He wasn't a "Big." He wasn't some high-powered architect or a guy with a signature cocktail and a penthouse. Steve Brady was just a bartender with a thick Queens accent and a corduroy jacket. When we talk about David Eigenberg Sex and the City history, we’re talking about a character who fundamentally broke the show’s original DNA. Initially, the HBO hit was a fantasy. It was about chasing the unattainable in a pair of Manolo Blahniks. Then Steve walked in, asked Miranda for a beer, and suddenly the show had to deal with the messy reality of "normal" guys.
Honestly, Steve Brady shouldn't have lasted. He was originally meant to be a one-off or a short-term romantic hurdle for Miranda Hobbes. But David Eigenberg brought something to the role that the writers couldn't ignore: a genuine, puppy-dog vulnerability that acted as the perfect foil to Miranda’s razor-sharp cynicism. He became the emotional anchor of a show that often drifted into the stratosphere of high fashion and higher stakes.
The Evolution of David Eigenberg in the Sex and the City Universe
It’s been decades. People still have heated debates over brunch about whether Steve was "good enough" for Miranda. It’s wild. Most actors would kill for that kind of longevity in the public consciousness. Eigenberg didn't just play a boyfriend; he played a shift in the cultural zeitgeist. He represented the "soft man" before that was even a trendy term. He cried. He wanted to cuddle. He bought a bar called Scout because he had a dream, not because he had a venture capital firm backing him.
The chemistry between Eigenberg and Cynthia Nixon was the show's secret weapon. While Carrie and Big were busy playing mind games for six seasons, Steve and Miranda were doing the hard work. They were dealing with unplanned pregnancies, laundry, and the terrifying prospect of moving to Brooklyn. It’s funny how Brooklyn was treated like a foreign country in 2004. Now, it’s the height of cool, but Steve was the one who dragged the show across the bridge.
David Eigenberg’s performance is actually quite subtle if you look back at the early seasons. He uses his physicality—that slightly slumped shoulder, the way he looks up through his eyelashes—to show a man who knows he’s punching above his weight class intellectually but doesn't care because he knows he has more heart.
Why the Fans Turned (and Why They Came Back)
Then came the first movie. The cheating scandal.
If you want to see a fanbase go nuclear, mention the Steve-cheats-on-Miranda plotline. It felt like a betrayal of the character's core. Steve was the loyal one! He was the guy who waited! Eigenberg played those scenes with a devastating sense of shame. He didn't make Steve a villain; he made him a human who messed up because he felt neglected. It was uncomfortable to watch because it felt too real for a glamorized rom-com.
But then came And Just Like That... and things got even weirder.
The revival series took Steve Brady and, in the eyes of many fans, did him dirty. They gave him hearing aids—which, to be fair, reflects David Eigenberg’s real-life hearing loss—but they also made him seem somewhat "checked out." The vibrant, scrappy bartender was suddenly a guy eating ice cream on the couch while his wife explored a new life with someone else.
The Real-Life Impact of David Eigenberg's Health on the Script
It's rare for a show to write an actor's actual physical ailments into the script, but that’s exactly what happened with the revival. David Eigenberg has been open about his hearing loss. Instead of hiding it with clever editing or tiny earpieces, the showrunners decided to make it part of Steve’s story.
👉 See also: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
This decision was polarizing. Some viewers felt it was a beautiful representation of aging. Others felt it was a way to "dim" Steve so that Miranda's departure felt more justified. Regardless of where you stand, Eigenberg’s willingness to be that vulnerable on screen is a testament to his craft. He isn't interested in being the "cool guy." He’s interested in being the real guy.
He once mentioned in an interview that he didn't realize how much the fans loved Steve until he started getting stopped on the street by people angry at Miranda. That’s the power of the David Eigenberg Sex and the City legacy. He became a surrogate for every guy who felt like he was trying his best but still falling short of some impossible standard.
Steve Brady vs. The "Alpha" Male
If you look at the roster of men on the show, it's a graveyard of egos.
- Mr. Big: Emotionally unavailable until the literal last minute.
- Aiden Shaw: Great, but perhaps too granola for the New York grit.
- Harry Goldenblatt: The only other "real" contender for best husband.
- Berger: The Post-it note guy. Enough said.
Steve was different. He was the only one who truly challenged the women's perceptions of class. Miranda was a high-powered partner at a law firm. Steve was... Steve. He represented the "low-status" male who offered high-status emotional intelligence. That’s a rare archetype in late 90s television.
The brilliance of Eigenberg’s casting is that he doesn't look like a model. He looks like a guy you’d actually see in a bar in Queens. He has a lived-in face. That authenticity is why, even when the writing for his character got shaky in the later years, the audience stayed fiercely protective of him. You don't protect Big. You watch Big. You protect Steve.
The Brooklyn Effect
We have to talk about the house. The brownstone.
When Steve convinced Miranda to buy that dilapidated house in Brooklyn, it was a turning point for the series. It signaled the end of the "single in the city" era and the beginning of the "building a life" era. Eigenberg played those scenes with a quiet persistence. He wasn't demanding; he was just right. He saw the future before Miranda did.
Breaking Down the David Eigenberg Style
What makes him a great actor? It’s the "in-between" moments. It’s the way he reacts when he’s not the one talking.
In the scene where Miranda tells him she’s pregnant, look at his face. There’s a flicker of about six different emotions: terror, joy, confusion, and finally, a sort of resolute "okay, let’s do this." He doesn't need a three-page monologue to tell you what Steve is thinking. He does it with a squint.
✨ Don't miss: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
Contrast this with his work on Chicago Fire as Christopher Herrmann. It’s a completely different vibe, yet that same "everyman" DNA is there. He’s the salt of the earth. He’s the guy you want in your corner when things go south. This consistency has made David Eigenberg one of the most reliable character actors in Hollywood.
The Steve Brady Redemption Arc
Despite the rocky road in And Just Like That..., Steve remains a fan favorite. Why? Because he’s the only character who hasn't really changed his soul. Carrie is still searching, Charlotte is still perfecting, and Miranda is... well, Miranda is reinventing. But Steve? Steve is still there. He’s still a dad. He’s still hardworking. He still loves his kid.
There’s a comfort in that.
In a world of "pivoting" and "disrupting," Steve Brady is a constant. David Eigenberg has managed to maintain that dignity for over twenty-five years. That’s not just good acting; that’s a deep understanding of who this person is at their core.
What Most People Get Wrong About Steve
The biggest misconception is that Steve was "weak."
People mistake his kindness for a lack of ambition. But Steve was the one who opened a successful bar in a cutthroat New York market. He was the one who cared for his mother as she descended into dementia. He was the one who had the strength to stay when things got boring.
Strength isn't always about winning an argument or making the most money. Sometimes, it’s about being the person who holds the towel while someone else vomits. Steve was that guy. Eigenberg never played him as a doormat; he played him as a man who chose his battles.
Actionable Takeaways from the Steve Brady Playbook
If you’re looking to apply some "Steve Brady energy" to your own life—minus the cheating and the hearing loss drama—here is how you do it.
Embrace the "Soft" Skills
In your career and relationships, don't underestimate the power of being the person who actually listens. Steve’s bar wasn't successful because he made the best martinis; it was because people felt seen when they sat across from him.
🔗 Read more: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
Don't Fear the Bridge
Miranda was terrified of Brooklyn because it represented a loss of status. Steve saw it as an opportunity for growth. Don't let your ego stop you from making a move that actually improves your quality of life.
Accountability is Key
When Steve messed up, he owned it. He didn't make excuses (okay, maybe a few, but he eventually faced the music). In a world of ghosting and gaslighting, being the person who says "I failed, and I’m sorry" is a superpower.
Stay Grounded
Despite being surrounded by the glitz and glamour of Manhattan’s elite, Steve never tried to be anyone else. He kept his accent. He kept his interests. Authenticity is the ultimate long-game strategy.
Final Thoughts on the Legacy
David Eigenberg’s contribution to the cultural phenomenon of Sex and the City cannot be overstated. He provided the friction necessary to make the show’s themes of love and independence actually mean something. Without Steve, Miranda’s arc would have been significantly less compelling.
He reminded us that sometimes the person you end up with isn't the person you put on your vision board. They’re the person who shows up at your door with a six-pack of beer and a genuine smile.
To truly appreciate the character, you have to look past the "aw shucks" exterior and see the man underneath. Steve Brady was the heart of the show, even when the show forgot it. And David Eigenberg was the only actor who could have pulled that off with such grace.
If you want to revisit his best moments, start with Season 4, Episode 18 ("I Heart NY"). The scene by the bridge is a masterclass in understated romantic acting. It’s not about the words; it’s about the silence between them. That is the essence of Steve Brady. That is the essence of David Eigenberg.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Re-watch the "Scout" opening episodes to see Steve's entrepreneurial side.
- Follow David Eigenberg's current work on Chicago Fire to see how he’s evolved the "everyman" archetype.
- Consider how the portrayal of aging and disability in And Just Like That... changed your perspective on the characters you grew up with.