Eleven years. It has been over a decade since Tony Romo lofted that high, arched ball toward the left sideline at Lambeau Field, and honestly, the wound still feels fresh for Dallas fans. If you were watching the 2014 NFC Divisional Round on January 11, 2015, you remember exactly where you were when Dez Bryant leaped over Sam Shields. You remember the three steps. You remember the lunge for the goal line.
And you definitely remember Gene Steratore walking toward the center of the field to tell a national audience that what they just saw didn’t actually happen.
💡 You might also like: NFL Divisional Round Picks: What Most People Get Wrong About This Weekend
The Dez Bryant catch no catch saga isn't just a footnote in NFL history; it’s the moment the league’s rulebook collided head-on with common sense. It’s the play that forced the NFL to admit, years later, that their definition of a catch was basically broken.
The Play That Broke the Internet Before the Internet Was Ready
It was 4th-and-2. The Cowboys were trailing the Green Bay Packers 26-21 with about four and a half minutes left on the clock. Dallas was at the Packers' 32-yard line. This wasn't just a play; it was the play of the season.
Romo took the snap, saw Bryant in single coverage, and let it rip. Dez did what Dez did best—he attacked the ball at its highest point. He secured it, landed on his left foot, then his right foot, and then his left again. As he was going down, he shifted the ball to his left arm and lunged toward the end zone. The ball hit the ground, popped up, and he pinned it against his leg.
Initially, it was ruled a catch at the 1-yard line. Lambeau went silent. Dallas was seconds away from a go-ahead touchdown and a potential trip to the NFC Championship.
Then came the red flag from Mike McCarthy.
Why the NFL Ruled It Incomplete
Dean Blandino, who was the NFL’s Vice President of Officiating at the time, had a rough night on Twitter after that game. The official explanation was based on the "going to the ground" requirement.
Back then, the rule stated that if a player was going to the ground in the act of making a catch, he had to maintain control of the ball throughout the entire process of contacting the ground. Because the ball bobbled slightly when it hit the turf during Dez's lunge, the refs decided he hadn't "completed the process."
Basically, the NFL argued that Dez didn't make a "move common to the game" or establish himself as a runner before hitting the dirt.
But here’s the thing: he took three steps. He switched hands. He reached for the goal line. If reaching for a touchdown isn’t a football move, then what is? The logic felt incredibly circular. The league was essentially punishing a player for being too athletic. Because he tried to score instead of just falling down like a sack of potatoes, he lost the catch entirely.
The Fallout and the "Dez Caught It" Movement
The reaction was instant and visceral. Even players from rival teams couldn't believe it. Odell Beckham Jr. famously tweeted that the call was "a joke."
For years, "Dez Caught It" became a rallying cry. It wasn't just about Cowboys fans being salty—though, trust me, they were. It was about the fact that nobody—not the players, not the coaches, and certainly not the fans—knew what a catch was anymore. Every Sunday became a guessing game of "will the replay booth ruin this highlight?"
This confusion reached a breaking point a few years later with the Jesse James "no catch" for the Steelers against the Patriots. It became clear that the rulebook was out of sync with the physical reality of the sport.
The 2018 Pivot: The NFL Admits They Got It Wrong
It took three years, but the NFL finally blinked. In March 2018, the Competition Committee—which included Cowboys executive Stephen Jones and Packers President Mark Murphy—unanimously approved a simplified catch rule.
They removed the "going to the ground" requirement that haunted Dez. Under the new (and current) rules, a catch is completed if a player:
- Has control of the ball.
- Has two feet (or another body part) down in bounds.
- Performs a football move (such as a third step, reaching for the line to gain, or the ability to perform such an act).
In a moment of rare transparency, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell and the committee essentially used the Dez Bryant play as the "template" for what should be a catch. They admitted that under the 2018 criteria, Dez’s play would have been a completion.
✨ Don't miss: Pittsburgh Steelers vs Arizona Cardinals: Why This Matchup Still Feels Like a Grudge Match
It was a total vindication, but it was three years too late to change the score at Lambeau.
Why It Still Matters Today
The Dez Bryant catch no catch controversy changed how we watch football. It’s why you see referees today being much more hesitant to overturn "bang-bang" plays on the sideline. It shifted the philosophy of officiating from "find a reason to disqualify this" to "let the play on the field stand unless it's a clear error."
It also served as a reminder of how much one officiating decision can alter the trajectory of a franchise. Had that catch stood, Tony Romo might have a ring. Jason Garrett might have had a different legacy in Dallas. Instead, it became the "what if" that defines an entire era of Cowboys football.
What You Should Know About Catch Rules Now
If you’re watching a game today and a similar play happens, remember these three markers to determine if it’s a catch:
- The Third Step: If the receiver gets a third foot down, the "process" is over. It’s a catch, and anything after that is either a fumble or a dead ball.
- The Reach: Reaching for the pylon or the first down marker is now explicitly defined as a "football move."
- Movement of the Ball: A slight shift or "bobble" is okay as long as the player maintains control. The ball touching the ground isn't an automatic incompletion anymore, provided the player doesn't lose his grip because of the contact.
The legacy of the Dez Bryant play is that it forced the NFL to stop being a "rulebook-first" league and start being a "football-first" league. We might never get that 2014 playoff win back, but at least the sport is better for it.
✨ Don't miss: List of Super Bowls and Teams: What Most Fans Get Wrong
To stay ahead of current officiating trends, keep an eye on the NFL Operations weekly officiating videos. They often break down "close calls" from the previous Sunday, showing exactly how the 2018 rule changes are being applied in real-time. If you want to understand the nuance, watch how officials handle the "surviving the ground" aspect during diving catches in the end zone—that’s the last remaining shred of the old rule that still causes headaches today.