Tarik Skubal might be the best pitcher in baseball right now. Two straight Cy Young awards? Check. A sub-2.30 ERA? You bet. But honestly, if you’ve been doom-scrolling through Detroit Tigers MLB rumors lately, you’d think the guy was already packing his bags for Toronto or New York. The noise is deafening.
The spark for this latest fire was a massive, $13 million gap in arbitration filings. Detroit offered $19 million; Skubal’s camp asked for $32 million. It’s the kind of discrepancy that makes fans want to throw their phones. People are panicking because they think a trade is the only way this ends. They’re wrong.
The Reality Behind the Tarik Skubal Trade Buzz
Look, Scott Harris isn't stupid. You don't trade a generational ace just because his agent, Scott Boras, is playing hardball in January. Yes, the Blue Jays have been "urged" by analysts like Sid Seixeiro to make a run at him. Yes, the Dodgers and Yankees are always lurking like sharks. But league insiders, including Mark Feinsand, have been pretty clear: that arbitration gap doesn't actually change the Tigers' stance.
One AL executive recently pointed out that even if the Tigers lose the hearing and have to pay the full $32 million, it might limit their spending elsewhere, but it doesn't force a trade. Skubal is under team control.
The Tigers are coming off a division title. They have +2800 odds to win the World Series. You don’t subtract a Cy Young winner from that equation unless someone offers you the literal moon.
Is Spencer Torkelson Actually the One on the Move?
While everyone is staring at Skubal, there’s a much more realistic trade candidate sitting right at first base. Spencer Torkelson is a enigma. He hit 31 homers last year. That’s elite power. But he also looked completely lost in the ALDS, going 0-for-6 in a winner-take-all Game 5 and striking out four times.
🔗 Read more: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The rumor mill suggests Torkelson’s trade value is actually at a peak right now because of that regular-season power surge. If the Tigers want to upgrade their lineup with a more consistent bat—think someone like Cody Bellinger or even a trade for a Cubs infielder—Torkelson might be the chip they use.
It’s a tough pill to swallow. Tork was the 1-1 pick. He’s supposed to be the cornerstone. But with the way the Tigers struggled to score in the playoffs against the Mariners, Harris might decide that "potential" isn't enough anymore.
Free Agency: The Search for a Veteran Arm
Detroit’s rotation beyond Skubal is... shaky. Reese Olson and Casey Mize have flashes of brilliance, but they aren't exactly 200-inning workhorses yet. That’s why the Detroit Tigers MLB rumors regarding Max Scherzer are so tantalizing.
Imagine Mad Max back in a Tigers uniform. He’s 41 now. He had a 5.19 ERA with the Blue Jays last season. It’s not the 2013 version of Scherzer, but the veteran leadership would be immeasurable.
Other names floating around include:
💡 You might also like: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
- Chris Bassitt: A reliable strikeout guy who could stabilize the middle of the rotation.
- Lucas Giolito: A high-upside play if he can find his old form.
- Justin Verlander: The ultimate "reunion" dream that refuses to die, especially with reports that he’s still drawing interest from several clubs after a strong finish with the Giants.
Honestly, the Tigers probably need two of these guys. They’ve already added Kenley Jansen and Kyle Finnegan to the bullpen, which is great, but a bullpen can’t save you if your starters are out by the fourth inning.
The Kevin McGonigle Factor
If you aren't following the farm system, you’re missing the real story. Kevin McGonigle is a "do-everything" bat. He’s been tearing up the Arizona Fall League and some scouts think he could break camp with the big club.
The Tigers have been surprisingly open about his readiness. ZiPS projections have him as one of the top five hitters on the team already, even with limited Double-A experience. If McGonigle or Max Clark forces their way onto the roster, it changes everything about how the Tigers approach the trade deadline.
What Most People Get Wrong About Scott Harris
There’s this narrative that the Tigers are "cheap" or "scared" to spend. They didn't even sniff the Alex Bregman market before he signed with the Cubs for $175 million. But if you look at the international signings—like the $2.3 million they just dropped on Venezuelan catcher Manuel Bolivar—it’s clear the money is there. They’re just being selective.
They aren't going to overpay for a 30-year-old third baseman when they have McGonigle and Hao-Yu Lee knocking on the door. It’s about the "window." The window is open now, but they want it to stay open for a decade.
📖 Related: Mizzou 2024 Football Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
Actionable Insights for Tigers Fans
If you're trying to keep up with the chaos, stop looking at the national headlines and start watching the smaller moves. Here is what actually matters for the next few weeks:
- Watch the Arbitration Hearing: If they settle before the hearing, the "Skubal trade" rumors will die instantly. If they go to the hearing, expect another week of frantic tweets.
- Monitor the First Base Market: If Detroit doesn't sign a veteran power hitter soon, the odds of Torkelson staying put go up significantly.
- Spring Training Plate Appearances: Keep a close eye on McGonigle’s strikeout rate in Lakeland. If he’s hovering around 12-15%, he’s making the team.
- The Starting Pitching "Second Tier": Forget the $200 million arms. Watch for 1-2 year deals for guys like Brandon Woodruff or Shane Bieber. That is the Scott Harris sweet spot.
The Tigers aren't in a rebuild anymore. They’re in a "refinement" phase. It’s frustrating because it’s slow, but the bones of a champion are there. You just have to look past the arbitration noise to see it.
Check the spring training schedule. If the Tigers don't add a veteran starter by the time pitchers and catchers report, the pressure on Mize and Olson becomes the biggest story in Detroit.
Next Steps: You should keep an eye on the upcoming arbitration hearing dates; usually, these conclude by early February. If no settlement is reached by then, the "financial gap" narrative will likely dominate the headlines until Opening Day. Additionally, monitor the waiver wire for any veteran outfielders the Tigers might snag to provide a safety net for Max Clark’s development.