Super Bowl Sunday is basically a national holiday. For most people, that means wings, expensive commercials, and maybe a casual five-dollar pool at the office. But for a specific breed of gambler, the actual game—the running, the passing, the tackling—is almost secondary to the absolute chaos happening on the fringes.
I’m talking about the people who ignore the point spread entirely to put thousands of dollars on the color of a liquid. Or the length of a song.
Crazy Super Bowl bets have evolved from a basement hobby into a multi-billion dollar industry that handles everything from the temperature in the stadium to the specific brand of sneakers a halftime performer wears. It’s weird. It’s often irrational. And honestly, it’s one of the few times a year where a millionaire might lose a fortune because a pop star held a note for three seconds too long.
The $3.5 Million Plane Ride and the Legend of Mattress Mack
You can't talk about high-stakes insanity without mentioning Jim "Mattress Mack" McIngvale. This guy doesn't just bet; he uses the sportsbook as a hedge for his furniture empire in Houston.
Back in 2022, Mack grabbed his mobile phone at the airport and dropped $3.46 million on the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Why? Because he’d promised his customers that if the Bucs won, they’d get full refunds on any furniture they’d bought for over $3,000. Tom Brady came through, the Bucs won, and Mack paid out a staggering amount in refunds while pocketing a $2.75 million profit from the bet.
But it’s not always a win.
🔗 Read more: The Philadelphia Phillies Boston Red Sox Rivalry: Why This Interleague Matchup Always Feels Personal
He once put $9.5 million total on the Cincinnati Bengals to beat the Rams. He lost every cent. He sat there and watched the Rams clinch it with a late Cooper Kupp touchdown, effectively lighting nearly ten million dollars on fire in front of the world.
When the National Anthem Becomes a Life-or-Death Event
If you’ve ever seen a group of grown men screaming at a TV during the "Star-Spangled Banner," they aren't just being patriotic. They’ve probably bet the "Over" on the anthem length.
Oddsmakers set a line—usually around 1 minute and 58 seconds—and the bet is decided the second the singer stops. It sounds simple. It’s not. In Super Bowl XLIX, Idina Menzel was the target. One bettor reportedly timed the rehearsal, noticed she was dragging the final "free," and hammered the over.
She held that note for what felt like an eternity.
The clock ticked past 2:01, and thousands of people won because of a vocal choice. Conversely, Reba McEntire’s 2024 performance was a heartbreaker for "Over" bettors. She clocked in at 96 seconds, smashing the "Under" and leaving people who expected a long country drawl in the dust.
💡 You might also like: The Eagles and Chiefs Score That Changed Everything for Philadelphia and Kansas City
The Gatorade Color Obsession
This is the ultimate "how do they even know?" bet.
There is no logic here. You’d think the team colors matter, but they don’t. In 2020, purple Gatorade became the betting favorite because of a rumor that it was a tribute to the late Kobe Bryant. It made sense emotionally.
The actual color? Orange.
Bettors took a literal bath on that one. Looking at the history, Orange has been the most common choice (appearing 5 times since 2001), followed by Clear and Yellow. But here’s the kicker: some sportsbooks in states like Nevada won't even take this bet because the information can leak so easily. If a sideline assistant tells a cousin it’s Blue this year, the house is cooked.
Prop Bets That Feel Like Fever Dreams
Standard football bets involve yards or touchdowns. Crazy Super Bowl bets involve things that shouldn't be legal to gamble on.
📖 Related: The Detroit Lions Game Recap That Proves This Team Is Different
- The Octopus: This is when a player scores a touchdown and then immediately scores the two-point conversion. It’s rare. It’s weird. Jalen Hurts pulled it off in Super Bowl LVII, and it paid out at massive odds for the few people brave enough to check that box.
- The Scorigami: Betting on the game ending with a score that has never happened before in NFL history.
- The First Commercial: You can literally bet on whether a beer brand or a car brand will show their logo first after kickoff.
- Puppy Bowl Cross-Overs: Yes, people have placed bets on whether the "MVP" of the Puppy Bowl will be a certain breed compared to the actual Super Bowl MVP's jersey number.
The "Black Sunday" Disaster of 1979
Long before the internet made gambling easy, the bookies in Las Vegas got absolutely destroyed by a single game. This was Super Bowl XIII—Steelers vs. Cowboys.
The line opened with the Steelers as 3.5-point favorites. The betting public hammered Pittsburgh. The books moved the line to 4.5 to try and get people to bet on Dallas. Then, the "wiseguys" (professional gamblers) bet the Cowboys at +4.5.
The final score? Steelers 35, Cowboys 31.
The margin was exactly 4. This meant the people who bet Steelers -3.5 won. The people who bet Cowboys +4.5 also won. The sportsbooks lost on both sides of the same game. They called it "Black Sunday," and it’s the reason modern oddsmakers are terrified of "middling" a game.
How to Not Lose Your Mind (or Wallet)
If you're looking to get into the world of novelty props, you have to realize these are basically lottery tickets. There is no "film study" for the color of liquid in a plastic jug.
- Check the limits: Most books cap crazy prop bets at low amounts ($100-$500) because they know the risk of inside information is high.
- Anthem Research: If you’re betting the anthem, look up the singer's past performances on YouTube. Some artists are consistently fast; others like to milk the spotlight.
- The "Tails Never Fails" Fallacy: It’s a 50/50 shot. Tails has won 30 times, and Heads has won 28. There is no "streak" that matters for a coin flip.
The real value in these bets isn't in the profit—it's in the entertainment. It makes the three hours of pre-game coverage actually watchable. Just don't be the person who loses their rent money because Kendrick Lamar decided not to wear a hat during the halftime show.
Next Steps for the Savvy Bettor:
Before kickoff, grab a printable "Prop Bet Sheet" for your party. It’s a great way to track things like the coin toss, the first penalty, and whether a coach will lose his challenge. If you're betting for real, stick to the regulated apps and keep the "crazy" stuff to a small fraction of your total bankroll. Success in Super Bowl betting is about managing the volatility of the weird as much as it is about predicting the game.