You’ve seen the memes. You’ve probably heard the high-pitched, manic laughter of Funtime Freddy a thousand times in Sister Location. But the count the ways fnaf story? That hits different. It’s not just another jump-scare simulator or a bit of lore tucked away in a 16-bit minigame. It is a grim, claustrophobic psychological horror story that reminds us why Scott Cawthon’s universe became a global phenomenon in the first place. This isn't about power outages or wind-up music boxes. It’s about being trapped inside the literal chest cavity of a killing machine while it politely asks you how you’d like to die.
Honestly, when Fazbear Frights #1: Into the Pit first dropped, people were skeptical. Fans were used to the games. They weren't sure if the books would actually "count" or if they’d just be filler. Then they read "Count the Ways." It changed everything. It introduced us to Millie, a goth teenager who basically hates everything, and a version of Funtime Freddy that is way more articulate—and way more sadistic—than anything we saw on a computer screen.
🔗 Read more: How Much Is It to Grade a Pokemon Card Explained (Simply)
The Reality of Millie and the Pink Bear
Millie Fitzsimmons isn't your typical horror protagonist. She’s moody. She writes poetry about death. She’s kind of a lot to handle for her grandfather, who just wants her to be happy. This is what makes the story work; it’s a character study long before the metal teeth show up. She’s hiding in her grandfather's workshop, a place filled with junk and old animatronics, trying to escape a world she feels doesn't get her. Then she hides inside a bear. Not just any bear, but a derelict, prototype version of Funtime Freddy.
And he talks back.
The dynamic here is incredible. You have this girl who has spent her life romanticizing death, only to be confronted by a machine that offers it to her in a very literal, very painful way. It’s a "be careful what you wish for" scenario that feels more like a Twilight Zone episode than a standard slasher. Funtime Freddy isn't just a robot following a script here. He’s a historian of execution. He’s a weirdly polite captor. He’s terrifying because he gives Millie a choice.
📖 Related: NYT Connections Hints September 6: What Most People Get Wrong
Why the Count the Ways FNAF Story Stands Out
Most FNAF lore is a puzzle. You’re looking for dates, names, and purple guys. But count the ways fnaf focuses on the "how" and the "why" of the animatronics' design. It confirms what we always suspected: these things were built for a specific, dark purpose. Funtime Freddy’s internal storage tank isn't for birthday cakes.
The story is a countdown. Freddy offers Millie various historical ways to go out. Starvation? Dehydration? Decapitation? He lists them off like a waiter describing the specials at a restaurant. It’s morbid. It’s also surprisingly educational in a dark way, as the book touches on real historical execution methods. This version of Freddy feels more like a villain from a Saw movie than a mascot. He’s calculated. He’s patient. He knows she can’t get out.
The pacing in this story is what really gets people. It jumps between Millie’s life leading up to this moment—her failed crush, her frustration with her family—and the cold, dark reality of the metal ribs pressing against her. It’s a claustrophobe’s nightmare. You can almost feel the grease and the smell of old circus dust.
The Connection to the Games
Is this the same Funtime Freddy from Sister Location? That’s the big debate. In the games, we know Funtime Freddy was designed by William Afton to capture children. He has a "storage tank" in his blueprint. "Count the Ways" gives us a front-row seat to what happens when that tank is actually occupied.
The book Freddy seems older, maybe a prototype or a discarded model. He’s in a workshop, not a high-tech underground facility. But the personality? It’s consistent. That chaotic, unstable energy is there. The main difference is the voice. In the game, he’s loud and bombastic ("Hey Bon-Bon!"). In the book, he’s eloquent and chillingly calm. It makes him feel more like a sentient predator and less like a malfunctioning toy.
Some theorists, like those in the Game Theorists community or on the FNAF subreddit, argue that these stories are "parallels" rather than direct canon. Whether Millie exists in the same timeline as Gregory or Michael Afton doesn't really matter for the impact of the story. What matters is what it tells us about Afton’s intentions. He wasn't just building robots; he was building death traps that could think.
🔗 Read more: The Fortnite Skibidi Toilet Collab: Why This Rumor Won't Die
Addressing the Ending (No Spoilers, Sorta)
People always ask about the ending. It’s one of the most discussed "cliffhangers" in the series. Without giving away the final page, it’s worth noting that the story doesn't rely on a cheap jump scare. It relies on a decision. Millie’s character arc finishes at the exact moment the "count" ends. It’s a masterclass in tension.
Most people get wrong that the story is just about gore. It’s not. There’s actually very little "on-screen" violence. The horror is all in the anticipation. It’s in the conversation. It’s the realization that Millie’s teenage angst was a luxury she didn't know she had until it was replaced by a very real, very metal threat.
How to Get the Most Out of the Fazbear Frights Series
If you're just getting into the books because of count the ways fnaf, don't just stop there. The series is a goldmine for anyone who thinks the games have become too complicated.
- Read in order, but feel free to skip. You don't have to read every story to understand the next, but the "Stitchwraith" epilogues at the end of each book actually connect them all together.
- Look for the parallels. Notice how certain characters in the books mirror characters in the games. It’s like a puzzle where the pieces are made of prose instead of pixels.
- Listen to the audiobook. Kellen Goff, the voice of Funtime Freddy in the games, doesn't narrate this specific story (the talented Kevin R. Free does), but the narration adds a layer of dread you don't get by just reading the words on the page.
- Pay attention to the junk. The setting of the workshop is filled with Easter eggs for eagle-eyed fans. It’s not just random scrap metal.
The real takeaway from count the ways fnaf is that the series is at its best when it focuses on the human element. We care about Millie because we’ve all been that frustrated, misunderstood kid. We’re scared of Freddy because he represents a cold, mechanical indifference to our human problems. It’s a perfect pairing.
If you’re looking to dive deeper into the lore, start by comparing the blueprints found in the Freddy Files with the descriptions in this story. You’ll find that the "storage tank" specs align almost perfectly with the space Millie is trapped in. It’s a grim reminder that in the world of FNAF, everything—even a hollowed-out bear—has a purpose.
To truly understand the impact of this story, look at the fan art and the "Count the Ways" song by Dawko. It’s one of the few book stories that spawned an entire sub-culture within the fandom. It’s not just a short story; it’s a core pillar of what FNAF has become in the 2020s. Stop viewing the animatronics as just jump-scare machines and start seeing them as the historical executioners they were always meant to be. The next time you see Funtime Freddy, you won't just hear a laugh; you'll hear a choice. Choose wisely.