You start the game as a literal sacrifice. A blade swings, your head rolls, and then—darkness. But instead of the void, you meet a chained god who gives you a deal you can't really refuse. That’s the entry point. Most players just see it as a cool roguelike mechanic to get the action started, but the cult of the lamb lore is actually a tragedy about family, betrayal, and the terrifying realization that you aren’t actually the hero. You're just the latest pawn in a cosmic grudge match that’s been rotting away for centuries.
It's messy. It’s violent.
Honestly, the deeper you look into the history of the Lands of the Old Faith, the more you realize that "The One Who Waits" isn't just a generic spooky boss. He’s a brother. He’s Narinder. And the four Bishops who chained him? They didn't do it because they were purely evil. They did it because they were absolutely terrified of what he represented: change.
The Five Prevailed, Then They Fell
Long before you ever picked up the Red Crown, there were five. Shamura, Heket, Kallamar, Leshy, and Narinder. They weren't just gods; they were siblings. They ruled over everything. Each one represented a pillar of existence, and for a long time, things were... well, maybe not "peaceful," but stable.
But Narinder got greedy. Or maybe he was just more honest than the others. While the four Bishops were obsessed with maintaining the status quo—the "Old Faith"—Narinder wanted to push boundaries. He wanted to evolve. To the others, this looked like heresy. To him, it was just the natural progression of power. This wasn't some minor disagreement over ritual styles. This was a total war.
Shamura, the eldest and the wisest, was the one who ultimately made the call to cast him down. It’s a bit of a gut punch when you find out that Shamura actually loved Narinder the most. They taught him, mentored him, and then had to be the one to orchestrate his eternal imprisonment. That kind of betrayal leaves a mark, and not just emotionally. If you look at the Bishop designs, they are literally falling apart. Heket’s throat is ripped open. Leshy is blind. Kallamar is a nervous wreck. This is the physical price they paid for trying to erase their brother from history.
The Prophecy That Backfired
The Bishops did something incredibly stupid: they tried to outsmart fate.
✨ Don't miss: Finding the Rusty Cryptic Vessel in Lies of P and Why You Actually Need It
They heard a prophecy that a sheep would rise up and bring about the end of the Old Faith. Their solution? Kill every single sheep in existence. Genocidal? Yes. Effective? Not even close. By slaughtering every lamb, they essentially created the very vacuum that Narinder needed. They left one lamb left—you. And by killing you, they sent you straight into Narinder's arms in the afterlife.
It’s a classic Greek tragedy setup. By trying to avoid their destiny, they sprinted right into it.
The cult of the lamb lore really hits its stride when you realize the Red Crown isn't just a weapon. It's a sentient piece of the Old Faith itself. When Narinder gives it to you, he’s not just giving you power; he’s giving you a leash. You think you’re building a community of cute woodland critters, but you’re actually just rebuilding the same oppressive structures the Bishops used, just under a different management team.
Why Narinder Was Really Banished
We need to talk about what Narinder actually wanted. He represented Death, but not just the "ending" kind. He represented the transition and the "after." The other Bishops were terrified of mortality. They wanted to live forever as stagnant rulers. Narinder saw that for the world to grow, things had to end.
If you talk to the NPC Ratau—your predecessor—you get snippets of how many times this has happened before. You aren't the first "vessel." You're just the one who actually succeeded. Ratau failed because he couldn't handle the blood toll. He had a conscience. To truly progress in the lore, you have to realize that having a conscience is almost a handicap in this universe.
The Role of the Crown and the Silk Cradle
The Silk Cradle is where the lore gets really heavy. This is Shamura’s domain. Because Shamura is the Bishop of Wisdom, they are the one who remembers everything, even as their mind is shattering. Throughout your encounters, Shamura doesn't just threaten you. They pity you.
🔗 Read more: Finding every Hollow Knight mask shard without losing your mind
"The One Who Waits is a brother to us," they'll say. They admit they miss him. This adds a layer of complexity that most indie games miss. The "villains" are grieving. They are a broken family. When you finally reach the end and have to choose whether to sacrifice yourself or fight Narinder, the game is asking you if you’ve learned anything from the Bishops’ mistakes.
If you choose to spare Narinder after defeating him, he becomes a follower. A mortal. It’s the ultimate humiliation, but also the only way to truly "break" the cycle of the Old Faith. He goes from a god of death to a guy who has to clean up poop in your camp. There’s a weirdly dark humor in that, but it also completes the narrative arc of the five siblings.
The Mystery of the Entities Beyond
Then there are the "Mystic Sellers" and the entities like Forneus. Forneus is a merchant, but her backstory is devastating. She had two sons, Aym and Baal. Narinder took them as his guardians. When you play through the game, you aren't just fighting monsters; you’re fighting Forneus’s stolen children.
- Aym and Baal were "gifts" to Narinder.
- They serve as his shadows.
- You can actually reunite them with their mother in the post-game content.
This is one of the few truly "good" things you can do in the game. It’s a rare moment of genuine heart in a world that is otherwise obsessed with ritualistic murder and brainwashing. It proves that while the gods are petty and cruel, the people caught in their wake still have a shred of humanity left.
Understanding the "Relics of the Old Faith"
When the game updated to include the Relics, it wasn't just a combat tweak. It added a massive amount of environmental storytelling. These objects—teeth, eyes, tattered robes—are all that’s left of the era before the Bishops went mad.
They suggest that the world used to be much bigger. There were other gods, other cults, and other ways of existing. The Bishops didn't just rule; they purged. They simplified the world into four neat, controlled zones. By collecting these relics, you are essentially piecing together a history that the Bishops tried to burn.
💡 You might also like: Animal Crossing for PC: Why It Doesn’t Exist and the Real Ways People Play Anyway
It makes you wonder: if the Lamb stays in power long enough, will they eventually become just as paranoid as Heket or Kallamar? Will the Lamb start seeing threats in every new creature that wanders into camp? The lore implies that the Red Crown has a corruptive influence. It’s not just "power corrupts"; it's that the Crown itself has a will. It wants to be fed. It wants devotion.
How to Piece the Story Together Yourself
To really get the full picture of cult of the lamb lore, you have to do more than just finish the boss fights. You need to be a bit of a detective.
- Read the Lore Tablets: These are hidden in the various regions (Anura, Anchordeep, etc.). They provide the Bishops' perspective on Narinder’s betrayal.
- Talk to the NPCs repeatedly: Characters like Clauneck and Kudaai offer cryptic hints about the nature of the crowns (yes, there are more than one).
- Pay attention to the background art: The statues in the background of boss arenas often depict the five siblings before they were mutilated.
The game is very "Show, Don't Tell." It expects you to notice that Heket is always hungry because her throat was crushed, preventing her from ever feeling full. It expects you to see that Kallamar’s cowardice is a direct result of seeing what Narinder was capable of doing to their eldest sibling.
What’s Next? Actionable Insights for Lore Hunters
If you’re looking to max out your understanding of the story while playing, don't just rush the endgame. Here is how you should approach your next run:
Prioritize the Post-Game "Godhood" Questline
After you defeat the final boss, the game doesn't end. You enter a "New Game+" of sorts where you encounter the "Mystic Seller." This entity is arguably more powerful than Narinder ever was. Trading "God Tears" to this entity reveals the final fates of the Bishops and allows you to recruit them into your cult. Recruiting the Bishops is essential for hearing their unique dialogue about their regrets.
Reunite the Cats
If you get the Aym and Baal necklaces (through the Mystic Seller), sacrifice two followers wearing them. You'll summon the two guardians. After defeating them in battle, you can turn them into followers. Use the "Missionary" to send them back to Forneus. This completes one of the most significant subplots in the game and gives you a massive sense of closure regarding Narinder's past.
Focus on the Graveyard
Build a graveyard. It sounds morbid, but as you bury your followers and read their epitaphs, you start to see the "human" cost of your cult. The game tracks their lives. Seeing a follower’s life story—from being a rescued dissenter to a loyal high priest—reinforces the theme that the Lamb is just as much a manipulator as the Old Faith was.
Ultimately, the lore isn't about being a hero. It’s about the cycle of power. You can be a "kind" leader, but you are still a leader who demands worship. The Old Faith is dead, but as long as the Lamb wears the Crown, the system they built stays exactly the same. That’s the real horror of the game. It’s not the demons or the blood—it’s the fact that the more things change, the more they stay the same.