Courage: Why Most People Get it Completely Wrong

Courage: Why Most People Get it Completely Wrong

Courage is kind of a misunderstood beast. Most people think it’s about being fearless, like those high-octane action heroes who jump off buildings without a second thought. Honestly? That’s not courage. That’s usually just a lack of imagination or a very specific type of neurological wiring. Real courage is much messier. It’s that tightness in your chest when you’re about to say something unpopular. It's the shaky hands of a whistleblower.

It’s doing the thing while you are absolutely terrified.

If you look at the etymology, the word comes from the Latin cor, meaning heart. Originally, it meant to speak one's mind by telling all one's heart. We’ve drifted away from that. Nowadays, we treat it like a commodity or a personality trait you’re either born with or you’re not. But psychologists like Dr. Carol Dweck or the late Maya Angelou argued differently. They saw it as a muscle. You develop it by actually using it, starting with small, uncomfortable moments before you ever get to the life-altering stuff.

The Science of Bravery: What’s Actually Happening in Your Brain?

When you’re faced with a situation that requires courage, your brain isn't a calm lake. It’s a war zone. The amygdala—that almond-shaped bit responsible for your fight-or-flight response—starts screaming. It floods your system with cortisol and adrenaline. Your heart rate spikes. You might sweat. This is the physiological "wall."

People who exhibit high levels of courage aren't ignoring these signals. They’re just processing them through the prefrontal cortex more effectively. Research published in Nature has looked at the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex (sgACC). When people face their fears, this specific area of the brain lights up. It’s basically the biological seat of "doing it anyway."

It’s not about the absence of fear. It’s about the presence of a "why" that is bigger than the fear.

Think about the bystander effect. It’s a well-documented psychological phenomenon where people are less likely to help someone in distress if others are around. Breaking that effect takes an incredible amount of social courage. You have to be willing to look "stupid" or be "wrong" in front of a crowd. That tiny moment of deciding to step forward is where the brain shifts from passive observation to active, courageous engagement.

Why Courage Matters More Than Talent

We live in a world obsessed with "hustle" and "talent." But talent without courage is just potential sitting on a shelf gathering dust. You’ve probably met incredibly gifted people who never do anything with their skills because they’re too scared of being judged.

💡 You might also like: Kansas City MO to Olathe KS: How to Master the Commute and the Culture

Courage is the gatekeeper.

In business, we see this all the time. Look at the story of Ed Catmull and the early days of Pixar. It took immense courage to stick to the "Braintrust" model—where everyone, regardless of rank, could brutally critique a film. It’s painful to have your work torn apart. It takes guts to create a culture where honesty is valued over hierarchy. Most companies fail because they’re too cowardly to tell the truth to the boss.

Then there’s the personal side.

  • Asking for a raise when you know you've earned it.
  • Ending a relationship that’s "fine" but soul-crushing.
  • Admitting you were wrong in an argument with your spouse.

These aren't "heroic" in the cinematic sense, but they are the building blocks of a life well-lived. Without these small acts, you end up in a life that feels like an ill-fitting suit.

The Different Flavors of Being Brave

It's not all about running into burning buildings. Dr. Robert Biswas-Diener, often called the "Indiana Jones of Positive Psychology," categorizes courage into different types. This is a helpful way to look at it because you might be incredibly brave in one area and a total chicken in another.

Physical Courage is the one we all recognize. It's the soldier, the firefighter, the athlete pushing through a grueling injury. It’s tangible.

Moral Courage is much rarer. This is standing up for your values when it costs you something. Think of Viktor Frankl in the concentration camps or Malala Yousafzai advocating for education. It’s the ability to remain firm in your ethics when the entire world is telling you to bend.

Social Courage is the one we struggle with most in the age of social media. It’s the risk of being canceled, mocked, or excluded. It’s wearing what you want, saying what you think, and being okay with the fact that not everyone is going to like you. Honestly, for many people today, posting an unpopular opinion feels more dangerous than skydiving.

Psychological Courage is the internal battle. It’s the strength to face your own demons, your trauma, or your addictions. Going to therapy is an act of courage. Facing the parts of yourself that you’ve spent years hiding from is perhaps the hardest thing a human can do.

Misconceptions That Keep Us Small

One of the biggest lies we believe is that "courageous people don't feel doubt."

That is total nonsense.

If you don't feel doubt, you're not being courageous; you're just being certain. Courage requires uncertainty. It requires the possibility of failure. If the outcome is guaranteed, no bravery is required.

Another misconception? That courage is loud.

Mary Anne Radmacher famously wrote that "courage doesn't always roar. Sometimes courage is the quiet voice at the end of the day saying, 'I will try again tomorrow.'" This is the courage of the entrepreneur whose first three businesses failed. It's the courage of the person struggling with chronic pain who gets out of bed anyway.

The High Cost of Playing it Safe

We often think the "safe" path is the best one. But there is a massive hidden tax on cowardice.

Regret.

When you look at studies of people on their deathbeds—like the work of palliative care nurse Bronnie Ware—the top regrets aren't about things people did. They’re about things they didn't do. They didn't have the courage to express their feelings. They didn't have the courage to live a life true to themselves instead of the life others expected of them.

Living safely feels comfortable in the short term, but it’s a slow-motion disaster for the spirit. It leads to a "quiet desperation," as Thoreau put it. You stop growing. You stop learning. You basically become a biological machine repeating the same day over and over until you die.

How to Actually Build Your Courage Muscle

You don't start by fighting a dragon. You start by looking at a lizard.

If you want to become more courageous, you have to treat it like physical training. You wouldn't walk into a gym and try to bench press 400 pounds on day one. You'd start with the bar.

Step 1: Identify Your "Fear Threshold"

What is the thing that makes you slightly uncomfortable but won't ruin your life? Maybe it's sending a follow-up email to someone you admire. Maybe it's eating alone at a restaurant.

Step 2: Practice "Micro-Bravery"

Do one thing every day that makes you nervous. Just one.

  • Speak up in a meeting when you usually stay quiet.
  • Try a new hobby where you know you'll be the worst person in the room.
  • Call someone instead of texting because you're worried about the tone of the conversation.

Step 3: Reframe the Physiological Response

Next time your heart starts pounding, don't tell yourself "I'm scared." Tell yourself "I'm excited" or "My body is getting ready for a challenge." Harvard researcher Alison Wood Brooks found that people who reframed anxiety as excitement performed significantly better in stressful tasks.

Step 4: Find Your North Star

Courage is much easier when you know what you’re fighting for. If your goal is just "to be brave," you’ll fail when things get tough. But if your goal is "to provide a better life for my kids" or "to ensure this injustice doesn't happen to anyone else," the fear becomes secondary to the mission.

The Role of Vulnerability

You can't have courage without vulnerability. Brené Brown has spent decades researching this, and her conclusion is simple: you cannot be brave if you are wearing a suit of armor.

To be courageous, you have to be willing to be seen. You have to be willing to fail. You have to be willing to let people see that you don't have all the answers.

This is especially hard in leadership. We’ve been taught that leaders need to be stoic and invulnerable. But the most courageous leaders are the ones who can say, "I messed up," or "I don't know the way forward, but we're going to figure it out together." That honesty creates trust, and trust is the foundation of any courageous team.

Practical Next Steps for Living Courageously

Stop waiting for the fear to go away. It won’t. It’s part of your biological hardware. Instead, change your relationship with it.

Start by auditing your life. Where are you staying silent because you're afraid of the friction? Where are you avoiding a "no" because your ego is too fragile?

Pick one area of your life—just one—where you have been playing small. Write down the absolute worst-case scenario of taking a courageous step. Usually, the "disaster" we imagine is just a few minutes of embarrassment or a bruised ego.

Compare that to the long-term cost of staying exactly where you are.

Realize that most people are so worried about their own lives and their own fears that they aren't even paying attention to your "failures." They’re too busy being scared themselves.

The world doesn't need more "fearless" people. It needs more people who are terrified but choose to move forward anyway. It needs people who are willing to have the hard conversations, take the risks, and lead with their hearts. That is where real change happens. That is where life actually begins.

Next Steps for Implementation:

  • Identify one "difficult conversation" you've been avoiding for more than a week.
  • Schedule it for within the next 48 hours.
  • Don't script it perfectly; just commit to being honest about how you feel.
  • Document the feeling immediately after the conversation—usually, it’s a massive sense of relief, regardless of the outcome.
  • Repeat this process with increasingly "scary" tasks to recalibrate your nervous system's response to stress.