Indiana is No. 1. Read that again. It’s not a typo, and it’s not a basketball ranking.
The 2025 season just wrapped up in a way that feels like a fever dream for anyone who grew up watching the same four blue-bloods trade trophies every January. We’ve finally moved into the era where the college football top 25 isn't just a list of SEC powerhouses and a guest appearance by Ohio State. It’s a chaotic, NIL-fueled, portal-jumping mess that has basically flipped the sport on its head.
Honestly, if you told a fan five years ago that the Indiana Hoosiers would finish the regular season 13-0 and sit atop the AP Poll and the Coaches Poll heading into the postseason, they’d have asked to see your medical records. But here we are. The 2025-2026 cycle hasn't just been about rankings; it’s been a referendum on whether the "old way" of building a program even exists anymore.
The Chaos at the Top: Indiana, Georgia, and the Power Struggle
The final college football top 25 of the regular season tells a wild story. Indiana (13-0) holds the top spot, followed closely by a Georgia team (12-1) that looks like it wants to eat glass every time they take the field. Ohio State (12-1) is right there at three. It’s a weird sandwich. You have the ultimate underdog story on top, followed by the two most expensive rosters in the history of the sport.
People are still arguing about the Texas Tech ranking. The Red Raiders finishing at No. 4 with a 12-1 record is the kind of thing that makes Big 12 fans feel seen and SEC fans start typing in all caps on message boards. It’s about respect. Or the lack of it. Texas Tech has been dominant, yet there’s this lingering "yeah, but" because they didn't have to play a gauntlet of top-ten teams every weekend.
💡 You might also like: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
Then you look at Oregon. At 11-1, they’ve been a machine, but that one slip-up cost them a top-three spot. It’s brutal. The margin for error in the current landscape is basically zero.
The Real Top 10 (As of Mid-January 2026)
- Indiana (15-0 after the CFP push)
- Georgia (12-2)
- Ohio State (12-2)
- Texas Tech (12-2)
- Oregon (13-2)
- Ole Miss (13-2)
- Texas A&M (11-2)
- Oklahoma (10-3)
- Notre Dame (10-2)
- Miami (FL) (13-2)
Wait, Indiana at 15-0? Yeah, they kept the momentum going. But look at the losses for teams like Georgia and Ohio State. In the new 12-team playoff era, a loss in November doesn’t kill you anymore; it just changes your travel plans.
Why the Polls Don't Look Like They Used To
The transfer portal has basically turned college football into a one-year-contract league. Look at Miami. They jumped to No. 10 because they basically bought a new defensive line and a quarterback (Carson Beck, remember him?) in one offseason. It works. But it also makes the college football top 25 incredibly volatile.
One week you’re a top-five lock, the next your star wideout is looking at his options and your coach is answering questions about his buyout.
📖 Related: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
The "Disrespect" Factor
Vanderbilt is No. 13. I’ll let that sink in. The Commodores finished 10-2. In any other decade, a 10-win Vandy team is the lead story on every sports show for a month. In 2026, they’re just another part of the "new normal" where talent is spread out just enough to let the smart coaches thrive.
Contrast that with Texas. The Longhorns finished 10-3 and landed at No. 14. For a team that started the season with more hype than a Marvel movie, 14th feels like a failure. Arch Manning had his moments, but the consistency just wasn't there when it mattered.
The Teams Nobody Talked About (But Should Have)
If you weren't watching James Madison or North Texas this year, you missed out. James Madison finished 12-2 and sat at No. 19. They are the new Boise State. They don’t care who you are or what your NIL budget is; they just show up and ruin your season.
North Texas (No. 23) is another one. They spent most of the year unranked, then suddenly they’re 12-2 and looking like a team that could beat half the ACC on a neutral field. This is the beauty of the current college football top 25. The gap between the "Power" schools and the "Group of Five" is shrinking, mainly because the blue-bloods are too busy fighting over the same five-star recruits while the mid-majors are building actual teams.
👉 See also: Inter Miami vs Toronto: What Really Happened in Their Recent Clashes
The Big Disappointments
- Alabama (No. 11): Finishing outside the top 10 is considered a state of emergency in Tuscaloosa. 11-4 is a "bad" year. Perspective is a funny thing.
- Michigan (No. 18): Post-Jim Harbaugh life has been... bumpy. 9-4 isn't a disaster, but when you're used to the mountaintop, 18th feels like the basement.
- Virginia (No. 20): Actually, this is a success story, but they fell four spots in the final tally after a rough postseason showing.
Looking Toward the 2026 Season
We’re already seeing the "Way-Too-Early" rankings for next year, and honestly, they’re mostly guesswork. But there are patterns. Ohio State is going to be No. 1 in almost every preseason poll because their recruiting hasn't slowed down. Texas Tech will likely start in the top 10 for the first time in forever.
The biggest question for the next college football top 25 cycle is Indiana. Can they do it again? Or was 2025 a "lightning in a bottle" season where everything just clicked? History says they’ll regress, but the portal says they can just reload.
What Actually Matters Now
Winning your conference still matters, but the "eye test" is becoming more about how you handle the schedule. The committee showed this year that they value a 10-2 record against a brutal schedule more than a 12-0 record against cupcakes.
If you want to track the rankings effectively, stop looking at the record and start looking at the "Strength of Record" (SOR). It’s the only way to make sense of why a three-loss Alabama is ranked ahead of a two-loss BYU.
Next Steps for the Savvy Fan:
Keep a close eye on the spring transfer window opening soon. The current college football top 25 is basically a snapshot in time; by April, at least five of these teams will look completely different. If a top-10 team loses their starting QB to the portal, expect them to slide 10 spots before the first kickoff of 2026. Bookmark the 247Sports Portal Tracker and the official NCAA rankings page to stay ahead of the inevitable roster shifts this spring.