You’ve seen the headlines. If you’ve been anywhere near the internet since Netflix dropped Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story, you know exactly what I’m talking about. People are obsessed. Specifically, they are obsessed with one particular moment in the third episode where Cooper Koch, playing the younger Menendez brother, stands under a prison shower head and... well, bares it all.
It went viral instantly.
But here’s the thing: while social media was busy losing its mind, a lot of people started assuming the scene was just another Hollywood trick. We’ve grown so used to CGI and elaborate "modesty garments" that the default assumption is usually "that’s gotta be a fake."
Honestly, it wasn't.
The Truth About the Shower Scene
Usually, when a show goes this "full" with its nudity, there’s a whole team of prosthetic artists involved. Think Boogie Nights or even some of the more graphic moments in Euphoria. But Cooper Koch isn't about that. When he sat down with Andy Cohen on Watch What Happens Live, he didn't even wait for the host to finish the question. He basically just pointed at the camera and confirmed: no prosthetic.
It was all him.
"Just to say, mine was not a prosthetic," Koch told Cohen, smiling. He even joked about being "well hung" after Cohen offered a cheeky "congratulations."
It’s a bold move for an actor whose career is currently exploding. Most people in his position would probably be a bit more guarded. But Cooper seems to have this very refreshing, almost nonchalant attitude toward his own body. He’s mentioned in a few interviews that he finds the massive media fascination with his "parts" a little strange.
Basically, he sees it as just another day at the office. To him, we all have bodies. We all have parts. So why is everyone acting like it’s a national emergency?
💡 You might also like: Why the Jordan Is My Lawyer Bikini Still Breaks the Internet
Why the Nudity Actually Matters for the Story
If you strip away the tabloid gossip (pun intended), the scene actually serves a purpose. Monsters is a heavy show. It deals with some of the most horrific allegations of sexual abuse ever brought to a courtroom. Ryan Murphy, the show's creator, isn't exactly known for subtlety, but this scene was meant to show Erik at his most vulnerable.
In that prison shower, Erik is being watched. He’s being hunted, in a way, by the gaze of other inmates.
The nudity highlights that loss of autonomy. When you’re in the system, you don’t even own your own skin. By showing everything, the directors forced the audience to look at Erik not as a "monster" or a headline, but as a physical human being who had been stripped of every bit of privacy he ever had.
It's uncomfortable. It's supposed to be.
Is Cooper Koch New to Nudity?
If you think this was his first time baring it all for the craft, you haven't been following his career. Cooper has been a "brave" actor for a while now.
Before he was Erik Menendez, he starred in a body-horror flick called Swallowed (2022). That movie is... intense. It's about drug smuggling and it gets very graphic, very fast. He also did a full-frontal scene in that one.
Then there’s his theater background. He’s gone on record saying he did a production of Hair in college where the entire cast got naked on stage.
"I've had some experience with nudity as a performer before and it's always been done really respectfully and artistically." — Cooper Koch
📖 Related: Pat Lalama Journalist Age: Why Experience Still Rules the Newsroom
So, while the world was shocked, Cooper was basically just doing what he’s always done. He’s an artist who treats the body like a tool. If the script calls for it, he’s going to do it. No ego, no fakes, just the work.
The Controversy Behind the "Gay" Narrative
We have to address the elephant in the room. The real Erik Menendez has been very vocal about his distaste for the show. He specifically hated the scenes that insinuated he might be gay or that there was some sort of "homoerotic" tension between him and his brother Lyle.
The shower scene plays into this. In the show, Erik has a moment with another inmate in the showers that feels heavily sexualized.
The real Erik says this never happened.
It's a weird spot for Cooper Koch. He’s an out gay man in real life, and he’s played queer characters before in movies like They/Them. He’s stated that he feels a deep connection to Erik and even visited the brothers in prison with Kim Kardashian. But he’s also an actor playing a role written by Ryan Murphy.
There’s a clear divide between the "Cooper Koch nudes" that people are Googling and the real-life tragedy of the Menendez family. Cooper has tried to bridge that gap by being an advocate for the brothers' resentencing, but he can't change the fact that the show he’s in took some major creative liberties.
Navigating the "Internet's Boyfriend" Status
It’s kind of wild how fast someone can go from "that guy in the horror movie" to "global superstar." Cooper doesn't even have a public Instagram. He’s one of those rare Gen Z actors who stays off social media, which honestly probably helps his mental health.
His brother, Payton Koch, is usually the one who has to post updates or statements for him.
👉 See also: Why Sexy Pictures of Mariah Carey Are Actually a Masterclass in Branding
But even without an IG account, the "Cooper Koch nudes" search term skyrocketed. People want to know everything about him. They want to know if he’s single (he’s not, he confirmed he has a boyfriend), they want to know his height, and they want to know about his "gay voice"—something he says he was bullied for early in his career.
It’s a lot of pressure.
One day you're a working actor trying to get a break, and the next, your literal anatomy is the subject of a viral Andy Cohen segment. Cooper seems to be handling it with more grace than most. He isn't leaning into the "sex symbol" thing too hard, but he isn't running away from it either.
What’s Next for Cooper?
The buzz isn't going away anytime soon. He’s already been nominated for a Golden Globe and an Emmy for his performance as Erik. Whether or not you agree with how the show handled the Menendez story, you can’t deny the kid can act.
That 30-minute one-take episode? The one where he just sits there and talks to his lawyer? That was legendary. It showed he has the range to do more than just look good in a shower.
He’s already lined up a role in Luca Guadagnino’s next project, Artificial. If you know Guadagnino (Call Me By Your Name, Challengers), you know he loves exploring the human form and complex desires. It feels like the perfect fit for where Cooper is at right now.
If you’re looking to follow his career, keep an eye on his film choices. He seems drawn to "fringe" stories—things that are a little dark, a little queer, and very human. He isn't the type to join a Marvel movie just for the paycheck. He wants to do stuff that makes people talk.
And boy, is he succeeding at that.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Content Consumers:
- Watch the Performance, Not Just the Clips: If you only see the "nude" snippets on X (Twitter), you're missing the actual acting. Episode 5 of Monsters is widely considered a masterclass in monologue delivery.
- Verify the Sources: When you see rumors about "fake parts" or "CGI bodies," remember that the actor himself has debunked them. Don't fall for the clickbait.
- Understand the Legal Context: Since the show aired, there has been actual movement in the real Menendez case. Following the legal updates on their resentencing provides a much deeper understanding of why Cooper took this role in the first place.
- Check Out His Earlier Work: If you liked his intensity, go back and watch Swallowed. It’s a very different vibe but shows the same level of commitment to the role.
- Respect the Privacy: Since he doesn't have social media, avoid following "fan accounts" that claim to be him. They're almost always fake or just reposting his brother’s content.
The conversation around Cooper Koch is a weird mix of thirst and high-brow acting appreciation. It's a strange place to be, but he seems to be the only person in the room who isn't blushing.