In the world of Taylor Swift, nothing is ever just a coincidence. We know this. We’ve spent years decoding liner notes, counting fence posts in Instagram photos, and pausing music videos at the 1:13 mark. But sometimes, the conversation shifts from lighthearted "Easter egg" hunting into something much more raw, personal, and frankly, heavy.
Lately, a specific question has been haunting the corners of the internet: did taylor swift have a miscarriage?
It’s a question that feels almost too intrusive to type. Yet, if you look at the search data or spend five minutes on Swiftie TikTok, you’ll see it’s everywhere. It didn't start with a tabloid headline or a leaked medical record. It started with a song. Specifically, a haunting 3 a.m. track called "Bigger Than The Whole Sky."
The Song That Sparked a Thousand Theories
When Midnights dropped in October 2022, most of us were ready for sparkly synth-pop and "Anti-Hero" vibes. Then came the 3 a.m. tracks. "Bigger Than The Whole Sky" hit like a physical weight.
The lyrics aren't just sad; they’re specific.
"Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye / You were bigger than the whole sky / You were more than just a short time."
These lines, combined with the crushing refrain—"I’m never gonna meet / What could’ve been, would’ve been / What should’ve been you"—sent shockwaves through the fandom. For anyone who has ever sat in a cold doctor's office and heard the silence where a heartbeat should be, these words weren't just poetry. They were a transcript of their own lives.
Honestly, the reaction was instantaneous. Thousands of women began sharing their own stories of pregnancy loss, using the song as a soundtrack for their grief. It became an anthem for the "1 in 4." But as the personal stories grew, so did the speculation about Taylor herself.
📖 Related: Judge Dana and Keith Cutler: What Most People Get Wrong About TV’s Favorite Legal Couple
What We Actually Know (and What We Don't)
Let’s be real for a second: Taylor Swift has never confirmed that she has had a miscarriage.
She hasn't denied it, either. In fact, she hasn't said anything about the song's specific inspiration at all. This is a woman who usually gives us a "prologue" or a "secret message," but with "Bigger Than The Whole Sky," she’s remained completely silent.
Some fans pointed to her close friend, Claire Winter Kislinger, who had publicly shared her own experience with pregnancy loss around the time the song was written. Taylor is famous for writing about her friends' lives—take "Ronan," for instance, which was written about Maya Thompson’s young son who passed away from cancer. It’s entirely possible that Taylor was simply being a "best friend with a pen," articulating a pain she witnessed but didn't personally live through.
Then came The Tortured Poets Department in 2024.
The speculation flared up again with songs like "loml." While most people see it as a breakup song about Joe Alwyn or Matty Healy, lines about "talking rings and talking cradles" suggest a future that was planned and then violently snatched away.
But does "talking cradles" mean a miscarriage? Not necessarily. It could just as easily be about the death of a dream—the moment you realize you won't be having children with the person you thought was "the one."
The Complexity of Parasocial Grief
It’s kinda weird how we do this, isn't it? We take these three-minute snapshots of a billionaire's life and try to build a medical history out of them.
👉 See also: The Billy Bob Tattoo: What Angelina Jolie Taught Us About Inking Your Ex
There's a fine line between finding comfort in a song and demanding to know the "truth" behind it. The "did taylor swift have a miscarriage" discourse often ignores the fact that Taylor, despite her "The Manuscript" lifestyle, is entitled to a private life.
If she did go through it, the silence is her choice. If she didn't, the song remains a gift to those who did.
Experts in fan culture often talk about E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) in content, but in the world of Swifties, the only "expertise" is how well you know the lore. And the lore tells us that Taylor uses fiction just as often as she uses autobiography. Think about Folklore. She told us flat out that those stories weren't all hers. She was "clambering into the trees" of other people's lives.
Why the Rumors Won't Die
The internet loves a tragedy. It also loves a mystery.
When you combine the two with a global superstar, you get a cycle of speculation that’s impossible to stop. Some fans have even gone back to older songs like "Hoax" or "Peace," looking for clues they might have missed. They point to lyrics like "my barren land" in "Hoax" as evidence.
But here's the thing: Taylor is a writer who loves metaphors. "Barren" can mean a creative drought. It can mean an empty relationship. It can mean a soul that feels hollowed out by public scrutiny.
Assuming it's a literal reference to her reproductive health is a massive leap.
✨ Don't miss: Birth Date of Pope Francis: Why Dec 17 Still Matters for the Church
The Actionable Truth for Fans
If you’re here because you’ve felt a deep connection to those lyrics, the "fact" of whether Taylor experienced it matters less than the fact that she gave you a way to talk about it.
Miscarriage is often treated like a secret. It’s a "wait until 12 weeks to tell anyone" kind of taboo. By releasing a song that mirrors that specific brand of "what-if" grief, Taylor cracked the door open for a lot of people who were suffering in silence.
Whether it was her story or not, the impact is the same.
How to approach the "Bigger Than The Whole Sky" conversation:
- Listen to the music, not the gossip. The power of the song is in the feeling it evokes, not the medical history it might imply.
- Respect the silence. If Taylor hasn't spoken on it, she likely doesn't want to.
- Support others. If you see people sharing their miscarriage stories under the "did taylor swift have a miscarriage" umbrella, offer empathy rather than digging for celebrity tea.
- Recognize the "Short Time" metaphor. Many people use the song for other types of loss—the death of a pet, a friend, or even a version of themselves they lost. That’s the beauty of her songwriting; it’s a shapeshifter.
Ultimately, the answer to did taylor swift have a miscarriage is that we don't know, and we probably never will. And honestly? That's okay. We have the music. We have the communal grieving. We have the "could've, would've, should've" of it all.
Instead of searching for a "confirmed" status, maybe we should just appreciate that one of the most famous people on earth wrote a song that makes the loneliest experience in the world feel a little bit less like a vacuum.
If you or someone you know is struggling with pregnancy loss, reaching out to organizations like Share Pregnancy & Infant Loss Support or the Miscarriage Association is a much more productive next step than refreshing a Taylor Swift theory thread. Grief is real, whether it belongs to a pop star or the person sitting next to you on the bus.