Football rivalries are usually about geography or divisional hate. You’ve got the Ravens and Steelers beating each other's brains out twice a year, or the Broncos and Raiders trading barbs since the AFL days. But the Denver Broncos vs Pittsburgh Steelers rivalry is different. It’s an "appointment" rivalry. It’s the kind of matchup that only happens every few years, yet when it does, the stakes are almost always high enough to make your heart skip.
Think about it. These two teams have met eight times in the postseason. That is a massive number for teams that aren't even in the same division. Most franchises don't see their own rivals that often in January.
The Stat That Stings in the Steel City
If you ask a casual fan which team has historically dominated the AFC, they’ll probably point to Pittsburgh. Six Super Bowl rings tend to do that for your reputation. But here is the kicker: Denver is one of the very few teams that actually has a winning record against the Steelers.
Honestly, it drives Pittsburgh fans crazy.
Across 35 total meetings, the Broncos hold a 20-14-1 lead. Even more impressive? Denver is 5-3 against them in the playoffs. While the Steelers were building the "Steel Curtain" legacy in the 70s, Denver’s "Orange Crush" was right there, handing them a 34-21 exit in the 1977 Divisional Round. It was Denver’s first-ever playoff appearance. Talk about making an entrance.
Why the Mile High Advantage is Real
Playing in Denver isn't just a cliché about thin air. It’s a nightmare for the black and gold. The Steelers are 8-7 at home against Denver, but when they travel to the Rockies, things fall apart. They are 6-13-1 all-time in Denver.
🔗 Read more: Inter Miami vs Toronto: What Really Happened in Their Recent Clashes
13-4-1 if you only count regular season games at Mile High.
The most recent chapter in 2024 saw the Steelers finally bucking the trend with a gritty 13-6 win, but historically, the altitude and the crowd noise have acted like a 12th man for the Broncos.
Tim Tebow and the 11-Second Heartbreak
You can’t talk about Denver Broncos vs Pittsburgh Steelers without mentioning 2011. It is legally required at this point.
The Steelers came into that Wild Card game as 12-4 heavyweights. Denver was an 8-8 squad that had basically stumbled into the playoffs behind the "Tebow Magic" phenomenon. Everyone—and I mean everyone—expected Pittsburgh to steamroll them.
Then came the first play of overtime.
💡 You might also like: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
Tim Tebow dropped back, hit Demaryius Thomas on a slant, and Thomas took it 80 yards to the house. Eleven seconds. That’s all it took. It remains one of the most shocking upsets in NFL history because it defied every logic-based metric we had at the time.
The New Era: Bo Nix vs The Steel City Defense
Fast forward to the present. The 2024 matchup was a defensive slog that felt more like a 1920s wrestling match than a modern football game. It highlighted exactly where these two franchises are right now.
Pittsburgh is currently in a "Standard" transition. With Mike Tomlin recently stepping away after nearly two decades of never having a losing season, the Steelers are searching for a new identity. They still have T.J. Watt, who remains a terrifying human being for any offensive tackle to block, but the offensive side is a revolving door of "what ifs."
On the other side, Sean Payton is trying to mold Bo Nix into the next franchise cornerstone.
Nix’s debut against the Steelers was a "welcome to the NFL" moment he’d probably like to forget. He threw two interceptions and struggled to find rhythm against a Pittsburgh defensive front that barely blitzed. In fact, the Steelers only blitzed on 7% of plays in that game—the lowest in the league that week—and still harassed Nix all afternoon.
📖 Related: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
Tactical Differences in 2026
By 2026, this matchup looks entirely different. The rosters have shifted significantly:
- The Quarterback Room: Pittsburgh has moved on from the Russell Wilson/Justin Fields experiment, leaning into new faces like Will Howard and even veteran Aaron Rodgers taking a late-career swing in the black and gold.
- Denver's Weapons: The Broncos have surrounded Nix with young speed, specifically Marvin Mims Jr. and rookie standouts like Pat Bryant.
- Defensive Philosophies: Denver under Vance Joseph is hyper-aggressive. They blitzed nearly 47% of the time in their last meeting. Pittsburgh, under their new leadership, maintains that classic "bend but don't break" zone-heavy scheme.
What to Watch for in the Next Matchup
If you’re betting on the next time these two meet, look at the turnover margin. It sounds like a "football 101" coaching point, but for these two specific teams, it’s the only stat that matters.
Over the last few seasons, the Steelers are almost unbeatable (29-7) when they win or tie the turnover battle. When they lose it? They are 0-15-1. Denver, meanwhile, has been plagued by red-zone turnovers that stall out Sean Payton’s scripted drives.
The "Orange Crush" and the "Steel Curtain" may be names from the past, but the physical, defensive identity of this rivalry hasn't changed. It's going to be low-scoring. It's going to be loud. And more likely than not, it’s going to be decided by a single mistake in the fourth quarter.
To prep for the next clash, keep an eye on Denver's offensive line development. If they can't handle the four-man rush from Pittsburgh's front, Nix (or whoever is under center) won't have the time to exploit the Steelers' secondary, regardless of how much talent they have at wideout. Monitor the injury reports for T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith; when those two are healthy, the Steelers' win percentage jumps by nearly 20 points. On the Denver side, watch the progression of corner Pat Surtain II. His ability to erase a team's WR1 is the only reason Denver’s aggressive blitzing scheme doesn't get burned deep every play.