We’ve all been there. You make a choice that makes zero sense on paper but feels absolutely "right" in the moment. Maybe it’s staying with a partner who is objectively wrong for you, or perhaps it’s a sudden, impulsive career pivot because your gut told you to jump. People call these crimes of the heart. It’s a poetic phrase, sure, but in reality, it describes the messy, often destructive collision between our logical brains and our emotional desires.
It’s not just about romance.
When we talk about crimes of the heart, we’re talking about the fundamental ways humans prioritize feeling over fact. This isn't just some abstract concept from a 1980s play or a movie; it’s a psychological reality that dictates how we spend money, who we trust, and how we ruin our own lives sometimes. We like to think we’re rational. We aren’t. We’re emotional creatures who occasionally use logic to justify what our hearts already decided to do.
The Psychological Weight of Crimes of the Heart
Why do we do it? Why do we commit these "crimes" against our own best interests?
Psychologists often point to the "affect heuristic." It’s a mental shortcut. Instead of weighing every pro and con, your brain just asks, "How do I feel about this?" If the feeling is warm, you go for it. If the feeling is cold, you run. The problem is that your feelings are frequently liars. They are built on old traumas, fleeting chemistry, and biological drives that haven't updated since we were living in caves.
Consider the work of Daniel Kahneman in Thinking, Fast and Slow. He talks about System 1—the fast, instinctive, and emotional part of the brain. This is where the crimes of the heart live. System 2 is the slow, deliberate, logical part. The issue is that System 1 is always running in the background, making snap judgments before System 2 even gets out of bed.
Honestly, most of our "bad" decisions are just System 1 winning the tug-of-war.
The Role of Infatuation and Brain Chemistry
When you’re in the throes of a new relationship, your brain is basically on drugs. Dopamine, oxytocin, and norepinephrine create a cocktail that mimics the effects of certain stimulants. This is where the most common crimes of the heart happen. You ignore the "red flags." You overlook the fact that they don't have a job or that they treat waiters like garbage.
👉 See also: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
You’re chemically compromised.
Research from the Kinsey Institute has shown that the brain’s reward system lights up during early-stage love in the same way it does for addiction. This isn't a metaphor. It’s biology. When we say someone is "blinded by love," we are describing a literal neurological state where the prefrontal cortex—the part of the brain responsible for judgment—is suppressed.
Real-World Examples: When Emotion Trumps Logic
Let’s look at how this plays out outside of just dating. Crimes of the heart manifest in family dynamics and even professional settings.
Take the "Sunk Cost Fallacy." This is a classic crime of the heart. You’ve invested five years into a failing business or a dead-end degree. Logic says "cut your losses." The heart says, "But I've put so much love and effort into this!" So you stay. You keep pouring resources into a black hole because your emotional attachment to the idea of success outweighs the reality of the situation.
- The Family Enabler: A parent continues to bail out an adult child who refuses to change. It’s a crime of the heart because the parent's love prevents them from setting the boundaries that would actually help the child.
- The Passion Project: An entrepreneur bankrupts their family to fund an invention that no one wants. They love the product too much to see the market data.
- The "One That Got Away": Someone sabotages a perfectly healthy current relationship because they are emotionally tethered to a toxic ex from a decade ago.
These aren't just mistakes. They are deep-seated emotional compulsions.
Beth Henley’s Influence on the Term
We can’t really discuss crimes of the heart without mentioning Beth Henley’s 1979 play of the same name. It won a Pulitzer for a reason. It captured the chaotic, dark, and often absurd nature of family loyalty and personal mistakes. The Magrath sisters—Lenny, Meg, and Babe—each deal with their own "crimes." Babe shoots her husband because she "didn't like his looks," but it’s really about the years of emotional suffocation she endured.
The play resonates because it doesn't judge. It just shows the mess. It highlights how our upbringing and our internal wounds lead us to do things that look "crazy" to outsiders but feel inevitable to us.
✨ Don't miss: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
Why We Root for the "Criminal"
In fiction and in life, we often have a weird sympathy for these crimes. Why? Because we see ourselves in them. We’ve all felt that desperate, irrational pull. We’ve all wanted something we shouldn't have. There is something deeply human about being "all heart and no head," even if it leads to a total train wreck.
How to Spot a Crime of the Heart Before It Happens
You can’t always stop yourself. Emotions are fast. Logic is slow. But you can start to recognize the patterns.
One major sign is defensiveness. If someone asks you a simple question about a choice you’re making—like, "Why are you quitting your job without a backup?"—and you get immediately angry, that’s a red flag. Anger is often a shield for an emotional decision that can't stand up to scrutiny. You're protecting the "heart" from the "head."
Another sign? Isolation. If you find yourself hiding your actions from the people who usually give you good advice, you’re likely committing a crime of the heart. You know they’ll point out the flaws, so you just don't tell them. You create a bubble where only your feelings exist.
The "Five-Year Rule" Test
A simple way to check yourself is to ask: "Will the version of me five years from now be grateful for this decision?"
The heart lives in the now. It wants satisfaction now. It wants the dopamine hit now. The future self is a stranger to the heart. By forcing yourself to think about the long-term consequences, you engage that System 2 logic and give yourself a fighting chance to avoid a disaster.
The Cost of Emotional Impulsivity
The fallout of these decisions isn't just "feeling bad." There are tangible, sometimes irreversible consequences. Financial ruin. Estranged families. Career setbacks. The term "crimes of the heart" sounds soft, but the impact is hard.
🔗 Read more: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong
According to various sociological studies on divorce, "irreconcilable differences" often boil down to a series of emotional decisions made without regard for long-term compatibility. We choose partners based on chemistry (the heart) and then wonder why we can't agree on finances or child-rearing (the head).
It’s a mismatch of priorities.
Is It Ever Good to Follow Your Heart?
This isn't to say that emotions are always the enemy. That would be a boring, robotic way to live. Sometimes, the heart sees things the brain misses. Intuition isn't magic; it’s your brain processing patterns you haven't consciously noticed yet.
The trick is balance.
If your heart says "I love this person" and your brain says "They have a stable life, share my values, and treat me well," then you’re in the clear. The "crime" only happens when the heart is acting in direct opposition to clear, present evidence of harm.
True Wisdom = Emotional Intelligence + Radical Honesty.
Actionable Steps to Protect Yourself
If you feel like you’re on the verge of making a massive emotional mistake, or if you’ve been caught in a cycle of crimes of the heart, here is how you actually pivot. No fluff.
- Implement a 48-hour cooling-off period. For any major life decision driven by a "feeling," wait two full days. If the feeling is still just as intense and you still can't find a logical reason to back it up, keep waiting.
- Audit your "Inner Circle." Do you have at least one friend who is allowed to tell you that you're being an idiot? If everyone around you is a "yes man" for your emotions, you're at high risk.
- Write the "Counter-Argument." Literally take a piece of paper. Write down every reason why the decision you want to make is a bad idea. If you can't even bring yourself to write them down, you’ve already lost your objectivity.
- Check your physical state. Are you tired? Lonely? Stressed? Our hearts are way more prone to "crime" when our basic needs aren't met. We seek emotional highs to mask physical or mental lows.
- Externalize the situation. Imagine your best friend is about to do exactly what you are doing. What would you tell them? We are almost always better at giving advice than taking it.
Navigating crimes of the heart isn't about becoming a cold, unfeeling person. It's about becoming a person who respects their emotions enough to verify them. Don't let your heart lead you off a cliff just because it likes the view. Take the wheel, look at the map, and then decide if the drive is worth the gas.