If you were watching the game on September 28, 2025, you probably haven't stopped thinking about it. A 40-40 tie. In the modern NFL, that just doesn't happen. It was the second-highest scoring tie in the history of the league, and honestly, it was the most fitting chapter for a rivalry that refuses to be normal.
The Dallas Cowboys vs Packers saga isn't just about football. It’s about psychological warfare. It’s about the fact that Green Bay has basically treated AT&T Stadium like their own personal vacation home for the last decade.
When you look at the numbers, the Packers hold a 22-17-1 lead in the all-time series. But that’s a boring way to describe a blood feud that spans from the frozen tundra of the 1960s to the high-tech drama of 2026.
The Haunting of Jerry World
Let’s be real for a second. Most Dallas fans go into a matchup against Green Bay with a specific kind of dread. It’s the kind of dread earned from years of watching Aaron Rodgers—and now Jordan Love—tear their hearts out in the final two minutes.
The January 2024 Wild Card game was probably the low point. The Cowboys were the number two seed. They were supposed to roll. Instead, Jordan Love and the 7th-seeded Packers walked into Arlington and put up 48 points. It was an absolute dismantling.
That game extended a weird, almost paranormal streak: the Packers have as many postseason wins at AT&T Stadium as the Cowboys do. That is a stat that should make every person in North Texas want to throw their remote through the window.
Why Jordan Love Changed Everything
For a while, people thought the "Cowboy Killer" era would end when Rodgers left for the Jets. Wrong. Jordan Love stepped in and immediately looked like he’d been studying the "How to Ruin a Cowboy Fan's Sunday" manual for years.
💡 You might also like: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
In that 2024 blowout, Love threw for 272 yards and three touchdowns with a nearly perfect passer rating. He wasn't just good; he was surgically precise. It felt like a torch passing from one tormentor to the next.
The Ice Bowl and the 90s Revenge
You can't talk about Dallas Cowboys vs Packers without mentioning the "Ice Bowl." December 31, 1967. It was -13°F at kickoff. The wind chill was roughly "instant death."
Bart Starr's quarterback sneak at the one-yard line didn't just win a game; it established the Packers as the kings of the 1960s. They won the first two Super Bowls because they could survive the Cowboys in the postseason.
Then came the 90s. This was the one era where Dallas actually owned the Packers. Between 1991 and 1996, the Cowboys went on an 8-game winning streak.
- 1993 NFC Divisional: Dallas wins 27-17.
- 1994 NFC Divisional: Dallas wins 35-9.
- 1995 NFC Championship: Dallas wins 38-27.
Troy Aikman, Emmitt Smith, and Michael Irvin basically lived in Brett Favre's nightmares. Favre famously couldn't win in Irving. It didn't matter how many MVPs he had; he’d show up at Texas Stadium and the Cowboys' defense would swallow him whole.
The Catch That Wasn't (and Still Is)
"Dez caught it."
📖 Related: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
If you say those three words in a Dallas sports bar, someone might buy you a drink, or they might start crying. The 2014 Divisional Playoff game is the moment that defined the modern version of this rivalry.
It was 4th-and-2. Tony Romo threw a moonshot to Dez Bryant. Dez climbed the ladder, grabbed the ball, and took three steps before hitting the ground. The ball bobbled. The refs overturned it.
The NFL literally had to change the rules of what a catch is because of that play.
Green Bay won 26-21, but the "catch" remains a permanent scar on the Dallas psyche. It’s the moment the rivalry moved from being about stats to being about "what if."
Breaking Down the All-Time Numbers
Sometimes prose doesn't do the sheer weight of this history justice. You have to see how these two have traded blows over sixty years.
The Packers lead the overall series 22-17-1. In the postseason, it's even tighter, with Green Bay holding a slim 5-4 edge.
👉 See also: Inter Miami vs Toronto: What Really Happened in Their Recent Clashes
What's wild is the scoring. Dallas averages about 24 points per game in this matchup, while Green Bay is around 25. That one-point difference over 40 games tells you exactly how close these teams usually are—at least until the fourth quarter starts and things get weird.
Why the 2025 Tie Still Matters
The 40-40 tie in September 2025 was significant because it showed a Dallas team that finally refused to fold.
Dak Prescott threw for over 300 yards. Micah Parsons—who, remember, grew up a Packers fan and has been criticized for being "too nice" to them—actually recorded a massive sack in overtime that prevented a Green Bay win.
It was a gritty, ugly, beautiful mess. Brandon Aubrey and Brandon McManus traded field goals in the extra period. Neither team would give an inch. It was the first tie in the history of the rivalry, and it felt like a truce after years of Green Bay dominance.
Actionable Insights for the Next Matchup
If you're betting on or just watching the next Dallas Cowboys vs Packers game, keep these specific factors in mind:
- The Quarterback Pressure Rate: Micah Parsons is the key. When Dallas can't get to the QB, their secondary tends to get shredded by the Packers' rhythm-based passing game.
- Home Field (Non) Advantage: Don't automatically give the edge to the home team. Green Bay is 5-0 at AT&T Stadium. They actually seem to play better in the "Death Star" than they do at Lambeau sometimes.
- The "Script" Factor: Watch the first two drives. In the last three meetings, the team that scores first has gone on to win (or tie) every single time.
- Injury Reports on the O-Line: Both teams rely heavily on pass protection to let Love and Prescott find deep routes. If the Packers are missing a starting tackle, the Dallas pass rush becomes a nightmare.
This rivalry doesn't have an "off" switch. Whether it's a blowout in the playoffs or a high-scoring tie in the regular season, the Cowboys and Packers are destined to keep breaking the record books.
Check the 2026 schedule for the next Lambeau meeting. It’s going to be cold, and it’s going to be loud.