It starts with a simple, almost frantic piano riff. Then the vocals hit. When Barry Manilow first belted out the lyrics to Could This Be Magic back in the late seventies, he probably didn't realize he was cementing a specific kind of pop-ballad trope that would outlast the disco era. It’s a song about that weird, dizzying moment when a friendship suddenly feels like something else. We've all been there. One minute you’re grabbing coffee, and the next, the air in the room feels heavy, and you’re staring at someone wondering if the universe just shifted.
Most people associate the track with Manilow’s 1978 album Even Now. Honestly, that record was a juggernaut. It went triple platinum. But if you dig into the liner notes, you realize the song wasn't actually written by Barry. It was a cover. The original came from a vocal group called The Dubs, way back in 1957.
There's a massive gap between the doo-wop aesthetics of the fifties and the polished, orchestral pop of the seventies. Yet, the question remains the same. Is it love? Or is it just a trick of the light?
The Anatomy of a Perfect Ballad
Why does this specific song work? It isn't just the melody. It’s the vulnerability. In the 1950s version by The Dubs, Richard Blandon’s lead vocal carries a raw, almost desperate quality. It’s stripped down. Fast forward to the Barry Manilow era, and the production swells. You have strings. You have that signature "Manilow crescendo" that feels like a tidal wave hitting a pier.
The songwriting credits go to Adrienne Anderson and Barry Manilow for the later version's arrangement, but the soul of the track belongs to the 1957 original writers. It’s a short song. Usually under three minutes. In that tiny window, it has to convince you that "magic" is a real, tangible thing. It’s efficient storytelling.
Pop music thrives on these "could it be" moments. Think about it. If the singer were certain, the tension would vanish. The song works because of the doubt. It’s the sonic equivalent of standing on a ledge.
Barry Manilow’s Influence on the Soft Rock Era
You can’t talk about Could This Be Magic without acknowledging Manilow’s grip on the charts during that period. Critics used to be pretty mean to him. They called his music "saccharine" or "over-the-top." But look at the staying power. His ability to interpret a 20-year-old doo-wop track and make it a staple of 1970s adult contemporary radio is a masterclass in A&R.
📖 Related: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
He understood his audience. People in 1978 were coming off the high of the psychedelic sixties and the grit of early seventies rock. They wanted something that felt safe but emotional.
Manilow’s version of Could This Be Magic isn't just a song; it’s a mood. It’s the soundtrack to a thousand high school proms where kids were too nervous to say how they felt. The production is glossy, sure. But the vocal delivery is surprisingly intimate. He doesn't oversing the verses. He saves the power for the "magic" reveal.
The Dubs and the Doo-Wop Roots
Let’s give credit where it’s actually due. The Dubs were a quintessential New York group. Formed from the ashes of two other groups, The Five Wings and The Scale-Tones, they had a knack for harmony that felt effortless.
When they recorded the original version, they weren't thinking about "SEO" or "brand longevity." They were capturing a vibe in a booth. The 1957 version has a rhythmic "clop-clop" percussion that feels like a heartbeat. It’s much more grounded than the 1978 cover. If you listen to them side-by-side, the 1957 version feels like a secret being whispered in an alley. The 1978 version feels like a Broadway finale.
Both are valid. Both capture that same essential human curiosity.
Why We Still Care About "Magic" in Music
In 2026, music is often about "the drop" or the viral TikTok hook. We’ve moved away from the slow-burn ballad in many ways. But Could This Be Magic still pops up in playlists. Why?
👉 See also: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
Basically, it’s because the "Is this real?" phase of a relationship never goes out of style. Whether you’re sending a DM or writing a letter on parchment, that feeling of uncertainty is universal. Music theorists often point to the chord progressions in these types of ballads—they use major sevenths and suspended chords to create a sense of "unresolved" emotion.
The music literally sounds like a question mark.
Common Misconceptions About the Lyrics
A lot of people think the song is about a breakup. It’s actually the opposite. It’s about the inception of something.
- Misconception 1: It was written for a movie. (Nope, though it sounds like it should be in a rom-com).
- Misconception 2: It’s a Barry Manilow original. (As we discussed, The Dubs got there first).
- Misconception 3: It’s about literal magic tricks. (It's a metaphor, guys).
There’s also a weirdly persistent rumor that the song was inspired by a specific magic show in Las Vegas. There's zero evidence for that. It’s purely about the "magic" of chemistry between two people.
Technical Brilliance in Simple Arrangements
If you’re a musician, try playing this on a piano. It’s not incredibly complex, but the timing is everything. The way the bridge connects back to the chorus requires a specific kind of emotional pacing.
Most modern pop songs have about four chords. Could This Be Magic uses a bit more sophistication in its harmonic movement, especially in the Manilow version. He was a Julliard-trained musician, after all. He knew how to inject just enough musical theory into a pop song to make it feel "expensive" without making it inaccessible to the average listener.
✨ Don't miss: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
It’s that "expensive" sound that defined the late seventies. It was the era of big studios, real orchestras, and high-fidelity recording. You can hear the room in those recordings. There’s a warmth to the analog tape that digital recreations often struggle to mimic.
How to Listen to "Could This Be Magic" Today
If you want to actually appreciate the history here, don't just stream the top result on Spotify. Do a little homework.
- Listen to The Dubs (1957): Focus on the harmonies. Notice how the background singers act like an instrument. It’s raw and beautiful.
- Listen to Barry Manilow (1978): Put on some good headphones. Listen to the way the orchestration builds. It’s a lesson in dynamic range.
- Check out the covers: Over the years, dozens of artists have tackled this. Some are jazz interpretations, others are straight pop.
Each version tells you a little bit about the era it was recorded in. The fifties version is about longing. The seventies version is about grandeur.
The Lasting Legacy of the Song
Honestly, songs like this are rare now. We live in an age of irony. Everything has to be meta or self-aware. Could This Be Magic is completely earnest. It’s not trying to be cool. It’s trying to be honest.
That earnestness is exactly why it stays on the radio. It’s why it gets played at weddings. It’s why, when you’re driving late at night and it comes on the "oldies" station, you don't change the channel. You just lean into the nostalgia.
Whether it's the 1957 original or the 1978 blockbuster, the track reminds us that sometimes, life doesn't make sense. Sometimes, things just feel... magical. And that's enough of an explanation.
Actionable Takeaways for Music Lovers
If you're looking to dive deeper into this specific corner of music history, here's what you should actually do:
- Explore the "Doo-Wop to Pop" Pipeline: Look up other songs from the fifties that were covered by seventies superstars. You’ll find a pattern. Artists like Linda Ronstadt and James Taylor made entire careers out of this.
- Analyze the Lyrics: Take a look at Adrienne Anderson’s other work. She was a powerhouse lyricist who worked closely with Manilow on hits like "Daybreak."
- Study the Arrangement: If you’re a songwriter, pay attention to the "build" of the song. It teaches you how to start small and end big—a skill that is sorely lacking in many of today’s "loop-based" tracks.
- Support the Classics: Check out the catalogs of groups like The Dubs. Many of these early R&B and doo-wop pioneers didn't get the royalties they deserved back in the day. Streaming their original versions helps keep their legacy alive.
The next time you hear that piano intro, don't just dismiss it as "grandpa music." It's a piece of a larger puzzle. It’s a bridge between the street corners of New York in the fifties and the massive arenas of the seventies. It’s a testament to the fact that a good question—"Could this be magic?"—is always worth asking.