Everyone thought Sean Payton had finally lost it. When the Denver Broncos took Bo Nix with the 12th overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, the collective groan from the national media was loud enough to be heard from the top of Pikes Peak. He was the sixth quarterback taken. Critics called him a "reach." They said he was just a check-down king who benefited from a gimmicky Oregon system.
They were wrong.
By the time the 2024 season wrapped up, the narrative hadn't just shifted; it had been completely demolished. The denver broncos quarterbacks 2024 room, which started the year as a massive question mark following the expensive divorce from Russell Wilson, ended the season as the foundation of a franchise resurgence. Denver didn't just find a starter; they found a record-breaker who led them back to the postseason for the first time since 2015.
The "Secret Formula" and the Rise of Bo Nix
If you want to understand why Sean Payton was so smug during the draft, you have to look at the data he was hiding. Payton uses a specific, almost obsessive, formula to evaluate quarterback processing. It’s the same one he used to scout Patrick Mahomes back in 2017.
Basically, he measures the rate of negative plays—sacks, fumbles, and interceptions—against total drop-backs. Most rookies fail this test miserably. Caleb Williams and Drake Maye had numbers that made Payton nervous. Bo Nix, however, posted a 6.8% average. That’s elite. It meant that even in college, Nix was making decisions faster than almost anyone else on the board.
It didn't take long for that to translate. Nix won the starting job in training camp, beating out Jarrett Stidham and Zach Wilson. He became the first Broncos rookie since John Elway in 1983 to start Week 1.
The early weeks were... well, they were "rookie" weeks. He threw two picks in a loss to Seattle. He looked a bit sped up. But Payton stayed patient, and Nix rewarded him by becoming a statistical monster as the weather got colder.
Breaking the Record Books
Nix didn't just "manage" games. He dominated them. Look at these numbers from his 17-game regular season:
- 3,775 passing yards (A Broncos rookie record).
- 29 passing touchdowns (Another rookie record).
- 376 completions (You guessed it, another record).
- 34 total touchdowns when you factor in his legs.
The real "I told you so" moment came in Week 18 against the Kansas City Chiefs. Nix went 26-of-29 for 321 yards and four scores. That 89.7% completion rate is the highest ever recorded by a rookie quarterback in NFL history with at least 25 attempts. He didn't just beat the Chiefs; he carved them up like a Thanksgiving turkey.
The Guys Who Didn't Play: Stidham and Wilson
While Bo Nix was the star of the show, the denver broncos quarterbacks 2024 depth chart was actually surprisingly stable. For years, Denver was a revolving door of "has-beens" and "never-weres." In 2024, they actually had competent insurance.
Jarrett Stidham spent the entire year in the "break glass in case of emergency" role. Honestly, that’s a tough gig for a guy who started games at the end of 2023. But Payton valued Stidham’s knowledge of the system. He was the veteran voice in the headset, helping Nix navigate defensive looks. Stidham didn't see meaningful action until garbage time in that Week 18 blowout, but his presence was vital for the culture in that room.
Then there was the Zach Wilson experiment. Denver traded for the former Jets high-pick as a low-risk, high-reward project. He never saw the field in 2024. But in a weird way, that was a win for Denver. It meant the starter was healthy and performing. Wilson was essentially in "QB rehab," learning how to play the position without the pressure of being the savior of a New York franchise.
The Complexity of the Payton-Nix Marriage
It wasn't all sunshine. There were games, like the Week 3 win against Tampa Bay, where Nix was still learning the "NFL speed." He struggled with deep ball accuracy early on. Critics pointed to his 6.7 yards per attempt and claimed he was "too safe."
But that was by design. Payton’s offense is built on timing and rhythm—what he calls "boring" football. It’s about getting the ball out in under 2.5 seconds to guys like Courtland Sutton, who had a massive 1,000-yard season.
By mid-season, the "safe" label disappeared. Nix started hitting Marvin Mims Jr. on deep shots. He became a legitimate rushing threat, tallying 430 yards on the ground. He wasn't just a system quarterback; he was the system.
What This Means for the Future
The 10-7 record and the playoff berth changed everything in Denver. The "dead money" from the Russell Wilson era still exists, but it doesn't feel like a millstone anymore.
Denver has its guy.
The 2024 season proved that Sean Payton’s "eye" for talent hasn't dimmed. He found a player who fits his brain—a high-processor who doesn't take sacks and doesn't turn the ball over.
💡 You might also like: Finding the Best Views: The Seat Map Toyota Center Secrets You Need to Know
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
If you're looking at where this team goes next, keep an eye on these specific trends:
- Draft Strategy: Since the QB spot is solidified, expect Denver to go "all-in" on playmakers. Nix needs more than just Sutton. Look for them to target a high-end "Y" receiver in the next cycle.
- The "Processing" Metric: Watch other teams try to mimic Payton’s scouting formula. The league is shifting away from "raw traits" and back toward "fast eyes."
- Stidham’s Future: With Nix established, Stidham becomes a valuable trade chip or a high-end backup. Denver will likely keep him for one more year to ensure Nix has that veteran support during his "sophomore" jump.
The era of the "QB Carousel" in Denver is officially over. Bo Nix didn't just start 17 games; he claimed the city. For the first time since Peyton Manning rode off into the sunset, Broncos Country has a reason to stop looking at mock drafts and start looking at the standings.
Next Steps for Denver:
To capitalize on this momentum, the front office must prioritize offensive line depth and a secondary vertical threat. Nix proved he can handle the volume; now he needs the weaponry to compete with the likes of Mahomes and Allen in the AFC arms race. Keep a close watch on the 2025 free agency period, as Denver will likely be a much more attractive destination for veteran wideouts now that the quarterback question is finally answered.