It finally happened. We lived through the first 12-team playoff, and honestly, it was total chaos. If you looked at the college football top 25 2024 list back in August, you probably thought you had it all figured out. Georgia was the king. Ohio State was the wealthy challenger. Oregon was the flashy new kid in the Big Ten.
But then the actual games started.
Remember when Vanderbilt—yes, Vandy—took down Alabama? That was the moment we all realized the 2024 season was going to be a fever dream. The final rankings didn't just reflect who won the most games; they told a story of blue-bloods barely hanging on and programs like Indiana and Boise State proving that the "little guys" aren't so little anymore.
Who Actually Won? The Final Rankings Shakeup
Let's cut to the chase. Ohio State ended the year at No. 1 in the AP Poll after beating Notre Dame 34-23 in the National Championship. It’s their first title in a decade. Will Howard wasn't always perfect, but he did exactly what he needed to do: get the ball to Jeremiah Smith. That kid is a human highlight reel.
✨ Don't miss: Finding the Best Texas Longhorns iPhone Wallpaper Without the Low-Res Junk
But the road there was weird. Oregon spent a massive chunk of the season at No. 1. They looked invincible. Then they hit the playoff and, well, things went south in the Rose Bowl against the Buckeyes.
The Top 10 Reality Check
- Ohio State (14-2): National Champs. They took 31 unanswered points against the Irish to seal it.
- Notre Dame (14-2): Everyone loves to hate them, but they beat Georgia in the Sugar Bowl. That counts for a lot.
- Oregon (13-1): Still the Big Ten champs, even if the playoff run ended earlier than they wanted.
- Texas (12-3): Welcome to the SEC. They handled the transition better than almost anyone expected.
- Penn State (12-3): Always the bridesmaid, but they finally won a playoff game.
- Georgia (11-3): The preseason No. 1. Seeing them at six feels wrong, but that loss to the Irish was a wake-up call.
- Arizona State (11-2): Talk about a glow-up. Kenny Dillingham is doing magic in Tempe.
- Boise State (12-2): Ashton Jeanty basically carried this team on his back to a top-10 finish.
- Tennessee (11-3): Still explosive, still loud, still dangerous.
- Indiana (11-2): Curt Cignetti is officially the most interesting man in Indiana.
The Group of Five Statement
For years, we heard that the Group of Five teams couldn't compete with the big budgets. 2024 said "hold my beer." Boise State didn't just make the playoff; they belonged there. They finished at No. 8, proving that a dominant running game and a blue field are enough to scare anyone.
Then there’s Army and Navy. It was like 1945 all over again. Both service academies were ranked in the top 25 simultaneously for the first time in decades. Army finished at No. 21 after a 12-2 season. They didn't even trail in a game until late in the year. It was disciplined, old-school football that made a lot of high-powered offenses look silly.
🔗 Read more: Why Isn't Mbappe Playing Today: The Real Madrid Crisis Explained
What Most People Get Wrong About the 2024 Rankings
People think the "best" teams are the ones with the most five-star recruits. 2024 proved that's a lie. Look at Florida State. They were a preseason darling and ended up in the "Bottom 25" for a good portion of the year. Talent matters, but chemistry and coaching matter more.
The college football top 25 2024 was defined by the transfer portal. Look at Miami. Cam Ward transformed that offense. Look at Colorado. Travis Hunter won the Heisman because he's a freak of nature, but also because that team played with a chip on its shoulder that most "traditional" powers lacked.
Surprises and Disappointments
- Vanderbilt: They weren't ranked at the end, but they were the "giant killers" of the SEC.
- SMU: They transitioned to the ACC and immediately finished in the top 15. That shouldn't be that easy.
- Alabama: Life after Saban was... bumpy. They finished 11th. For Bama, that’s a down year.
The Heisman Factor
You can't talk about the rankings without talking about Travis Hunter. He played nearly every snap on both sides of the ball. It’s exhausting just watching him. Colorado finished at No. 25, which might seem low, but considering where they were two years ago? It’s a miracle. Hunter’s presence alone kept them in the national conversation and moved the needle in the polls every single week.
💡 You might also like: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
How to Use These Rankings for 2025
If you’re looking at these 2024 results to predict next year, don't just look at the win-loss columns. Look at the rosters.
Ohio State is losing a ton of talent to the NFL. Texas is returning a deep defense. Indiana is now a "destination" for transfers. The landscape has shifted. The college football top 25 2024 wasn't just a list; it was the blueprint for the new era of the sport.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
- Watch the Coaching Carousel: Guys like Curt Cignetti (Indiana) and Kenny Dillingham (ASU) are the new blueprints. Follow where the "overachieving" coaches go.
- Ignore Preseason Hype: Georgia and FSU were the 2024 "locks." One finished 6th, the other didn't even make a bowl.
- Value the Trenches: The teams that stayed in the top 10 all season (Ohio State, Oregon, Penn State) had the best offensive lines. Flashy QBs are great, but protection wins titles.
- Follow the Five Highest-Ranked Champs: In the new 12-team format, the conference title is more valuable than ever. It’s the only guaranteed path.
The 2024 season is in the books, but the arguments about who was "actually" better will go on forever. That’s the beauty of college football.
Next Steps:
- Audit the returning starters for the current top 10 programs to see who has the best "continuity score" for 2025.
- Research the 2025 strength of schedule for the current top-ranked Big Ten and SEC teams, as conference expansion has made these paths significantly harder.