If you’ve ever sat in the dark of a theater—or even just sat at your laptop—watching a teenager in a striped blue polo have a complete emotional breakdown, you’ve felt the shadow of Evan Hansen. It’s a role that doesn't just ask for a good singing voice; it demands a literal pound of flesh. Honestly, playing Evan is basically a marathon where you’re crying the whole time.
The lineage of dear evan hansen actors is a weirdly exclusive club. It’s a group of young men who took on a role that became a cultural phenomenon, for better or for worse. From the original Broadway cast to the West End and the controversial movie, the people behind these characters have had some pretty wild trajectories. Some became massive movie stars, and others found that the weight of the cast (the literal one on their arm) was a lot harder to shake off than they expected.
The Ben Platt Era: Legend or Controversy?
You can’t talk about this show without starting with Ben Platt. He didn't just play the role; he was the role for an entire generation of "Fansens." When the show opened at the Music Box Theatre in late 2016, the buzz was deafening. Platt’s performance was visceral. He had this specific way of making his voice crack—a mix of anxiety and raw talent—that earned him a Tony Award and turned him into a household name overnight.
But things got complicated.
When the movie adaptation was announced in 2021, the decision to cast a 27-year-old Platt as a high schooler sparked a firestorm. People on TikTok weren't kind. The makeup and digital de-aging felt "uncanny valley" to many. While director Stephen Chbosky insisted that Platt’s understanding of the character was irreplaceable, the internet largely disagreed. It’s a classic case of a performance that worked perfectly under the warm glow of stage lights but felt "off" under the cold precision of a 4k camera lens.
📖 Related: Who Really Made the Gunga Din Movie Cast a Hollywood Legend
The Broadway Successors: More Than Just Replacements
After Platt left, the show didn't just fold. It became a revolving door of incredible talent. Each of the dear evan hansen actors brought a totally different energy to the role, which is kind of rare for a show that feels so tied to its originator.
- Noah Galvin: He took over right after Platt. Galvin brought a sharper, maybe slightly more cynical edge to Evan. He’s gone on to have a massive career in shows like The Good Doctor and films like Theater Camp.
- Taylor Trensch: His Evan felt more fragile, almost like he was actually going to shatter on stage.
- Andrew Barth Feldman: This is the one people still talk about. He was literally a teenager—plucked from the Jimmy Awards (high school theater's Oscars) at age 16 to lead a multi-million dollar Broadway show. Imagine going from homeroom to a Broadway dressing room. He later starred opposite Jennifer Lawrence in No Hard Feelings, proving there’s life after the blue polo.
- Jordan Fisher: He made history as the first Black actor to play Evan on Broadway. Fisher brought a pop-star vocal quality and a deep, soulful charisma that made the character feel fresh again right before the pandemic hit.
The West End Connection
Across the pond, Sam Tutty became the face of the show in London. He was only 22 when he won the Laurence Olivier Award for Best Actor in a Leading Role. Much like Feldman, Tutty was a relative unknown who became a superstar because he could tap into that specific brand of "Evan" loneliness.
The Families: Who Kept the Show Grounded?
It wasn't just the Evans. The supporting cast usually stays in their roles much longer than the leads, and they’re the ones who really built the world.
👉 See also: Oscar for Best Animated Film: Why Everyone Is Talking About KPop Demon Hunters
Rachel Bay Jones, who played Heidi Hansen (the mom), is a legend in the theater community. Her performance of "So Big / So Small" is basically the gold standard for how to make an entire audience sob. She stayed with the show through its peak, eventually winning a Tony.
Then you have the Murphys. Mike Faist, who originated Connor Murphy, is now a legitimate movie star. If you saw Steven Spielberg’s West Side Story or the tennis drama Challengers, you saw Mike Faist. He has this intense, brooding energy that translated perfectly from the "ghost" of Connor Murphy to the big screen.
The Reality of "Evan-ing"
It’s worth mentioning that being one of the dear evan hansen actors is physically brutal. The role is infamous for being one of the most taxing in musical theater history.
Evan is on stage for almost the entire show. He’s singing high-tenor power ballads while hyperventilating. He’s crying in every other scene. Several actors have spoken out about the toll it took on their mental health and their vocal cords. It’s a "marathon" role that requires a strict regimen of steaming, silence, and physical therapy.
Honestly, the "Dear Evan Hansen" experience is as much a feat of athleticism as it is acting.
What’s the Legacy?
As we look at the cast lists from 2016 through the closing in 2022, the show’s impact on the industry is undeniable. It launched the careers of people who are now the faces of Hollywood and Broadway.
Even if the movie was a bit of a stumble, the stage show remains a touchstone. Whether you love the story or find the character’s choices questionable (and let’s be real, Evan does some pretty terrible things), the actors who occupied that space did something extraordinary. They made us care about a kid who felt invisible.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans:
If you want to dive deeper into the world of these performers, check out the original Broadway cast recording to hear Ben Platt and Rachel Bay Jones at their peak. For a different vibe, look up Andrew Barth Feldman’s "Broadway Whodunnit" or watch Mike Faist’s breakout film performances to see how a stage actor transitions to the screen. You can also track the 2024-2025 UK tour schedules if you want to see a new generation of Evans take the stage in person.