Legal Reality: Can Schools Force Kids to Stand?
Let’s get the big legal hurdle out of the way first. No matter what a state law says, no public school in the United States can legally force a student to recite the Pledge of Allegiance or even stand for it.
This isn't new info. It’s been the law of the land since 1943.
In the middle of World War II, the Supreme Court decided West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette. It was a landmark case involving Jehovah’s Witnesses who believed pledging to a flag was a form of idolatry. Justice Robert Jackson wrote one of the most famous lines in legal history here: "If there is any fixed star in our constitutional constellation, it is that no official, high or petty, can prescribe what shall be orthodox in politics, nationalism, religion, or other matters of opinion."
Basically, the government can't force you to say things you don't believe.
Fast forward to today. Even though do schools still do the pledge of allegiance is a question with a "yes" answer, that "yes" comes with a giant asterisk. In 47 states, there is some kind of law on the books requiring the Pledge to be scheduled. Only Hawaii, Iowa, and Vermont lack specific statutes. But even in the states with strict-sounding laws, like Texas or Florida, students have the right to opt out.
Usually, this requires a written note from a parent. However, even without a note, schools often hesitate to punish students for sitting out because they know they’ll lose in court.
👉 See also: What Really Happened With the Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz
Why the Ritual Still Persists in Most Districts
So, if it’s optional, why do we still do it?
For many administrators, it’s just the path of least resistance. It’s how the school day starts. It’s the "bell ringer." It signals that the day has officially begun. Beyond that, there is immense pressure from local communities. A principal who decides to scrap the morning Pledge isn't just changing the schedule; they’re often inviting a firestorm of emails, school board protests, and local news segments.
Look at Nebraska. In recent years, they updated their requirements to ensure the Pledge is done at least once a day in public schools. The sentiment there—and in many other states—is that the Pledge serves as a "unifying" moment.
But does it actually unify?
Talk to a high school teacher in a metro area, and they’ll tell you a different story. In some classrooms, half the kids are on their phones, three are sitting down in protest of social injustices, and the rest are mumbling through it because they're tired. The ritual exists, but the meaning behind it is in a state of flux.
The Under God Controversy
We can't talk about the Pledge without talking about those two words: "under God."
They weren't always there. Congress added them in 1954 during the Cold War to distinguish the U.S. from "godless communists." Since then, it’s been a magnet for lawsuits. The American Humanist Association and various atheist groups have tried repeatedly to get the phrase removed or to have the Pledge declared unconstitutional in schools.
They’ve mostly failed.
✨ Don't miss: How Much Did Trump Add to the National Debt Explained (Simply)
Courts generally view the Pledge as a form of "ceremonial deism." It’s a fancy legal term that basically says the words have been used so much they’ve lost their specific religious power and are now just "patriotic traditions." Whether you agree with that or not, it’s the reason why the Pledge remains a daily fixture in the vast majority of American schools.
State-by-State Variations: It's a Patchwork
If you move from California to South Carolina, your kid's morning routine might look totally different.
- Florida and Texas: These states have some of the most robust requirements. Florida law requires the Pledge to be recited in every school, though it also requires schools to notify parents that students have the right to opt out.
- California: State law requires a "daily patriotic exercise." The Pledge is the default, but schools have a tiny bit more wiggle room in how they fulfill that requirement.
- The Pacific Northwest: In places like Oregon and Washington, you’ll find more districts where the Pledge is done, but there is a much higher rate of student "non-participation" (sitting down or staying silent) that is generally accepted without comment.
It’s also worth noting that private schools are a whole different ballgame. Since they aren't "state actors," they have much more leeway. A private religious school can absolutely make the Pledge mandatory as a condition of enrollment, whereas a public school cannot.
What Happens When Kids Refuse?
This is where things get "kinda" messy.
While the Supreme Court is clear, individual teachers aren't always up to date on 1940s case law. Every year, there are reports of a student being kicked out of a class or scolded by a substitute teacher for refusing to stand.
In 2017, a student in Texas was expelled for refusing to stand for the Pledge. The family sued, and the state's Attorney General actually intervened to defend the school's right to require a parental note for opting out. These clashes usually end in a settlement or the school backing down, but they highlight the tension.
For many students today, sitting for the Pledge isn't about being "anti-American." It’s often a localized version of the Colin Kaepernick protests. They’re sitting to highlight racial inequality or a lack of "liberty and justice for all," as the poem itself promises.
The Evolution of "Patriotic Exercises"
What’s interesting is how schools are starting to supplement the Pledge.
🔗 Read more: The Galveston Hurricane 1900 Orphanage Story Is More Tragic Than You Realized
Some schools have moved toward a "moment of silence" instead of, or in addition to, the Pledge. This gives kids a chance to pray, meditate, or just stare at their shoes for sixty seconds. It’s less controversial and serves a similar "centering" purpose for the school day.
There's also a growing movement in some districts to include "The Star-Spangled Banner" or even state-specific pledges. In Texas, for example, students recite the Pledge to the Texas flag right after the national one. If you’ve never been to a Texas public school, it’s a bit of a culture shock—"Honor the Texas flag; I pledge allegiance to thee, Texas, one state under God, one and indivisible."
The Global Context (Or Lack Thereof)
Honestly, the U.S. is a bit of an outlier here.
Most Western democracies don't have a daily ritual like this in their school systems. You won't find kids in the UK pledging to a flag every morning, nor in France or Germany. In those countries, such a display would often be seen as uncomfortably nationalistic.
In the U.S., however, the Pledge is seen as a tool for civic education. The idea is that by repeating these words, children will eventually internalize the values of the republic. Critics argue it’s just rote memorization without understanding. Supporters argue it’s a necessary anchor in a country that is incredibly diverse and often divided.
Is the Pledge Disappearing?
If you look at the data and the current legislative trends, the Pledge isn't going anywhere. If anything, several states have moved to strengthen the requirements for the Pledge in the last few years as part of a broader "back to basics" or "patriotic education" push.
However, the experience of the Pledge is definitely changing.
It used to be a universal, unquestioned act. Now, it’s a choice. Even in a room where everyone is standing, there’s an unspoken understanding that they don't have to be. That shift from "mandatory ritual" to "voluntary tradition" is the most significant change in the last fifty years.
Summary of Actionable Insights for Parents and Educators
If you’re navigating this issue right now, here are the ground truths to keep in mind:
- Know the State Law: Check your specific state’s education code. Most states require the school to offer the Pledge, but no state can legally require a student to participate against their will.
- The Opt-Out Process: If you want your child to opt out, the smoothest path is a simple, written note to the administration. This avoids putting the student in a position where they have to argue constitutional law with a teacher.
- Educate on Meaning: Whether a student stands or sits, the Pledge is a great "teachable moment." Discussing the meaning of words like "indivisible" or "republic" makes the exercise more than just a 30-second daily chore.
- Respect Boundaries: For educators, the best approach is to lead the Pledge as required by law but to remain strictly neutral regarding students who choose not to participate. Any form of coercion or public shaming is a direct violation of established First Amendment rights.
The question of do schools still do the pledge of allegiance is less about the words themselves and more about the evolving American identity. It remains one of the few daily rituals that almost every American shares, regardless of whether they’re saying the words or just standing in silence. It’s a 19th-century tradition navigating a 21st-century world, and for now, the flag is still staying in the corner of the classroom.