You've probably seen the photos. Those dramatic side-by-sides where a face cratered with acne scars suddenly looks like polished marble. It's tempting. Honestly, it looks like magic. But if you’re looking at dermabrasion before and after scar results, you need to know that what happens between those two photos is a messy, bloody, and surprisingly intense medical process. It’s not a spa day. It’s a "sand your face down with a high-speed power tool" day.
I've seen people go into this thinking it’s basically just a strong facial. It isn’t. Dermabrasion is a surgical procedure. We’re talking about a motorized brush or a diamond-tipped fraise spinning at thousands of revolutions per minute to literally grate away the upper layers of your skin. The goal is simple: controlled injury. By wounding the skin deeply enough, you force the body to replace that scar tissue with smoother, more organized collagen.
Does it work? Yes. But the "after" doesn't happen in a week. It takes months.
The gritty reality of dermabrasion before and after scar transformations
When we talk about "scars," we’re usually talking about two things: acne pits (atrophic scars) or surgical/traumatic marks. Dermabrasion is the heavyweight champion for the deep stuff. While lasers like Fraxel or CO2 get all the marketing love these days, many old-school dermatologists still swear by manual dermabrasion for "ice pick" scars or the "rolling" indents that lasers sometimes just graze over.
Here is the thing about the transition. Immediately after the procedure, you don't look like a success story. You look like you fell off a motorcycle and slid face-first across the pavement. Your skin will be raw. It will weep. You’ll be covered in specialized ointment and bandages for days. This is the "raw meat" phase, and it's why people hide in their houses for two weeks.
💡 You might also like: That Weird Feeling in Knee No Pain: What Your Body Is Actually Trying to Tell You
Why depth matters more than anything else
The trick—and the danger—of dermabrasion is the depth of the "wound." If the doctor goes too shallow, you’ve wasted your money and a lot of pain for zero result. If they go too deep? You end up with even worse scarring or permanent pigment loss. This is why you see such a massive variance in dermabrasion before and after scar galleries. The skill of the surgeon’s hand determines if you get "baby skin" or a "hypopigmented patch" that never tans again.
Dr. Harold Brody, a legend in the world of chemical peels and resurfacing, has often pointed out that dermabrasion is an art of tactile feedback. The surgeon feels the resistance of the scar tissue. Lasers are precise, but they don't "feel" the skin. That's why dermabrasion is still the gold standard for perioral rhytids (those deep lines around the mouth) and certain types of jagged scarring.
The healing timeline: A messy middle
Day 1 to 7 is the "what have I done?" phase. Your face is swollen. It’s red. You’re applying thick layers of petroleum jelly or Aquaphor every few hours because if that skin dries out and scabs over, you’re in trouble. Scabs lead to more scars. You want "wet healing."
By day 10, the new skin is usually there. It’s pink. Like, "just-slapped" pink. This is where the dermabrasion before and after scar photos usually skip ahead. But in reality, that pinkness (erythema) can last for three months. Sometimes six. You'll look like you have a permanent sunburn. If you go out in the sun without SPF 50 during this time? Forget it. You’ll develop hyperpigmentation, and the "after" photo will look worse than the "before."
📖 Related: Does Birth Control Pill Expire? What You Need to Know Before Taking an Old Pack
- Week 2: You can usually wear makeup. Specific, heavy-duty camouflage makeup.
- Month 1: The swelling is mostly gone. You start to see the scar edges softening.
- Month 6: The final result. The collagen has remodeled. The pinkness is gone.
The dark side of the "After"
Let’s be real: it doesn’t work for everyone. If you have a darker skin tone (Fitzpatrick scale IV through VI), most reputable surgeons will tell you to stay away from dermabrasion. The risk of permanent "ghosting"—where the treated area turns white and never recovers its color—is just too high. For those patients, chemical peels or microneedling are usually the safer, albeit slower, route.
Also, it won't fix everything. Deep "ice pick" scars often need "punch excisions" (where the doctor literally cuts the scar out with a tiny cookie cutter) before the dermabrasion even starts. If you expect a 100% smooth surface, you're going to be disappointed. Aim for 50% to 70% improvement. That sounds low, but on a face, 50% smoother skin is life-changing.
Costs, Pain, and the "Is it worth it?" Factor
It’s not cheap. You’re looking at anywhere from $1,500 to $4,000 depending on the size of the area and if you're being put under general anesthesia. Most people need local anesthesia with some "twilight" sedation because, frankly, the sound of the motor and the sensation of the friction is enough to make anyone squirm.
Is it worth it? Honestly, it depends on your psychology. If you’ve spent years hiding your face because of acne scars, then two weeks of looking like a burn victim is a small price to pay. But if you’re just looking to "brighten up" your complexion, this is overkill. You’re using a sledgehammer to hang a picture frame.
👉 See also: X Ray on Hand: What Your Doctor is Actually Looking For
Myths vs. Reality
People confuse dermabrasion with microdermabrasion all the time. They are not even in the same universe. Microdermabrasion is like a light scrub; it’s what you get at a mall. Dermabrasion is surgery. Don't let a "medspa" do this to you. If there isn't a board-certified dermatologist or plastic surgeon holding the tool, run away.
Another myth is that it’s a "one and done" for everyone. While usually true for deep scars, some people with severe texture issues might end up doing a second, lighter pass a year later.
Actionable steps for your "After"
If you are serious about pursuing a dermabrasion before and after scar transformation, stop looking at Instagram and start doing the following:
- Consult a "Scar Specialist": Not just a general plastic surgeon. You want someone who specializes in resurfacing. Ask how many dermabrasions they perform a month. If it's less than two, they might be out of practice with the manual technique.
- Prep your skin: Many doctors want you on a Retin-A or hydroquinone regimen for weeks before the procedure to "prime" the skin cells and minimize pigment issues.
- Clear your calendar: You cannot go to a wedding, a meeting, or a date for at least 10 to 14 days. Period.
- Buy the supplies early: Get the gentle cleansers, the huge tubs of ointment, and the ice packs ready. You won't want to be seen in a CVS three days post-op.
- Manage expectations: Look at your deepest scar. Imagine it half as deep. If you would be happy with that, proceed. If you need it to be gone entirely, you might be chasing a ghost.
The real "after" is found in the texture you feel when you wash your face in the shower. It’s the lack of shadows when you stand under harsh fluorescent lights. It takes grit to get there, but for the right candidate, the results remain the gold standard in a world full of over-hyped lasers.