You’ve probably seen the white smoke or the massive crowds in St. Peter’s Square on the news. It’s easy to assume the guy in the white robe is the "president" of all Christians. But if you actually ask a random person at a church on Sunday, "Hey, do Christians believe in the Pope?" the answer you get will depend entirely on what door you walked into.
Christianity is a huge, messy family. It’s got over 2 billion people. About half of them—the Catholics—view the Pope as their spiritual father. The other half? Well, they range from "he’s a nice guy" to "he’s fundamentally overstepping his bounds."
Why the Pope Matters to Catholics (and Only Some Others)
To understand why this is such a sticking point, you have to look at the job description. For a Roman Catholic, the Pope isn't just a leader. He’s the Vicar of Christ. That’s a fancy way of saying he’s Jesus' representative on Earth. This belief stems from a specific line in the Bible, Matthew 16:18, where Jesus tells Peter, "You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church."
Catholics take this literally. They believe in something called Apostolic Succession. This is the idea that there is an unbroken chain of "hand-offs" from Peter all the way to the current Pope. Because of this, they believe the Pope has "Papal Primacy." He’s the top of the hierarchy.
But here is where it gets spicy: Papal Infallibility.
Most people misunderstand this. It doesn't mean the Pope is a perfect human who never makes a mistake or never sins. Honestly, history is full of Popes who were, frankly, kind of terrible people. Infallibility only kicks in when the Pope speaks ex cathedra (from the chair) to define a specific doctrine on faith or morals. It’s actually only happened a couple of times in history, like when Pope Pius XII defined the Assumption of Mary in 1950.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Siege of Vienna 1683 Still Echoes in European History Today
The Great "No" from Protestants and Orthodox
If you head over to a Baptist, Methodist, or non-denominational church, the vibe is totally different. To them, the idea of one man having ultimate authority over every Christian is a dealbreaker.
Protestants usually lean on a concept called Sola Scriptura. Basically, they believe the Bible is the only infallible authority. If the Pope says something that isn't explicitly in the Bible, a Protestant is going to say, "Thanks, but no thanks." During the Reformation, guys like Martin Luther were pretty harsh about it. They didn't just disagree with the Pope; they thought the whole office was a human invention that distracted people from a direct relationship with God.
Then you have the Eastern Orthodox Christians. These folks are ancient—we're talking roots just as deep as the Catholics. They actually liked the Pope for the first thousand years! But in 1054, everything hit the fan in the "Great Schism."
The Orthodox view is that the Pope is "first among equals." Think of it like a group of friends where one person always picks the restaurant, but they don't actually own the car or the money. They respect the Bishop of Rome as a historic leader, but they reject the idea that he has "universal jurisdiction" to tell a bishop in Greece or Russia what to do.
🔗 Read more: Why the Blue Jordan 13 Retro Still Dominates the Streets
Do Christians Believe in the Pope as a World Leader?
Even if a Christian doesn't believe the Pope is their spiritual boss, they might still respect him. In 2026, the Pope functions almost like a global diplomat for morality.
- Political Influence: He’s the head of Vatican City, an actual country.
- Social Justice: Many Christians who aren't Catholic still admire the Pope's stance on poverty, climate change, or peace.
- Ecumenical Dialog: Groups like the World Council of Churches talk to the Vatican all the time.
However, don't confuse "respect" with "believing in." A Pentecostal might think the Pope is doing great work for the poor but would still never dream of asking him for a blessing. To them, the only "Head of the Church" is Jesus. Period.
The Coptic Pope: The One You Didn't Know About
Just to make things more confusing, there’s actually more than one Pope. The Coptic Orthodox Church in Egypt has its own leader, currently Pope Tawadros II.
If you ask an Egyptian Coptic Christian "do you believe in the Pope," they’ll say yes—but they aren't talking about the guy in Rome. They’re talking about the 118th successor to St. Mark. It’s a good reminder that "Christianity" is way more diverse than what we see on Western television.
💡 You might also like: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
Practical Takeaways for Your Next Conversation
If you're trying to navigate this topic without starting a theological war at Thanksgiving, keep these points in mind:
- Catholics follow him: They believe he has a unique, God-given authority to lead the global church.
- Protestants respect the Bible more: They generally view the Pope as a human leader of a specific denomination, not a divine authority over them.
- Orthodox see him as a brother, not a boss: They recognize his historical importance but refuse to let him make their rules.
- Infallibility is narrow: Even Catholics don't think everything the Pope says is "God’s word." It's a very specific legal-religious tool used rarely.
The best way to understand where someone stands is to look at their source of authority. Is it a person, a book, or a tradition? Usually, if the answer is "the Pope," you're talking to a Catholic.
To dig deeper into how these different groups actually practice their faith day-to-day, your next step is to research the Five Solas of the Reformation. Understanding these five pillars will show you exactly why the divide between Protestant "belief" and Catholic "tradition" remains so wide today.