If you’ve been scrolling through Instagram lately and felt like something was... off... on your feed, you aren't alone. The rumors started as a tiny ripple. A deleted photo here. A missing tag there. Then, the unfollow happened. It’s the digital equivalent of throwing someone’s clothes out a second-story window.
So, did Michelle and Aaron break up?
Yeah. They did. Honestly, for fans of The Valley, it feels like the end of an era that barely even started. One minute they’re the "it" couple of Season 2, and the next, insiders are confirming that Michelle Saniei Lally is packing her bags. It’s a lot to process, especially since we watched them navigate the messy aftermath of her divorce from Jesse Lally on national television.
What Really Happened with the Split
This wasn't just some casual "we're taking a break" situation. By July 2024, multiple sources, including People and Us Weekly, confirmed that Michelle and Aaron Nosler had officially called it quits after about a year of dating.
The signs were all over social media before the official PR statements hit. Michelle didn't just hide a few photos; she wiped her grid clean. If you go to her Instagram now, it’s like Aaron never existed. No coffee dates, no hikes, no smiling selfies. Aaron, on the other hand, was a bit slower on the draw, keeping a few memories up for a while, which just made the whole thing feel even more awkward for everyone watching.
The Moving Out Phase
According to reports from July 24, 2025, Michelle was already "in the process of moving out" of the home they shared. That’s a heavy move. Living together usually signals a long-term plan, and they had even talked about the "M" word—marriage.
📖 Related: Joshua Jackson and Katie Holmes: What Really Happened Between the Dawson’s Creek Stars
She’s now reportedly focusing on her daughter, Isabella Bunny, and her career as a real estate agent. It’s a classic "back to basics" move. When a relationship that was supposed to be your "safe harbor" after a public divorce falls apart, you usually just want to hunker down with your kid and your work.
Why Did Michelle and Aaron Break Up?
While neither of them has sat down for a "tell-all" podcast yet, the breadcrumbs are all over Season 2 of The Valley.
Drama with the ex was a huge factor. Jesse Lally isn't exactly a quiet, fade-into-the-background type of guy. During an episode that aired in May 2024, Michelle actually vented to Scheana Shay about the toll Jesse’s behavior was taking on her new romance.
Basically, Aaron reached a breaking point. He told her point-blank: "I love you, I love Isabella... but I can't deal with a crazy ex-husband like that." That’s a heavy ultimatum. He basically said if the drama didn't change, he was out. And since you can't really control an ex-spouse, the writing was pretty much on the wall.
The Rebound Factor
Let’s be real for a second. Michelle and Aaron started dating in October 2023, just shortly after her five-year marriage to Jesse ended. That’s fast.
👉 See also: Joseph Herbert Jr. Explained: Why Jo Koy’s Son Is More Than Just a Punchline
- Timing: They met when Michelle was arguably at her most vulnerable.
- Intensity: They moved in together quickly.
- Pressure: Filming a reality show adds a layer of "performative perfection" that most new couples can't survive.
Some fans on Reddit have been calling it a "rebound romance" since the beginning. Sometimes, the person who helps you get through a breakup isn't the person you're meant to stay with forever. They’re just the bridge to the next version of you.
The Divorce Drama That Won't End
Another reason things might have fizzled? Michelle’s divorce from Jesse actually got stalled.
There was a whole mess where she reportedly filled out the wrong paperwork, meaning the entire legal process had to start over from zero. Imagine trying to build a new life with a boyfriend while your old life is legally stuck in limbo because of a clerical error. It’s enough to make anyone stressed.
Add to that the "tangled web" of their shared finances as real estate partners, and you have a recipe for a relationship headache. Aaron was a financial advisor—he probably saw the math and realized how complicated his life was becoming.
A Tale of Two Michelles
If you arrived here looking for the other famous Michelle—as in, Bachelorette Michelle Young—the news is actually much happier.
✨ Don't miss: John Belushi Death Pictures: What Really Happened at the Chateau Marmont
People often get these two confused because they both had very public breakups with guys named Aaron or Nayte. But as of 2026, Michelle Young is actually married! She tied the knot with Jack Leius in June 2025.
So, if you’re looking for a silver lining in the "did Michelle break up" saga, it’s that one Michelle found her "Jackpot" while the other is still navigating the tricky waters of post-divorce life in the public eye.
What’s Next for Michelle Saniei?
Season 3 of The Valley is reportedly picking up cameras right as this breakup is settling. That means we’re going to see the raw, unedited version of this split.
Michelle is currently prioritizing:
- Co-parenting Isabella: Keeping things stable for her daughter despite the revolving door of partners.
- Real Estate: She’s still a powerhouse in the L.A. market.
- Health: Like her namesake Michelle Young, she’s been vocal about needing to take care of herself physically and mentally.
It’s a tough spot to be in. Being the "villain" or the "victim" in a reality TV narrative is exhausting. For now, Michelle seems content to be solo, navigating a "new chapter" that doesn't involve an ultimatum or a camera crew—at least for a few weeks.
If you’re following this story, keep an eye on her Instagram stories. That’s usually where the real truth comes out before the episodes air. Look for signs of a new apartment or maybe just a lot of "mom and me" content with Isabella. That’s the real focus now.
Check back for updates as Season 3 starts to leak more details about the "moving out" drama. The truth is usually found somewhere between the Instagram unfollow and the first day of filming.