You know that feeling when you're watching a show and you can't tell if you're looking at the hero or the villain? That’s the entire vibe of Apple TV’s mind-bending thriller. Most people think they’re just watching a sci-fi story about a box, but honestly, it’s a masterclass in acting. The Dark Matter TV show cast is doing something incredibly difficult here: playing multiple versions of themselves without making it feel like a cheap gimmick.
It’s about choices.
One version of you chose the family. The other chose the career. Same face, totally different soul. Joel Edgerton has to pull this off every single episode, and honestly, the way he shifts his posture just enough to signal which "Jason" he is? It’s kind of brilliant.
💡 You might also like: The Menendez Brothers Parents Funeral: What Really Happened at the Directors Guild of America
The Man with a Thousand Faces: Joel Edgerton as Jason Dessen
At the heart of everything is Jason Dessen. Or Jasons. Plural.
Joel Edgerton doesn't just play two guys; he plays a whole spectrum of what a human being can become when they lose their way. You’ve got Jason1—the physics professor who is basically a soft-hearted family man. Then you’ve got Jason2, the guy who built "The Box" but realized his professional success left him totally empty inside.
What’s wild is how Edgerton manages the nuances.
In the later episodes of the first season, we start seeing dozens of Jasons. Some are scarred. Some are angry. Some are just exhausted. It would have been so easy for this to feel like a cartoon, but Edgerton keeps it grounded. He’s been around for a long time—you probably remember him from The Great Gatsby or Warrior—but this role is easily his most complex work to date. He’s playing against himself, and you actually forget it’s the same actor.
Jennifer Connelly: More Than Just the Wife
It’s sort of a trope in sci-fi to have the "suffering wife" waiting at home, but Jennifer Connelly is way too good for that. As Daniela Dessen, she has to navigate a marriage where her husband literally isn't the man she married.
Connelly brings this raw, suspicious energy to the role. She’s an Academy Award winner for a reason. Whether she’s the Daniela who gave up her art for her family or the successful, slightly more hardened version in the alternate reality, she makes you feel the weight of her decisions.
Why Their Chemistry Matters
The show only works if you believe in the love story. Basically, if Jason isn't desperate to get back to this specific woman, the whole plot falls apart. Connelly and Edgerton have this lived-in comfort that makes the high-concept physics stuff feel secondary to the emotional stakes.
✨ Don't miss: BeBe CeCe Winans Christmas Songs: Why They Still Hit Different
The Supporting Players Who Steal the Scene
While the Dessens are the core, the rest of the Dark Matter TV show cast brings the world-building to life.
- Alice Braga (Amanda Lucas): She plays the psychiatrist who follows Jason into the multiverse. Braga is incredible at playing "capable but terrified." Her character is arguably the moral compass of the show, even when they're jumping through realities where the world is literally ending.
- Jimmi Simpson (Ryan Holder): You know him from Westworld and It's Always Sunny, so you expect him to be a little bit "off." In Dark Matter, he plays Ryan, Jason’s friend who wins the Pavia Prize. Watching his dynamic change depending on which universe they’re in is a highlight. He can go from a supportive buddy to a confused victim in a heartbeat.
- Dayo Okeniyi (Leighton Vance): He’s the billionaire funding the project. He brings a certain "tech-bro" menace that feels very relevant today. He's the guy who thinks money can buy entry into any reality he wants.
Oakes Fegley and the Stakes of Family
Don't overlook the kid. Oakes Fegley plays Charlie, Jason and Daniela’s son. In a show about infinite versions of the world, Charlie is the anchor. He’s the reason Jason1 keeps going when things get dark. Fegley plays him with a naturalism that avoids the "annoying TV teen" clichés. He just feels like a kid who wants his dad back, even if he can't quite put his finger on why his "new" dad feels like a stranger.
What's Happening with Season 2?
Apple TV+ officially renewed the series in August 2024. This is a huge deal because the first season covered most of Blake Crouch’s original novel.
Since we’re now moving into 2026, the buzz is all about where the cast goes next. Crouch is the showrunner, so the story is in good hands, but we’re entering uncharted territory. We know Edgerton and Connelly are returning—you can't have the show without them—but the multiverse allows for literally anyone to come back. Even characters who died might show up as different versions of themselves.
That’s the beauty of this cast. They aren't just playing roles; they're playing possibilities.
How to Watch and What to Look For
If you’re just starting or planning a rewatch, pay attention to the lighting and the sets. The actors often have to perform the same scene multiple times with slight variations.
- Watch the eyes. Edgerton changes his "gaze" depending on which Jason he is. Jason1 is usually looking for connection; Jason2 is usually looking for an exit or an advantage.
- Listen to the silence. Some of the best moments in the show are when the characters realize they don't recognize the person sitting across from them.
- Check the background. The "recurring" cast members like Amanda Brugel (who plays Blair) often pop up in unexpected places across different worlds.
The Dark Matter TV show cast succeeds because they treat the science fiction as a drama first. They don't get lost in the "how" of the box; they focus on the "why" of the people. It’s a messy, emotional, and often stressful journey that works because of the people on screen.
📖 Related: While You Were Sleeping Book: Why This Creepy Psychological Thriller Still Messes With Your Head
If you're looking for your next step with this show, your best bet is to dive into the official Apple TV+ behind-the-scenes features. They show exactly how they filmed the "multiple Jason" scenes, and it’ll make you respect Edgerton’s performance even more. You should also check out the original book by Blake Crouch—it gives a lot of internal monologue for the characters that the actors had to translate into physical performances.