You’re standing there. The waiter is hovering, pen poised over a tiny notepad, looking at you with that expectant, slightly judgmental "I have four other tables" stare. He asks the question: "And how would you like that prepared?" If you panic and just say "medium," you aren't alone. Most people treat the various levels of steak doneness like a safe middle ground because they’re afraid of blood or, conversely, afraid of chewing on a literal leather belt.
But here’s the thing. Understanding different cooks of steak isn't just about being a food snob. It’s about science. It’s about what happens to myofibrillar proteins and connective tissues when they hit a 500-degree cast-iron surface. If you order a Filet Mignon well-done, you’ve basically paid fifty bucks for a very expensive piece of beef jerky. On the flip side, if you order a fatty Ribeye rare, the fat hasn't had time to render, and you’re basically chewing on cold, rubbery candle wax. It’s gross. Honestly, it is.
Blue Rare: The "Is it Still Mooing?" Stage
Blue rare is polarizing. Some people think it’s the only way to eat meat; others think it’s a health hazard. It’s not. Technically, the internal temperature of a blue steak is somewhere between 115°F and 120°F. The outside is seared—usually very quickly at an incredibly high heat—but the inside remains bright red and barely warm.
Why "blue"? It’s a bit of a misnomer. The meat isn't actually blue, but the oxygen-deprived myoglobin in the center can have a slightly purplish hue before it hits the air.
If you’re eating a lean cut, like a Tenderloin, blue can be incredible because the meat is already soft. But don’t try this with a Wagyu or a heavily marbled strip. You need heat to break down those white flecks of intramuscular fat. Without that heat, you’re losing the very flavor you paid for. It’s a texture thing. Very soft. Very squishy. Very specific.
Why Rare is the Chef’s Secret (Usually)
Rare is the standard. If you ask a high-end chef at a place like Peter Luger or Keens how they recommend a steak, 90% of the time they’ll say rare. We’re talking a cool-to-warm red center and an internal temperature of about 125°F.
The protein fibers are just starting to tighten.
The juices are still locked in.
It’s the peak of tenderness.
💡 You might also like: Human DNA Found in Hot Dogs: What Really Happened and Why You Shouldn’t Panic
However, there is a massive misconception about the "blood" on the plate. It isn't blood. Most blood is removed during the slaughtering process. That red liquid is actually water mixed with myoglobin, a protein that delivers oxygen to the animal's muscles. If you can get past the "bleeding" visual, you realize this is where the most "beefy" flavor lives.
Medium Rare: The Universal Sweet Spot
This is the gold standard for different cooks of steak. If you don't know what to order, order medium-rare. It’s the safe bet for a reason. At 130°F to 135°F, something magical happens to the fat. It starts to melt. It bathes the muscle fibers in flavor.
The center is warm and red, but the edges are starting to turn a nice, firm pink. This is where the Ribeye shines. Because a Ribeye has that massive "eye" of fat and the "cap" (spinalis dorsi), it needs that extra bit of internal heat to transform the gristle into butter.
I’ve seen people argue about this for hours. Some say medium-rare is "overcooked." Those people are usually trying too hard to be edgy. For a thick-cut New York Strip, you want that fat rendered. You want that sear to be deep and crusty—what scientists call the Maillard reaction—while keeping the inside plush.
The No-Man's Land: Medium and Medium-Well
Medium is where we start losing the battle against evaporation. At 140°F to 145°F, the meat is mostly pink with a gray band around the edges. It’s starting to get firm. It’s fine. It’s okay. It’s "safe." But you’re losing moisture.
Medium-well is 150°F to 155°F. There’s a tiny hint of pink in the very center, but it’s mostly gray-brown. To be totally blunt, if you’re ordering high-quality, dry-aged beef medium-well, you’re wasting your money. The dry-aging process is designed to concentrate flavor by losing water weight over 30 to 60 days. By cooking it to medium-well, you’re just drying out what little moisture was left.
A Note on Food Safety and "The Danger Zone"
We have to talk about the USDA for a second. The USDA officially recommends cooking whole cuts of beef to 145°F followed by a three-minute rest. That is, by culinary standards, a medium steak. They do this to ensure that any surface bacteria, like E. coli, are killed off.
But here is the nuance: bacteria lives on the surface.
📖 Related: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
When you sear a steak, you’re killing everything on the outside. That’s why a rare steak is generally considered safe for healthy adults, whereas a rare hamburger is a huge "no-no." Ground beef mixes the surface bacteria throughout the meat. Don't play around with rare burgers. It's not worth the hospital trip. Stick to steaks for the low-temp stuff.
Well-Done: The Controversial Choice
Look, people get really elitist about well-done steak. Anthony Bourdain famously wrote in Kitchen Confidential about how chefs would save the oldest, toughest cuts of meat for the people who ordered well-done because they knew the customer wouldn't be able to tell the difference once it was charred to a crisp.
Is it "wrong"? Food is subjective.
But objectively, once beef hits 160°F+, the protein fibers (actin and myosin) shrink significantly. They squeeze out all the juice. The meat becomes physically shorter and thinner. It’s tough. It’s chewy.
If you absolutely must have your meat cooked through—maybe due to pregnancy or a compromised immune system—pick a cut with a lot of fat. A fatty chuck steak or a skirt steak can handle the heat better than a lean Filet Mignon. If you cook a Filet to well-done, it will have the texture of a hockey puck. You've been warned.
The Resting Phase: The Step Everyone Skips
This is arguably more important than the cook itself. When you take a steak off the grill, the muscle fibers are tight and constricted from the heat. All the juices are being pushed toward the center.
If you cut it immediately?
Whoosh.
👉 See also: God Willing and the Creek Don't Rise: The True Story Behind the Phrase Most People Get Wrong
All that flavor runs out onto your cutting board. It’s gone. You just worked for 20 minutes to get a perfect sear, and you wasted it in five seconds.
You have to let it rest. Give it five to ten minutes. Set a timer. Walk away. During this time, the temperature will actually continue to rise (this is called "carry-over cooking") by about 5 degrees, and the fibers will relax, reabsorbing those juices. When you finally slice into it, the liquid stays in the meat, not on the plate.
Thermal Dynamics and Your Kitchen
If you’re doing this at home, stop poking the meat with your finger to see if it’s done. Unless you’ve cooked ten thousand steaks, your "finger test" is probably wrong. Buy an instant-read digital thermometer. They’re twenty bucks. It is the single most important tool for mastering different cooks of steak.
- Rare: Pull at 120°F (Rests to 125°F)
- Medium-Rare: Pull at 130°F (Rests to 135°F)
- Medium: Pull at 140°F (Rests to 145°F)
- Medium-Well: Pull at 150°F (Rests to 155°F)
The Myth of Searing to "Lock in Juices"
This is a lie. Harold McGee debunked this years ago in On Food and Cooking. Searing doesn't create a waterproof seal. If it did, you wouldn't hear the steak sizzling (which is the sound of moisture escaping and hitting the pan). We sear for the flavor. We sear for the crunch. But the only thing that keeps juices inside is not overcooking it and letting it rest.
Real-World Advice for Your Next Dinner
Next time you’re at a steakhouse, look at the cut before you choose the cook. If it's a Filet, go rare or medium-rare. It’s too lean for anything else. If it's a Ribeye or a Porterhouse, medium-rare is the sweet spot to handle the fat content. If you're dealing with a Hanger steak or Flank steak, don't go past medium, or you’ll be chewing until next Tuesday.
Understanding how to navigate these temperatures changes the experience from just "eating dinner" to actually enjoying the nuances of the beef. It's the difference between a meal and an investment.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Buy a digital meat thermometer: Don't rely on "feel" or "timing" per side. Too many variables like pan thickness and initial meat temp will mess you up.
- Salt early: Salt your steak at least 45 minutes before cooking (or right before hitting the pan). Salting 10 minutes before actually draws moisture out without giving it time to be reabsorbed, which ruins your sear.
- The Room Temp Myth: Don't worry about "bringing the meat to room temperature" for an hour. Serious Eats did the math—it takes way too long to make a difference and just risks bacterial growth. Just cook it cold; it’s fine.
- Check the grain: When you finally eat, look at the direction the muscle fibers are running. Always slice perpendicular to those lines. This breaks up the fibers so your teeth don't have to do the work.