People love to talk about the "Slim Reaper" like he’s some kind of fragile glass figurine that’s going to shatter if a 240-pound linebacker looks at him the wrong way. Honestly, it’s been the narrative since he was lighting up the SEC at Alabama. Even after a Heisman and a couple of Super Bowl trips, the skeptics still point at his 170-pound frame and wait for the wheels to come off.
But here’s the thing: they’re wrong.
Basically, DeVonta Smith is the ultimate outlier in a league obsessed with "prototypical" size. While everyone else is looking for the next 6'4" monster who can jump over a skyscraper, Smith is out here systematically dismantling secondaries with better footwork and a higher football IQ than almost anyone in the game. It isn't just about speed; it's about the nuance.
Why the Size Narrative is Total Nonsense
You’ve probably heard it a million times. "He’s too skinny." "He won't last 17 games." Look at the actual data, though. Since entering the league in 2021, Smith has been remarkably durable. He played every single game in his first two seasons. Even in 2024 and 2025, when he dealt with the occasional hamstring tweak or ankle issue, he’s consistently outpaced the "big" receivers in terms of availability.
The reality is that his "slight" build might actually be a defensive mechanism. Think about it. He doesn’t take the massive, squared-up hits that a guy like A.J. Brown takes because defenders can’t actually find enough of him to hit. He’s like a ghost in the secondary.
In the 2025 season alone, DeVonta Smith put up 1,008 receiving yards on 77 catches. That's his third 1,000-yard season in five years. You don't do that by being a "fragile" player. You do that by being a technician.
The Secret Sauce: It’s the Route Running, Stupid
If you watch Smitty closely, his release off the line of scrimmage is basically art. He uses this "diamond" release that leaves cornerbacks reaching at air. Most receivers use their strength to fight through press coverage. Smith? He uses leverage and timing.
✨ Don't miss: Art Donovan: Why This Beer-Drinking Legend Still Matters
- The Hesitation: He makes the DB freeze for just a fraction of a second.
- The Burst: Before they can recover, he’s already three yards deep.
- The Ball Tracking: This is the part that nobody talks about enough. His hands are massive compared to his frame, and he high-points the ball like a guy who’s 6'3".
Take the Super Bowl LIX win against the Chiefs. That 46-yard touchdown he caught—the one they call "The Dagger"—wasn't just a lucky deep ball. He completely manipulated the safety with his eyes, broke his route at the perfect depth, and snatched the ball out of the air before anyone else could react. That’s pure skill.
What Really Happened with the Contracts
A lot of fans were wondering if the Eagles would actually pay a "WR2" top-tier money. In April 2024, Howie Roseman answered that by handing Smith a three-year, $75 million extension. That keeps him in Philly through 2028.
Some "experts" argued that $25 million a year was too much for a guy who shares targets with A.J. Brown. But if you look at the 2026 cap hit of about $10.7 million, it’s actually a brilliant piece of business. The Eagles know that Smith isn't just a "number two." He's a 1A. In many systems, he’d be the undisputed focal point.
🔗 Read more: A qué horas juega el Real Madrid: Horarios confirmados y dónde ver los próximos partidos
The Difference Between Smith and a "High Floor" WR like Jakobi Meyers
People often compare Smith to guys like Jakobi Meyers when talking about reliability. Meyers is great—don't get me wrong. He’s a "first down machine" and a target hog. But Smith has a ceiling that Meyers simply doesn't touch.
Meyers is the guy you want for a 3rd-and-6. Smith is the guy you want when you need to change the scoreboard in one play. His ability to generate explosive plays (20+ yard gains) is significantly higher. In 2025, Smith had nine catches of over 20 yards while playing in an offense that has a lot of mouths to feed.
The Future in Philly (and for Your Fantasy Team)
What should you expect moving forward? Honestly, more of the same, which is a very good thing.
The chemistry between Jalen Hurts and Smith is built on years of trust dating back to their Bama days. As Hurts matures, he’s leaning more on Smith’s ability to find "dead spots" in zone coverage.
- Reliability: He’s averaged over 13 yards per reception throughout his career.
- Touchdown Potential: Even with Saquon Barkley taking red zone carries, Smith’s 31 career touchdowns (as of the end of 2025) prove he’s a scoring threat.
- The "Clutch" Factor: He is the Eagles' all-time leader in postseason receiving yards. Let that sink in for a second. More than Harold Carmichael. More than Alshon Jeffery.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
If you're still doubting him, stop. The "size" issue has been thoroughly debunked by five years of elite production. When evaluating a wideout, look at the separation numbers and the catch radius, not just the weight on the scale.
For those looking at his future, keep an eye on his "situational" stats. He’s actually better on the road and on turf, where his speed is even more apparent. If you're betting on or drafting him, look for those fast-track matchups.
The Slim Reaper isn't going anywhere. He’s just getting started.