You’re sitting on a couch with a friend. You point at a pillow and call it "teal." They look at you like you’ve lost your mind and insist it’s definitely green. This isn't just a petty argument or a matter of semantics. It's a fundamental glitch in how humans process the world. We assume our eyes are high-definition cameras capturing an objective reality, but the truth is way messier. Colors that people see differently aren't just a viral internet trend; they are a window into the weird, subjective biology of being alive.
The dress. You remember it. That blue and black (or white and gold) monstrosity that broke the internet in 2015. It wasn't just a meme. It was a massive wake-up call for vision scientists like Bevil Conway at the National Eye Institute. He found that our brains are constantly "correcting" for lighting without us knowing. If your brain thought the dress was in a shadow, it saw white. If it thought the light was bright, it saw blue. We aren't seeing light. We're seeing an interpretation.
The Science of Why Your Red Isn't Mine
Our eyes use photoreceptors called cones. Most of us have three types: red, green, and blue. But here’s the kicker. The distribution of these cones varies wildly from person to person. A study by Joseph Carroll at the Medical College of Wisconsin used adaptive optics to look at living human retinas. He found that two people with perfectly "normal" color vision can have a 40-fold difference in the number of red-sensitive cones. Think about that.
One person's retina is packed with red sensors, while the person next to them has a sparse scattering. Yet, they both look at a fire truck and say "red." Why? Because we’ve been socially conditioned to label that specific wavelength as red. We agree on the word, but the internal experience—the "qualia"—might be totally different.
Then there are the Tetrachromats. Most humans are trichromatic. But a small percentage of women may possess a fourth cone, potentially allowing them to see up to 100 million colors, compared to the 1 million the rest of us see. Concetta Antico, an artist in San Diego, is a confirmed tetrachromat. To her, a gray pebble isn't just gray; it’s a mosaic of violets, oranges, and greens. She sees colors that people see differently because her hardware is literally upgraded.
The Language Trap
Language shapes sight. It sounds like sci-fi, but it's linguistic relativity. Take the Himba tribe in Namibia. They don’t have a separate word for "blue" in their language; it’s folded into "green." When researchers showed them a circle of green squares with one clearly blue square, many struggled to pick it out. However, they have many different words for various shades of green that look identical to Westerners. Because they have the words, their brains are tuned to see the distinction.
👉 See also: Executive desk with drawers: Why your home office setup is probably failing you
It makes you wonder. What are we missing because we don't have a name for it?
Lighting: The Great Deceiver
Metamerism is the reason you bought a "navy" suit in a store and realized it was charcoal gray once you stepped outside. Light sources have different spectral power distributions. Incandescent bulbs are heavy on the reds. Fluorescents lean blue and green.
When you look at colors that people see differently, you have to account for the "CRI" or Color Rendering Index of the light hitting the object.
- The Noon Sun: Provides a full, balanced spectrum. This is usually the "true" color.
- LED Bulbs: Often have "spikes" in the blue spectrum, which can make certain purples look muddy or brown.
- The Golden Hour: That late afternoon light is rich in long-wavelength reds, making everything look warmer and "flattening" cool blues.
Neuroscientist Pascal Wallisch, who studied the "Dress" phenomenon extensively, suggests that our "circadian type"—whether you're a lark or an owl—affects how you see color. Early risers spend more time in daylight (blue light), while night owls spend more time in artificial light (yellow light). Your brain adapts to your lifestyle, creating a permanent filter through which you view the world.
The Viral Culprits: More Than Just a Dress
Since 2015, several other "optical illusions" have gone viral, highlighting specific colors that people see differently.
✨ Don't miss: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
- The Pink or White Shoe: A Louis Vuitton-style sneaker appeared online. Some saw pink and white; others saw mint green and gray. This usually comes down to "white balance" in the brain. If you assume the lighting is "warm," you see the shoe as mint.
- The "Billie Eilish" Sneakers: The singer once posted a pair of Nike Air Uptempos that she swore were white and mint, but many followers saw white and pink.
- The Strawberry Filter: There is a famous image of strawberries that contains zero red pixels. Seriously. If you use a color picker on the image, the pixels are actually gray and cyan. But because your brain knows strawberries are red, it "paints" the red back in for you. This is called color constancy.
It's honestly a bit terrifying. Your brain is lying to you to make the world make sense. It prefers "consistency" over "accuracy."
Gender and Age Factors
It's not just a stereotype; men and women often see color differently. Research from Israel Abramov at CUNY found that men generally require a slightly longer wavelength to experience the same hue as women. A color that looks "true orange" to a woman might look a bit more yellowish to a man. Furthermore, women are generally better at distinguishing subtle gradations among similar colors, particularly in the middle of the spectrum (greens and yellows).
And then there's aging. As we get older, the lens of the eye naturally yellows. This acts like a physical "sepia filter." It absorbs blue light, making it harder to distinguish between blues and blacks or purples. This is why your grandpa might show up wearing one black sock and one navy sock—to him, they are identical.
The Role of Tech and Screens
We spend hours looking at OLED and LCD screens. These screens don't produce "orange." They produce a mix of red and green light that tricks our brain into perceiving orange.
Depending on your phone's "True Tone" or "Night Shift" settings, you might be looking at a completely different version of a photo than the person you're texting. This digital layer adds another level of complexity to the mystery of colors that people see differently. If your screen has a slight "cool" tint, you’re seeing more blue than the photographer intended.
🔗 Read more: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
How to Test Your Own Vision
If you're curious about where you fall on the spectrum, you don't necessarily need a lab.
- The Farnsworth-Munsell 100 Hue Test: This is the gold standard for testing color acuity. You have to arrange colored pegs in a smooth gradient. It’s surprisingly difficult and reveals exactly where your "blind spots" are in the color wheel.
- Enchroma Tests: These are designed to detect color blindness, but even people with "normal" vision can find them revealing regarding their sensitivity to certain shades.
- The "Neutral Gray" Experiment: Look at a bright yellow screen for 30 seconds, then look at a white wall. You'll see a purple-blue afterimage. This is "opponent process theory" in action—your red/green and blue/yellow pathways getting fatigued.
Actionable Steps for Navigating a Subjective World
Since we know vision is subjective, how do we handle it in real life? Whether you're decorating a house or designing a website, keep these reality-checks in mind.
Test colors in three lights. Never pick a paint color or a bridesmaid dress based on how it looks in the store. Take a sample into the sunlight, under an LED, and in a dim room. The shift will shock you.
Use HEX codes for professional work. If you are a designer, don't trust your eyes. Trust the math. A HEX code like #3498db is an objective instruction for a screen, even if two different screens (or two different sets of eyes) render it slightly differently.
Acknowledge the "My-Side Bias." When you argue about whether a car is "charcoal" or "dark green," remember that both of you are likely "right." Your brains are simply using different reference points for white balance.
Consider accessibility. If you're creating anything for public consumption, remember that 8% of men have some form of color vision deficiency (CVD). Don't rely on color alone to convey meaning. Use shapes, textures, or labels.
Stop trusting your eyes so much. They aren't windows; they're interpreters. The next time someone disagrees with you about a color, don't get annoyed. Just realize you're getting a glimpse into a slightly different version of reality.