You've probably got that one yellow and black drill sitting in a dusty hard-shell case in the garage. It’s a tank. You’ve dropped it off a ladder, used it to stir thin-set, and maybe even hammered a loose nail with the back of it. But when you go to pull the trigger, nothing happens. Or worse, it groans for three seconds and then gives up the ghost. Usually, the culprit is the DC9098 DeWalt 18V battery.
It's frustrating. These tools were built to last thirty years, but the battery technology inside them—specifically the Nickel-Cadmium (NiCad) chemistry—was never meant to live that long.
Honestly, the DC9098 is a bit of a relic. It’s part of the old "post-style" or "stem-mount" system that DeWalt dominated the market with for decades. If you’re still trying to find an original, genuine DeWalt-branded NiCad pack at a big-box store today, you're going to have a hard time. They officially discontinued the line a few years back. Now, we’re living in a world of third-party replacements and lithium adapters.
The Chemistry Problem Nobody Tells You About
Why do these batteries fail so consistently compared to the ones in your phone or your new 20V Max impact driver? It comes down to "memory effect" and crystal growth.
NiCad batteries like the DC9098 are picky. If you don't fully discharge them before popping them back on the charger, they "forget" their full capacity. Basically, the battery starts thinking that the 40% mark is actually zero. Over time, your 1.3Ah or 2.0Ah battery starts acting like a 0.5Ah battery.
Then there are the dendrites. These are tiny, microscopic metallic "spikes" that grow inside the cells. Eventually, they poke through the internal separator and create a short circuit. This is why you’ll pull a battery off the charger, and it feels hot but shows 0 volts on a multimeter. It’s internally bleeding out.
DC9098 vs DC9096: Does the Number Matter?
You'll see a lot of people asking if they can swap a DC9098 for a DC9096 or a DC9099. The short answer? Yes.
The DC9098 was traditionally the "compact" version. It was lighter and smaller, which made your drill less top-heavy when you were working overhead. The tradeoff was runtime. The DC9096 was the "XRP" (Extended Runtime) version. It’s physically taller and heavier because it has more cells inside.
Think of it like a fuel tank. A DC9098 is a 10-gallon tank; the DC9096 is a 20-gallon tank. Both use the same 18V "fuel," and both fit the same "engine" (your tool). If you don't mind the extra pound of weight, buying a DC9096 replacement for your DC9098-equipped tool is actually a massive upgrade in how many holes you can drill before stopping.
The 2026 Reality: Should You Buy a Replacement?
If you’re looking to get that old circular saw or reciprocating saw back in the game, you have three real options. None of them are perfect.
🔗 Read more: Substack: Why Everyone Is Suddenly a Newsletter Writer
1. The Third-Party NiCad/NiMH Route
You can go on Amazon or eBay and find "knock-off" batteries for twenty bucks. They usually claim 5.0Ah capacity, which is almost always a lie. You can't physically fit 5.0Ah of NiCad cells into that plastic housing. However, they're cheap. If you only use the tool twice a year to hang a picture frame, these are fine. Just don't leave them on the charger for a week, or they might melt.
2. The Lithium-Ion "Conversion" Packs
Some companies now make a DC9098-shaped shell filled with 18650 lithium cells. These are great because they don't have a memory effect. But there's a catch: you usually cannot use your original DeWalt black-and-silver charger. Lithium cells require a different charging profile. If you put a lithium replacement in an old NiCad charger, it could literally explode. Always check if the battery comes with its own dedicated charger.
3. The DCA1820 Adapter (The Pro Choice)
This is what most contractors did when DeWalt moved to the 20V Max system. You buy a plastic adapter that slides into your 18V tool. Then, you slide a modern 20V Max (which is actually 18V nominal) lithium battery into the adapter.
It’s the smartest move for most people. You get modern power, less weight, and you can share batteries with new tools. But—and this is a big "but"—you have to take the battery out of the adapter when you're done. The adapter has a small internal circuit that will slowly drain your battery to zero if left connected overnight. I've seen people ruin $100 batteries because they left them in the adapter on a Saturday and came back Monday to a "dead" brick.
Can You Actually "Shock" a Dead DC9098 Back to Life?
You might have seen those "zapping" videos on YouTube. Someone takes a welder or a high-voltage power supply and sparks the terminals of a dead battery.
Does it work? Sometimes.
Is it a permanent fix? No.
🔗 Read more: Trojan:Win32/Susgen.300983: Why Your Antivirus is Probably Freaking Out Over Nothing
What you’re doing is using high current to "burn" those metallic dendrites I mentioned earlier. It’s like blowing a fuse. It might clear the short and let the battery take a charge again, but the underlying chemistry is still degraded. It’s a "get me through the rest of the job" fix, not a "it's as good as new" fix. Also, it’s dangerous. Batteries store energy, and forced discharge can lead to acid leaks or fire.
Why Your Charger Is Blinking Like Crazy
If your charger is giving you that rapid-fire red blink (the "Broken Battery" signal), it’s usually because the voltage has dropped too low for the charger to recognize it. Most DeWalt chargers won't start the cycle if the pack is below about 10 or 12 volts.
A common trick is to "jump" the dead battery. You take a fully charged battery and use two pieces of copper wire to connect the positive-to-positive and negative-to-negative for about 30 seconds. This transfers just enough surface charge to the dead DC9098 to trick the charger into starting. It’s a classic MacGyver move that actually works more often than you'd think.
Making the Decision
If you’re a professional and your living depends on these tools, stop buying NiCad replacements. The technology is dead. Get the DCA1820 adapter and move into the 20V Max ecosystem. The weight savings alone will save your wrists by the end of the day.
For the DIYer who just loves the feel of their old 18V drill, look for a reputable NiMH (Nickel Metal Hydride) replacement. NiMH is a "cleaner" version of NiCad. It has more capacity and is slightly less prone to memory effect, but it still works with your old chargers.
💡 You might also like: Digital Maps: Why Your Phone Still Gets It Wrong
Actionable Steps for Your DC9098 Battery:
- Check the Voltage: Use a multimeter. If it’s reading 0V, you likely have a shorted cell. If it's reading 14V-16V, it's just "tired" and might benefit from a few full charge/discharge cycles.
- Store it Right: Never store your 18V batteries in the garage during winter. NiCad hates extreme cold. Bring them inside the house.
- Label Your Packs: Use a silver Sharpie to write the date of purchase on the bottom. These batteries usually last 3–5 years. If yours is from 2018, it’s earned its retirement.
- Recycle, Don't Trash: Cadmium is nasty stuff. It’s a heavy metal that shouldn't be in a landfill. Most Home Depot or Lowe's locations have a Call2Recycle bin at the front of the store specifically for these old power tool packs.
The DC9098 was a workhorse that helped build millions of homes. It's okay to let it go. Whether you choose to adapt, replace, or finally upgrade to the newer brushless lines, those old tools are still capable—they just need a better "heart" to keep beating.