It happens to everyone. You get a shiny new iPhone or a hand-me-down iPad, and suddenly you're staring at a login screen that feels like a gatekeeper. You need an account. Specifically, you need a new Apple ID, or as Apple has recently rebranded it across iOS 18 and newer systems, an Apple Account.
Terminology changes, but the frustration stays the same.
Honestly, setting this up should be easy. But then you hit a "Verification Failed" loop or a "Cannot Create Account at This Time" error, and suddenly you're ready to throw the device out the window. Most people rush through the setup and end up with a mess of old recovery emails they can't access or, worse, they accidentally create a "child" account when they meant to make a standard one.
Let's break down how this actually works in 2026.
🔗 Read more: iPhone 7 charger and cable: Why the wrong choice is killing your battery
The Rebrand: Apple ID vs. Apple Account
First, let's clear up the naming confusion. If you're looking for where to "Create an Apple ID" on a device running the latest software, you might see Apple Account instead. Apple officially started retiring the "ID" branding in late 2024 to make things sound more like a traditional service. It’s the same thing. Your login, your iCloud, your iMessage—it all lives under this one roof.
If you’re on an older device, say an iPhone 13 running an older iOS, it’ll still say Apple ID. Don't let that trip you up.
How to Actually Create a New Apple Account Without the Headaches
You’ve basically got three ways to do this. Most people try to do it during the initial "Hello" setup of a new phone. That’s fine, but if you're already past that screen, here is the path of least resistance.
The iPhone/iPad Method
Go to Settings. If you aren't signed in, tap "Sign in to your [Device]." From there, look for the tiny text that says "Don't have an Apple Account or forgot it?"
That's your doorway.
- Tap Create Apple Account.
- Enter your legal name and birthday. Apple is getting stricter about "nicknames" for developer and security reasons. If you want to use Apple Pay later, use your real name now.
- Choose your email. You can use a Gmail address you already own, or tap "Get a free iCloud email address."
Pro Tip: If you use a third-party email (like Yahoo or Gmail), you’re adding another layer of potential lockout. If you lose access to that Gmail, resetting your Apple password becomes a nightmare. Many power users prefer the dedicated @icloud.com address just to keep the "keys to the kingdom" in one ecosystem.
The Browser Method (The "Safety Valve")
If your phone is being buggy, go to appleid.apple.com. This is often the best way to bypass local device errors.
The web interface is cleaner. You fill out the forms, verify your phone number via SMS, and boom—you're done. You can then just sign into the device with the credentials you just made. This avoids that "Account cannot be created at this time" error that occasionally plagues the iOS Settings app.
🔗 Read more: How Much Weight is a kg? The Surprising Truth About the Kilogram
The Security Trap: Passkeys and 2FA
In 2026, a password isn't enough. Apple now pushes Passkeys hard.
Passkeys basically replace your password with your face or fingerprint. When you set up a new Apple ID, the system will likely nag you to enable this. Do it. It’s much harder to phish a FaceID scan than a text-based password.
However, you still need a "Trusted Phone Number."
Warning: Never use a temporary "burner" number for this. If you lose that number and forget your password, Apple's "Account Recovery" process can take anywhere from 3 days to 3 weeks. It is a slow, manual verification process designed to stop hackers, but it’s incredibly punishing for forgetful owners.
Why You Keep Getting Errors
"Your request cannot be completed at this time."
It’s the most vague error message in tech history. Usually, it means one of three things:
- Server issues: Check the Apple System Status page. If "Apple Account" is yellow or red, go get a coffee and try later.
- VPN usage: Apple hates VPNs during account creation. It looks like bot activity. Turn it off.
- Too many accounts: Apple limits how many new accounts can be created from a single IP address or a single device ID in a year. If you're trying to make your fifth account of the day on one iPhone, you're going to get blocked.
Managing the Mess: Can You Merge Accounts?
Short answer: No.
Longer answer: Still no, but sort of.
If you have an old account with all your photos and a new account for work, you cannot "merge" them into one. Apple has been "rumored" to be working on this for years, but as of 2026, it hasn't happened.
The closest thing you can do is Family Sharing. You can link your old account and your new account in a "Family" group to share apps and subscriptions, but your data stays separate. If you’re trying to move photos from an old ID to a new one, you have to manually download them and re-upload them. It’s tedious. It’s annoying. But it’s the only way.
Actionable Next Steps
If you’re ready to pull the trigger on a new account, here is your checklist to ensure you don't get locked out in six months:
- Use a Recovery Contact: Once the account is live, go to Settings > [Your Name] > Sign-in & Security > Account Recovery. Add a spouse or a trusted friend. If you get locked out, Apple will send a code to them to help you back in.
- Print Your Recovery Key: If you’re an "ultra-secure" type, generate a Recovery Key. But be warned: if you lose this key AND your password, Apple cannot help you. You are permanently locked out.
- Verify Your Email Immediately: Don't wait. Open that verification email and click the link. If you don't, the account might get flagged as "inactive" and deleted within 30 days.
- Update Your Trusted Number: The second you change your SIM card or phone number, update it in your Apple settings. This is the #1 reason people lose their accounts forever.
Setting up a new Apple ID is really about building a digital foundation. Take the five extra minutes to set up the recovery options now, and your future self will thank you when you inevitably forget your password at 2:00 AM.