Finding the right person to jump off a roof and hit a CGI monster with a golden lasso is harder than it looks. Most people just pick a pretty actress and call it a day. But if you’re looking at a dc wonder girl fancast, you have to understand the mess of the source material first. We aren’t just talking about one girl. We’re talking about a legacy that spans decades, different timelines, and three very distinct personalities that often get lumped together by casual fans.
James Gunn is out here rebuilding the entire DCU from scratch. He’s already got his Superman in David Corenswet and a Supergirl in Milly Alcock. But the Wonder Woman side of things? It’s a bit of a ghost town. While we know a prequel series called Paradise Lost is coming to HBO, the actual mantle of Wonder Girl remains wide open. Honestly, the choices the internet keeps making for Donna, Cassie, and Yara are starting to feel a little stale.
The Donna Troy Problem: More Than Just a Diana Lookalike
Donna Troy is the original. She’s the founding member of the Teen Titans and, quite frankly, has one of the most confusing backstories in comic book history. Is she a magical clone? An orphan saved from a fire? A titan of myth? It depends on which week you ask DC.
For a dc wonder girl fancast targeting Donna, you need someone who can carry the weight of being a leader. She isn't just a sidekick; she’s often the emotional glue of the Titans.
- Liza Soberano: This is a name that’s been picking up serious steam lately. She has that classic, ethereal look, but after seeing her in Lisa Frankenstein, it’s clear she has the range. She can be sweet, but there’s a sharpness there that Donna needs.
- Adria Arjona: Now, a lot of people want her for Diana Prince. I get it. She’s stunning and has that "warrior" energy. But if Gunn goes for an older Wonder Woman, Arjona might actually be the perfect "older sister" figure as Donna.
- Naomi Scott: She’s been in the conversation for years. She has the franchise experience from Aladdin and Power Rangers. She's a safe bet, maybe a bit too safe, but she can definitely handle the stunt work.
The biggest mistake fans make is casting Donna too young. If she’s going to be a contemporary of Nightwing, she needs to look like she’s in her mid-20s. Casting a teenager just to fit a "girl" label ruins the dynamic.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
Why Cassie Sandsmark Needs a Total Rebrand
Cassie is the one with the attitude. The daughter of Zeus. The girl who spent years trying to live up to a legacy she didn't always want. If Donna is the responsible older sister, Cassie is the rebellious middle child who listens to punk rock and punches holes in tanks.
Most people fancast McKenna Grace here. I love her work, I really do. But is she a Cassie? Maybe five years ago. Now, we need someone who can play that specific "Young Justice" energy.
- Millie Gibson: You might know her from Doctor Who. She has that perfect blend of "I'm just a kid" and "I will end you." Cassie is often portrayed as a blonde, and while hair dye exists, Gibson’s natural vibe fits the more modern, slightly bratty but heroic version of the character.
- Kathryn Newton: She’s already done the Marvel thing with Ant-Man, but she’s basically the human embodiment of Cassie Sandsmark. She’s got the athletic build and that specific "mean girl who is actually a hero" face.
- Megan Charpentier: A deeper cut, but she’s been a fan favorite on Reddit for a while. She has a grounded quality that could work if Gunn decides to make the DCU feel a bit more "real" and less like a Saturday morning cartoon.
The Yara Flor Factor: The Future of the Mantle
Yara Flor is the new kid on the block. Created by Joëlle Jones, she’s a Brazilian Amazon with a personality that is—bluntly—exhausting in the best way possible. She’s arrogant, hilarious, and rides a pegasus named Jerry. You can’t just cast any actress for Yara; she has to be Brazilian, or at least Latina with that specific fire.
The internet usually screams for Bruna Marquezine. And look, she was great in Blue Beetle. She’s Brazilian royalty. It’s the easiest win in history. But because she’s already played Jenny Kord, would Gunn double-cast her? Probably not. It’s a shame, honestly.
🔗 Read more: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
If not Bruna, where do we go? Some people suggest Xochitl Gomez, but she’s tied up with America Chavez over at Marvel. The reality is that for Yara Flor, DC might need to do an open casting call in South America. We need a fresh face who isn't carrying the baggage of three other franchises.
Breaking Down the DCU Timeline
Here is the thing. James Gunn is starting his universe with a pre-existing Bat-family. Damian Wayne is Robin. That means Dick Grayson is already Nightwing. If Dick is Nightwing, Donna Troy should already be a grown woman.
If the DCU follows this logic, a dc wonder girl fancast shouldn't be looking for 16-year-olds for Donna. We should be looking at actresses in their late 20s. This leaves the "Wonder Girl" title open for Cassie or Yara to take over in the modern day.
Imagine a movie where Donna Troy is basically retired or operating as "Troia," and she has to mentor a young, chaotic Cassie Sandsmark. That’s a movie I’d actually pay to see. It’s much more interesting than another origin story about someone finding a magic belt in a museum.
💡 You might also like: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
What DC Actually Needs to Do Next
If you're following the news, the script for the new Wonder Woman film is currently being penned by Ana Nogueira. She’s the same writer who did Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow. This is a huge sign. It means they are looking for high-concept, emotional storytelling, not just "hit the bad guy."
- Prioritize Chemistry: Whoever gets cast as Wonder Girl needs to have a screen test with the future Wonder Woman. The sisterly bond is the most important part of the character.
- Don't Fear the Costume: We’ve had enough "grounded" superhero suits. Give us the stars, the red jumpsuits, and the golden lassos.
- Diversity of Background: With Yara Flor especially, DC has a chance to represent a culture that rarely gets the spotlight in superhero films. Don't waste it by casting someone who "looks the part" but has no connection to the heritage.
Stop looking for "mini-Gal Gadots." The next Wonder Girl needs to be her own person. Whether it's the regal Donna, the fiery Cassie, or the chaotic Yara, the DCU has a chance to finally get the Amazons right.
To stay ahead of the curve, keep an eye on the casting calls for Paradise Lost. While it's a prequel, the actresses cast as the ancient Amazons will likely set the "look" for whoever eventually takes on the mantle of Wonder Girl in the present day. If they cast a specific demographic for the Bana-Mighdall tribe, that might give us a massive hint about whether Yara Flor is in the works sooner rather than later.