Honestly, if you’re still thinking about Premier League defending as just "stopping goals," you’re living in 2015. The game has shifted so much lately that the center-backs are basically the new playmakers, and the full-backs? They’re practically wingers who happen to track back once in a while.
We’ve seen some wild stuff this 2025/26 season. Teams are abandoning that super-slow, "pass-it-to-death" build-up and going vertical. Fast.
It's weird because for years we were told that long balls were dead. Now, according to data from the first half of the season, direct speed metrics are through the roof. If you’re one of the defenders in Premier League squads right now, you aren't just expected to win a header; you’ve got to be a quarterback.
The Stat-Heads vs. The Eye Test
Most fans look at clean sheets and think that’s the whole story. It isn't. Not even close.
Take William Saliba at Arsenal. The guy is a freak. He’s currently sitting in the 95th percentile for ground duel success. But it's his "boring" stats that actually matter. He’s only making about 4 clearances a game, which sounds low until you realize Arsenal never lets the ball get near their box anyway. They've conceded only 3 goals in some stretches this year, which is just stupidly good.
Then you have the Ruben Dias situation at Manchester City. He’s been level with Sunderland’s Omar Alderete on the Squawka Score—around 74%—which is basically as high as it gets for a center-half. But here’s the kicker: City just lost Dias to a hamstring issue and Josko Gvardiol to a broken leg.
That is a disaster.
Gvardiol was averaging 2.5 points per game for City when he started next to Dias. Without them? City’s win rate literally falls off a cliff. They’ve been averaging 1.16 points per match when that duo is broken up. It sort of proves that even with all the tactical genius in the world, if your big men at the back are out, you're in trouble.
💡 You might also like: Current Score of the Steelers Game: Why the 30-6 Texans Blowout Changed Everything
The Rise of the Randoms
If you told me two years ago that a Sunderland defender would be outperforming almost everyone, I’d have laughed. But Alderete has been colossal. He’s averaging nearly 6 clearances per 90 minutes.
That’s what’s great about the league right now. You don't have to be at a "Big Six" club to be world-class. Malick Thiaw at Newcastle is another one. He’s winning 75% of his aerial duels. You basically can't cross the ball near him. He’s been a massive reason why Newcastle is hovering around those European spots again.
Why Technical Skill Is Killing the Traditional "Hard Man"
Remember the days of the 6'4" defender who just wanted to kick people? Those guys are gone. Or they’re on the bench.
Nowadays, if you can’t complete a line-breaking pass, you're a liability. Look at Trevoh Chalobah at Chelsea. He’s been averaging over 5 passes into the final third per game. For a defender! That’s more than some creative midfielders were doing a decade ago.
And then there's the speed. Abdukodir Khusanov at City recently clocked a top speed of 35.7km/h. That’s faster than Erling Haaland.
Think about that.
The guy tasked with marking the fastest striker in the world is actually faster than him. It’s an arms race. If you’re a slow defender in this league, you’re basically a target for every 19-year-old winger with a point to prove.
📖 Related: Last Match Man City: Why Newcastle Couldn't Stop the Semenyo Surge
Full-Backs or Secret Wingers?
We have to talk about Jurrien Timber. He’s finally healthy and has basically pushed Ben White out of the starting XI at Arsenal.
Timber has 2 goals and 4 assists already this year. He’s essentially a right-winger who starts from deep. It’s the same with Achraf Hakimi or Rayan Aït-Nouri. These guys aren't "defenders" in the way your dad remembers them. They are engine rooms.
The Tactical Shift Nobody Noticed
Arne Slot at Liverpool has been having a bit of a weird time with this. While Virgil van Dijk is still the king of defensive headers—he’s got over 210 already this season—the team is struggling against the "long ball resurgence."
Basically, teams are realizing that if you press Liverpool high, they’ll just ping it over your head.
It’s making the life of defenders in Premier League teams much more chaotic. You have to be ready to sprint 40 yards back toward your own goal at any second because a keeper like Nick Pope or David Raya has spotted a run and launched a 60-yard missile.
Speaking of Raya, he’s currently leading the league with 10 clean sheets. But he’s also wandering about 18 yards away from his goal line on average. It’s high-risk, high-reward stuff.
What Actually Matters for the Title Race
Arsenal is currently 6 points clear as we hit the mid-point of January 2026. Why? Because of their defensive perfection.
👉 See also: Cowboys Score: Why Dallas Just Can't Finish the Job When it Matters
They don't make mistakes.
While teams like Everton have made 9 errors leading to shots, Arsenal has made... one. Just one. That’s the difference between fighting for a trophy and fighting for your life at the bottom of the table.
City is "hunting" them, as some pundits put it, but with Dias and Gvardiol out, Pep is having to use Nathan Ake and the young Max Alleyne. Ake is reliable, but he hasn't quite got that same telepathic connection with the rest of the backline yet.
Actionable Insights for the Rest of the Season
If you're watching the games or playing FPL, keep an eye on these specific shifts:
- Watch the Aerial Success Rates: Players like Van Dijk and Thiaw are becoming more valuable as teams go more direct. If a team can't win their headers, they’ll get bullied by the new "vertical" tactics.
- Track Recovery Pace: In a league where defenders like Khusanov are hitting 35km/h+, "positioning" isn't enough anymore. You need raw recovery speed.
- Focus on Error-Prone Teams: The gap between Arsenal (1 error) and Everton (9 errors) is where the league is won and lost.
- Monitor the Injury Lists: Manchester City’s title charge literally depends on how fast Gvardiol and Dias get back. Without them, the "Points Per Game" drop is too steep to ignore.
The standard of defenders in Premier League football has never been higher, but the demands have never been more ridiculous. You have to be a sprinter, a playmaker, and a brick wall all at once. If you blink, you're on the highlights reel for all the wrong reasons.
Next Step: Check out the upcoming match between City and Brighton. It'll be the ultimate test of whether City's makeshift defense can handle a team that loves to exploit those high-line vulnerabilities.