Football is violent. We know that. But for the last decade, the NFL has been obsessed with one specific type of violence: the use of the crown of the helmet. It sounds simple enough when you hear it on a broadcast, right? A player lowers his head, makes contact with the top of his shell, and the yellow flag flies. Easy.
Except it isn't. Not even close.
If you’ve spent any time watching Sunday afternoon games lately, you’ve seen the confusion. A running back lowers his center of gravity to squeeze through a hole, his head naturally dips, and suddenly he’s hit with a 15-yard penalty that kills a scoring drive. Fans scream at their TVs. Coaches lose their minds on the sidelines. Even the announcers—who literally have the rulebook in front of them—often sound like they’re guessing.
The reality is that the crown of the helmet rule is one of the most difficult things to officiate in the history of the sport. It’s a rule born out of a desperate need for safety, yet it constantly clashes with the physics of how human beings actually play football.
The Anatomy of the Strike
Let’s get technical for a second. What actually is the "crown"?
The NFL defines it as the very top portion of the helmet. If you imagine a circle on the top of the shell, that’s your danger zone. When a player—offensive or defensive—lowers their head and initiates contact with that specific area against an opponent, it’s a foul.
Why? Because of "axial loading."
When the head is tucked down, the spine loses its natural curvature. It becomes a straight rod. If you hit something with the top of your head in that position, all that force travels directly down the vertebrae. It doesn’t take a doctor to realize that’s how catastrophic neck injuries happen. Ryan Shazier’s devastating injury in 2017 is the shadow that hangs over this entire rule. It changed how the league looked at "initiating contact."
✨ Don't miss: Liechtenstein National Football Team: Why Their Struggles are Different Than You Think
Why Referees Hate Calling It
Honestly, officiating this is a nightmare. Imagine trying to see a three-inch circle on top of a player's head while they are moving at 20 miles per hour. Everything happens in milliseconds.
The league expanded the rule in 2018 to make it a foul regardless of where the opponent is hit. You don't have to hit the other guy in the head; if you use the crown of the helmet to hit him in the thigh, it's still a flag. But here is where it gets murky.
Referees are told to look for three specific things:
- The player lowers his head to establish a linear body posture.
- The player initiates contact with the crown.
- The contact is "forcible."
That third one is the kicker. "Forcible" is subjective. One ref's "glancing blow" is another ref's "deadly spear." This subjectivity is why you see such wild inconsistency from week to week. You'll see a defender get ejected in a Raiders game for a hit that wouldn't even get a whistle in a Ravens game. It drives everyone insane.
The Running Back Dilemma
For years, this was seen as a "defender's rule." It was meant to stop safeties from launching themselves like human missiles. But lately, the NFL has been cracking down on offensive players, specifically running backs.
Think about the physics of a goal-line stand. A 230-pound back is trying to get one yard. His natural instinct is to get low. When you get low, your head naturally drops. In 2023 and 2024, we saw a massive uptick in "Use of Helmet" fines being sent out on Tuesday mornings to players who weren't even flagged during the game.
Josh Jacobs and David Montgomery have both been vocal about this. They argue that by penalizing the crown of the helmet in these situations, the league is essentially asking them to stop protecting themselves. If they run upright, they get their chests caved in. If they lower their heads, they lose $20,000. It's a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" scenario that feels more like a legal liability shield for the league than a functional game rule.
🔗 Read more: Cómo entender la tabla de Copa Oro y por qué los puntos no siempre cuentan la historia completa
The Evolution of the Wording
It’s worth noting that the rulebook has been tweaked almost every single offseason. It used to be called "spearing." Then it was "targeting" (which is still the college term, though the rules differ). Now, the NFL officially refers to it under Rule 12, Section 2, Article 10.
The language is dense. It talks about "linear posture" and "unobstructed path." But at its core, the league is trying to legislate out a fundamental habit. Football players are taught from age five to "put your forehead on the numbers." Breaking that muscle memory at the professional level is like trying to tell a golfer to change their swing in the middle of the Masters. It's awkward. It looks clunky.
Real-World Impact on the Game
When the flag flies for a crown of the helmet violation, it’s a 15-yarder. It’s an automatic first down. In terms of impact, it’s right up there with pass interference.
But there is a secondary impact: the "hesitation factor."
Defensive coordinators like Steve Spagnuolo or Vic Fangio have talked about how players are now thinking instead of reacting. A split second of thought—Is my head too low?—is the difference between a sack and a 40-yard completion. We are seeing a fundamental shift in how tackling is taught. The "Hawk Tackle" or rugby-style tackle, popularized by Pete Carroll years ago, is now the gold standard because it keeps the head out of the fight.
What Most People Get Wrong
A common misconception is that the rule only applies if there is helmet-to-helmet contact.
That is false.
💡 You might also like: Ohio State Football All White Uniforms: Why the Icy Look Always Sparks a Debate
You can be flagged for a crown of the helmet foul even if you hit the opponent's shoulder, chest, or stomach. The foul is about the initiator's head position, not the recipient's injury. This is why fans get so frustrated. They see a hit that looks "clean" because the heads didn't knock together, but the flag is still there because the tackler "speared" with the top of his head.
Another thing? The "incidental" loophole. The rulebook says that if the contact is "incidental" to a conventional tackle, it shouldn't be a foul. But again, who defines "incidental"? In the heat of a playoff game, that's a massive amount of power to give to a human official who is watching the play in real-time without the benefit of 4K slow-motion replays.
Looking Ahead: The Future of the Shell
Is the rule working? Statistically, concussions are a moving target, but the league insists that the "Use of Helmet" rule has lowered the rate of spinal injuries.
We are also seeing technological shifts. The "Guardian Caps" you see in training camp are a visual reminder of how much the league fears the crown. While players don't wear them in regular-season games yet, the data being collected from them is influencing how the crown of the helmet rule is refined.
Expect more fines. Expect more confusing flags. The NFL has made its stance clear: the head is no longer a weapon. It’s a liability.
Next Steps for Players and Fans
To truly understand how this rule affects the game you're watching, focus on the "posture" of the tackler rather than the point of impact. If you see a player's spine become a straight line parallel to the ground right before a hit, a flag is likely coming.
For those playing the game, the shift toward "shoulder-led" tackling isn't just a coaching clinic suggestion anymore—it's a financial necessity. Keep the eyes up. If you can see what you're hitting, you aren't using the crown. The moment your eyes hit the turf, you've put your career and your paycheck at risk.
Watch the hips of the ball carrier. Defenders who aim for the "strike zone" between the waist and the neck while keeping their heads to the side are the ones who stay on the field. The era of the "big hit" involving a lowered head is officially dead, whether the fans like it or not.