Honestly, it’s rare to see a show get the desert right. Most Westerns or crime dramas treat the American Southwest like a flat, orange postcard, but Dark Winds Season 1 feels different. It feels heavy. When the series first dropped on AMC in 2022, it wasn't just another police procedural filling a slot; it was an adaptation of Tony Hillerman’s iconic "Leaphorn & Chee" books that people had been waiting decades to see done properly. Produced by heavyweights like George R.R. Martin and Robert Redford, the stakes were high. It had to be good.
The show takes us back to 1971. That’s a specific vibe.
What Actually Happens in Dark Winds Season 1?
The plot kicks off with a double murder at a motel and a high-stakes armored truck robbery in Gallup, New Mexico. It seems like two separate things. It’s not. Lieutenant Joe Leaphorn, played by the incredible Zahn McClarnon, is a man who carries the weight of his community and his own personal tragedies on his shoulders. He’s Navajo Police. He knows the land. But he’s forced to work with Jim Chee, a young deputy who’s been away at university and is secretly working for the FBI.
The tension isn't just about the "who-dun-it." It's about the "where-are-you-from."
Leaphorn is cynical. He’s seen the Bureau mess things up before. Chee is caught between two worlds, trying to prove his worth to an FBI that mostly views him as a tool. Kiowa Gordon brings a sort of nervous, modern energy to Chee that contrasts perfectly with McClarnon’s stillness. The mystery itself—involving a group called the Buffalo Society—is actually based on the real-world tensions of the 1970s, specifically the American Indian Movement and the radicalism of that era.
The Layers of the Story
It’s easy to get lost in the heist. The helicopter escape in the first episode is visceral. But the show spends just as much time on a medical clinic run by Leaphorn’s wife, Emma. This is where the show gets brave. It touches on the horrific reality of forced sterilizations of Indigenous women, a dark chapter of American history that isn't talked about enough in mainstream media.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
- The Buffalo Society isn't just a gang of thieves.
- The FBI’s involvement is messy and often obstructive.
- The "Witch" or Diné spiritual elements aren't just spooky window dressing; they represent the psychological state of the characters.
You’ve got a series that refuses to be simple. One minute you're watching a standard foot chase through the brush, and the next, you're sitting in a quiet hogan discussing the philosophy of balance and the "Beauty Way."
Why Dark Winds Season 1 Hits Different
Most crime shows rely on a "case of the week" format. Dark Winds Season 1 doesn't do that. It’s a six-episode arc that breathes. It allows the wind—that actual, howling dark wind—to be a character. The cinematography by Guy Godfree is stunning. He captures the scale of the Navajo Nation, which spans over 27,000 square miles. You feel the isolation. If a car breaks down out there, you’re basically on another planet.
Director Chris Eyre, who did Smoke Signals, knows how to frame these actors. There is a specific pacing to the dialogue. People don't always talk just to fill the silence. Sometimes they just look.
Let’s talk about Zahn McClarnon for a second. The man is a powerhouse. You might know him from Fargo or Westworld, but here, he’s the lead. He has this way of expressing grief without saying a word. His son died in an explosion at a local oil site, and that trauma is the engine of his character. He isn't just solving a robbery; he's trying to find some sort of justice in a world that feels rigged against his people.
Accuracy and the Writer’s Room
One reason the show feels so authentic is the room. The writers' room for the first season was entirely Native American. This matters. It’s the difference between a character being a "stoic Indian" trope and being a real human with a sense of humor, a family, and a complex relationship with their culture. They get the small things right—the way people tease each other, the specific cadence of English spoken on the Rez, and the reverence for elders like Hosteen Tso.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
The Cultural Impact of the First Season
When the finale aired, it left a lot of people reeling. The resolution of the Buffalo Society plotline wasn't a clean, "everyone goes to jail" ending. It was bloody and complicated. It asked questions about what justice looks like when the legal system is fundamentally broken.
The show also boosted interest in Tony Hillerman’s work, though it’s worth noting the show makes significant changes. In the books, Leaphorn is the older, more "rational" one, while Chee is the one more in touch with traditional Navajo beliefs. The show swaps some of these dynamics or blends them, making Leaphorn more of a bridge between the two.
What People Get Wrong About the Show
A lot of viewers go in expecting Longmire or Yellowstone. It isn't that. It’s noir. It’s dark, moody, and occasionally supernatural. Or is it? That’s the brilliance of the writing. It leaves just enough room for you to wonder if the "curse" being discussed is a literal spiritual force or just the manifestation of human greed and evil.
- Is it a horror show? No, but it has moments that feel like a thriller.
- Do I need to read the books first? Definitely not. The show stands on its own.
- Is it historically accurate? Mostly. While the specific heist is fictional, the political climate of 1971 is captured perfectly.
Critical Insights for New Viewers
If you’re just starting Dark Winds Season 1, pay attention to the background characters. Bernadette Manuelito, played by Jessica Matten, is arguably the most competent person on the force. Her journey throughout the season is just as compelling as Leaphorn’s. She represents the future of the Navajo Police, balancing duty with the reality of being a woman in a male-dominated field during the 70s.
The tension between Leaphorn and Whitover (the FBI agent played by Noah Emmerich) is a masterclass in passive-aggressive power dynamics. Emmerich plays "condescending fed" better than almost anyone in Hollywood.
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
How to Get the Most Out of Your Rewatch
To truly appreciate what the creators did here, you have to look past the surface-level mystery. The show is about the survival of a culture.
- Watch for the symbolism of the birds. Owls and crows appear throughout the season, signaling death or a shift in the wind.
- Listen to the sound design. The desert is never truly quiet. There is a constant hum of insects, wind, and distant engines.
- Track the money. Follow the path of the stolen cash. It’s a metaphor for how wealth is extracted from Indigenous lands and where it actually ends up.
Dark Winds Season 1 succeeded because it didn't try to be a "Native American show" for a white audience. It just told a great story that happened to be deeply rooted in a specific place and time. It respects the intelligence of the viewer. It doesn't over-explain the Navajo language or customs; it invites you to keep up.
If you want to dive deeper, look into the history of the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) during the 70s. Understanding the jurisdictional nightmares Leaphorn has to navigate—where the FBI handles felonies but the tribal police handle everything else—makes the stakes of his investigation much clearer. The show isn't just about catching a bad guy; it’s about navigating a legal maze designed to make him fail.
The best way to experience the show is to watch it with an eye for the landscapes. These aren't just pretty backdrops. The canyons and mesas are the bones of the story. They provide cover for the criminals and a home for the heroes. By the time the credits roll on the final episode, you'll realized that the "dark winds" of the title aren't just weather—they are the forces of change, greed, and history blowing through the Navajo Nation.
To move forward with your exploration of this series, start by comparing the first season's portrayal of Joe Leaphorn with the 1991 film The Dark Wind or the early 2000s TV movies. You'll quickly see why this 2022 iteration is considered the definitive version. Then, look into the filming locations around Camel Rock Studios and the Tesuque Pueblo to see how the production supported local Indigenous economies.