You're standing in a bathhouse in Novigrad, steam everywhere, and a giant of a man named Sigismund Dijkstra—going by the alias Sigi Reuven—is telling you someone stole a massive fortune from right under his nose. This is the setup for the Witcher 3 Count Reuven's Treasure quest, and honestly, it’s one of the most stressful missions in the entire game if you’re trying to play the "good guy" while also being a competent Witcher. Most people mess this up because they get emotional. They see Triss Merigold in pain and they start swinging swords.
But here’s the thing: if you want to find the location of the treasure and get the best possible outcome for the later stages of the game, you have to play a very dangerous game of double-agent. It's not just about finding gold. It’s about navigating the political cesspool of Novigrad while keeping your friends alive.
What Actually Happened to the Treasure?
Basically, the treasure was moved through the sewers. Dijkstra’s "unbreakable" vault was breached by a group of thieves who used a neutralized mold to survive the toxic fumes down there. When you start investigating the Witcher 3 Count Reuven's Treasure, you'll find yourself sniffing around drains and looking at popped silver cylinders. It’s classic Geralt detective work.
The trail eventually leads to a house belonging to Margrave Henckel. Except Henckel is dead. Like, very dead. He died of a heart attack, but someone has been using his identity. When you search the house with Triss, you’ll find a hidden room triggered by a wine bottle. This is where the plot thickens. You realize that Caleb Menge, the head of the Temple Guard and a general piece of work, is the one who actually has the loot—or at least knows where it is.
Caleb Menge isn't just some low-level thug. He’s the leader of the Witch Hunters. This makes the next part of the quest incredibly high-stakes because you can’t just walk into the Temple Guard outpost and ask for the money back. You have to go undercover.
The Choice That Ruins Everything: Torturing Triss
This is the part of the Witcher 3 Count Reuven's Treasure quest that makes everyone’s skin crawl. Triss suggests a plan: you "hand her over" to the Witch Hunters as a prisoner. While they’re busy being awful to her in the back room, you talk to Menge and find out where the treasure is.
🔗 Read more: Gothic Romance Outfit Dress to Impress: Why Everyone is Obsessed With This Vibe Right Now
You have three main paths here, but only one gives you the full picture.
If you lose your cool and start a fight the moment you hear Triss scream, you're going to have to kill every single person in that compound. It’s satisfying. It’s cathartic. But it’s also a failure in terms of information gathering. If you fight early, you never learn the location of the treasure from Menge. You’ll have to find a note on his desk that points to a spy, but Dijkstra will be annoyed because the actual gold is still missing.
The "optimal" path, though it feels terrible, is to let the Witch Hunters take Triss. They will take her to a side room and you will hear her fingernails being pulled out. Yeah. It’s brutal. You have to sit there and have a conversation with Menge while your friend is being tortured feet away. You need to pick specific dialogue options to keep the ruse going:
- Ask about the treasure first.
- Tell him you want something in exchange.
- Don't let your emotions show.
If you endure this, Menge reveals the location of the treasure vault in Kovir. Shortly after, Triss will kill Menge herself (she’s a badass, remember), and you’ll escape over the roof.
Dealing with Dijkstra’s Saltiness
Dijkstra is a man of logic and ledgers. If you come back to him and say, "Hey, I killed everyone but I don't know where the money is," he’s going to be a jerk. He’ll still help you later with the Battle of Kaer Morhen, but he won't be happy about it.
💡 You might also like: The Problem With Roblox Bypassed Audios 2025: Why They Still Won't Go Away
However, if you successfully navigated the Witcher 3 Count Reuven's Treasure dialogue and found the location of the gold, Dijkstra is much more cooperative. He even gives you a sizeable reward. More importantly, it affects your relationship with him throughout the rest of the Novigrad arc. Dijkstra is a key player in the "Reason of State" quest later on, which decides the fate of the entire North. Starting that relationship on a foundation of "I actually found your money" makes things smoother.
There’s a common misconception that you must let Triss be tortured to finish the game. You don't. You can go in guns blazing. But from a completionist standpoint, you lose out on the "best" outcome for this specific quest.
The Spy and the Shack
After the mess at the Temple Guard outpost, you’ll have to meet a spy in a small shack in the middle of the night. This part of the Witcher 3 Count Reuven's Treasure quest is often overlooked but it's where you wrap up the loose ends. You find out that the spy was working for someone even higher up—eternal fire politics are messy.
Whether you killed Menge or he died in the chaos, you’ll end up at this shack. If you did the "stealth" route where Triss was tortured, you’ll have a key and a location. If you went in swinging, you’ll be hunting for clues. Regardless, the spy usually ends up dead or fleeing.
Actionable Tips for the Best Outcome
If you're playing through this right now, here is exactly how to handle it for maximum efficiency and the best rewards.
📖 Related: All Might Crystals Echoes of Wisdom: Why This Quest Item Is Driving Zelda Fans Wild
First, before you even go to the Temple Guard, make sure you've finished any other Novigrad side quests involving Triss. The game flow is better that way. Second, when you are in the bathhouse at the start, actually listen to the dialogue about the mold. It helps you understand the "pop" sound you hear later in the sewers.
When you get to the interrogation with Menge, follow these steps:
- Stay Calm: Do not choose the "Enough of this" or "I've heard enough" options. These trigger combat immediately.
- Focus on the Treasure: Choose the dialogue options that prioritize the gold. It sounds cold, but Triss specifically asked you to do this. She can handle herself.
- The Reward: After the quest, go back to Dijkstra immediately. Don't wander off. The conversation triggers better if the quest state is fresh.
The Witcher 3 Count Reuven's Treasure isn't just a fetch quest. It’s a test of whether you can prioritize the mission over your emotions. Geralt is a professional, and sometimes being a professional means letting your friend take a hit so you can win the war. It's a dark, gritty look at the reality of being a Witcher in a city that hates you.
To wrap this up, the quest ends once you’ve reported back to Dijkstra and dealt with the spy. From here, you’ll likely move on to "Get Junior" or continue the search for Dandelion. Make sure you loot Menge’s office thoroughly before leaving; there are letters and keys there that provide extra lore and context for the mage underground in Novigrad. If you're looking for the actual gold, remember: it's in a bank in Kovir. You won't be carrying bags of coins out of the sewer. You're securing the information of the treasure, which to a man like Dijkstra, is just as good as the gold itself.
Final piece of advice: don't feel too bad about Triss. She’s a powerful sorceress and her fingers heal. The political leverage you gain by finding the Witcher 3 Count Reuven's Treasure is worth far more in the long run than a clean conscience in the moment. Proceed to the next stage of the Novigrad storyline by checking in with Priscilla at the Kingfisher Inn to start tracking down Dandelion's various "girlfriends."