The internet basically exploded on January 20, 2025. One minute, people were watching Donald Trump’s second inauguration festivities, and the next, a single video clip of Elon Musk was being dissected like a Zapruder film. It wasn't about a rocket or a new Tesla feature this time. It was about a hand gesture. Specifically, people were asking: did elon musk give the nazi salute while standing on stage at the Capital One Arena?
The footage shows Musk jumping around, clearly hyped up, before stopping to address the crowd. He thanks them for making the election result happen. Then, he places his hand over his heart and thrusts it upward and outward—straight-armed, palm down. He did it twice. To a huge chunk of the world, that motion looked exactly like a "Heil Hitler" salute. For others, it was just a guy being awkward and expressive.
But when you're the richest man on Earth and you're standing in the center of American power, "awkward" doesn't always cut it as an excuse.
The Moment at the Capital One Arena
Context is everything, but sometimes context just makes things weirder. Musk was at a post-inauguration rally in Washington, D.C. He was riding high on the success of the campaign he’d poured hundreds of millions of dollars into. After a bit of his signature "dad dancing," he got serious for a second.
He told the crowd, "My heart goes out to you. It is thanks to you that the future of civilization is assured." Between these words, he performed the gesture. Hand to heart, then a sharp, diagonal extension of the arm.
Within two hours, Google Trends showed a 500% spike in searches for did elon musk give the nazi salute. It wasn't just a few trolls on X (the platform he literally owns) stirring the pot. Major news outlets and historians were weighing in almost instantly.
👉 See also: Why the Recent Snowfall Western New York State Emergency Was Different
Experts Are Not Agreeing on This One
If you think there's a consensus, you're wrong. The reaction was split right down the middle, often along political lines, but even the "experts" couldn't settle on a single story.
The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) actually came out to defend him at first. They posted on X that it seemed like an "awkward gesture in a moment of enthusiasm, not a Nazi salute." They even asked people to give each other "a bit of grace." Honestly, that didn't sit well with everyone. Critics pointed out that the ADL's own handbook defines the Nazi salute as an outstretched right arm with the palm down.
On the other side, you had heavyweight historians like Ruth Ben-Ghiat from NYU. She didn't mince words, calling it a "Nazi salute and a very belligerent one too." Claire Aubin, a researcher who focuses on Nazism in the U.S., told people to "believe your eyes."
The "Roman Salute" Argument
Musk’s defenders, including his advisor Andrea Stroppa, tried to pivot the narrative. They claimed it was a "Roman salute"—an ancient gesture of honor. Here’s the problem with that: historians say the "Roman salute" isn't actually Roman.
Martin M. Winkler, a classics professor, has written extensively about this. There is zero evidence—no statues, no coins, no writings—that the Romans ever actually saluted this way. The gesture was basically invented for 19th-century stage plays and later adopted by Italian fascists under Mussolini before Hitler took it for the Nazis. So, calling it "Roman" doesn't really distance it from fascism; it just traces the lineage back to where the fascists got it.
✨ Don't miss: Nate Silver Trump Approval Rating: Why the 2026 Numbers Look So Different
Musk’s Own Reaction
Elon didn't exactly apologize. He did what he usually does: he mocked the outrage. He posted on X that his critics need "better dirty tricks" and that the "everyone is Hitler" attack is "sooo tired."
Interestingly, he followed that up with some pretty edgy jokes about the Holocaust, which didn't help his case with Jewish organizations. The Simon Wiesenthal Center expressed "serious concerns," and Masha Pearl of The Blue Card (a charity for Holocaust survivors) called the gesture an "unmistakable symbol of hate."
Why This Keeps Coming Up
This wasn't an isolated incident in the eyes of his critics. They look at the "big picture."
- Musk has previously endorsed "Great Replacement" conspiracy theories on his platform.
- He’s been increasingly vocal in supporting far-right parties in Europe, like the AfD in Germany.
- He has a history of "trolling" that often dances right on the edge of offensive imagery.
In Germany, where Nazi symbols are strictly illegal, the reaction was particularly fierce. Newspapers like Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung argued it was impossible for someone as terminally online as Musk to be unaware of what that gesture looks like.
The Public's Verdict
A YouGov survey conducted shortly after the event showed a perfectly divided public. About 42% of Americans thought it was a "gesture from the heart," while another 42% saw it as a Nazi or Roman salute. Among those who thought it was a Nazi salute, roughly half believed he did it on purpose to signal his views, while 30% thought he was just doing it to "trigger the libs."
🔗 Read more: Weather Forecast Lockport NY: Why Today’s Snow Isn’t Just Hype
Basically, your take on the video probably depends on how you already feel about the guy.
What to Take Away From the Controversy
Whether you think it was a massive "slip of the hand" or a calculated dog whistle, the impact is the same. The event normalized a gesture that has been taboo for eighty years.
If you're trying to figure out the truth for yourself, look at the raw footage—not just the stills. Watch the speed of the arm movement. Listen to the words he says immediately after.
Actionable Insights for the Informed Reader:
- Verify the Source: When seeing clips like this, always look for the full, unedited video to understand the physical momentum of the gesture.
- Understand the Symbolism: Recognize that the "Roman salute" defense is historically flawed; the gesture is tied to 20th-century fascism regardless of the name used.
- Monitor Platform Policies: Keep an eye on how X handles the circulation of these images, as the owner's personal controversies often dictate how "free speech" is applied to sensitive symbols.
- Look for Patterning: Evaluate public figures not on a single frame, but on their long-term associations and the rhetoric they amplify over time.
The debate over whether did elon musk give the nazi salute isn't going away because it’s not just about a hand movement. It’s about what people think he stands for. In a world of high-definition cameras and instant viral takes, even a "moment of enthusiasm" can become a historical marker.