College football is finally back, and honestly, it took exactly four quarters for the preseason hype to start crumbling. If you looked at the college football coaches poll after week 1, you saw a leaderboard that looks significantly different from the "safe" picks we saw back in August. We went from talking about Texas as the clear-cut titan to watching Ohio State leapfrog them after a statement win in Columbus.
It’s chaotic. It’s reactionary. It’s exactly what makes this sport a beautiful disaster every September.
The coaches are often accused of being "sticky" with their rankings—meaning they don't like to move teams down unless they lose by thirty. But this time? They actually swung the axe. Between Alabama’s unexpected stumble and Florida State’s meteoric rise from unranked to the top 20, the Week 1 adjustments proved that the "benefit of the doubt" is a dying currency in the 12-team playoff era.
The Big Shakeup: Ohio State Takes the Throne
Let’s be real: the biggest story of the week was the showdown at the Horseshoe. Texas came in as the No. 1 team in the land, carrying all that "it’s our year" energy. Then they met the Buckeyes. Ohio State’s defense looked like a pro unit, stifling Arch Manning in his first massive road test.
Because of that 14-7 slugfest, Ohio State (+1) is your new No. 1.
Texas didn't fall off the face of the earth, but a five-spot drop to No. 6 feels about right when you can’t find the end zone in the second half. The coaches didn't just reward the win; they rewarded the way Ohio State controlled the line of scrimmage. It’s a message to the rest of the country: if you want that top spot, you’re going to have to outmuscle the Big Ten favorites.
📖 Related: U of Washington Football News: Why Jedd Fisch’s Roster Overhaul Is Working
The Rise of the Tigers and the Fall of the Tide
If you’re an LSU fan, you’re probably feeling pretty smug right about now. Brian Kelly finally broke his "opening game" curse with a 17-10 win over Clemson in Death Valley. It wasn't pretty. It was, however, effective.
LSU jumped five spots to No. 4.
Garrett Nussmeier didn't put up "video game" numbers, but he was efficient. More importantly, that LSU defense, which was a sieve last year, actually looked like they knew where they were supposed to be.
On the flip side, we have to talk about the elephant in the room. Alabama.
- Alabama dropped 12 spots.
- They currently sit at No. 20.
- The loss to Florida State was... well, it was a lot.
Kalen DeBoer’s debut was supposed to be a smooth transition. Instead, the Crimson Tide looked listless in a 31-17 loss to a Seminoles team that was unranked to start the season. Now, Florida State is sitting at No. 19, having pulled off the biggest jump of the week. Basically, the coaches decided that if you lose by two touchdowns to an unranked opponent, you don't get to stay in the top 10. Simple as that.
👉 See also: Top 5 Wide Receivers in NFL: What Most People Get Wrong
Breaking Down the New Top 10
It's helpful to see the pecking order now that the dust has settled. The college football coaches poll after week 1 gives us a clear look at who the "experts" think are the real contenders versus the pretenders.
- Ohio State (The new undisputed king)
- Penn State (Moved up after a clean win over Nevada)
- Georgia (Kirby Smart’s bunch looked dominant against Marshall)
- LSU (The biggest winner of the top 10)
- Oregon (Throttled Montana State, looked every bit the Big Ten contender)
- Texas (The fall from grace was steep, but they're still dangerous)
- Miami (Carson Beck’s debut win over Notre Dame was a statement)
- Clemson (A slight drop after the LSU loss, but the defense is legit)
- Notre Dame (Slid four spots; the run game was non-existent)
- Arizona State (Welcome back to the big time, Sun Devils)
It is kinda wild to see Arizona State at No. 10, isn't it? They’ve been an afterthought for a minute, but the coaches are clearly buying the hype after Week 1.
Winners and Losers: The Brutal Reality
The middle of the poll is where things get really weird. You’ve got teams like Illinois and South Carolina creeping up, while "sure things" like Kansas State and Boise State completely vanished.
Kansas State lost a heartbreaker to Iowa State in Ireland. That’s a long flight home to realize you’re no longer ranked. Meanwhile, Boise State got absolutely dismantled by USF, losing 34-7. When the "Group of Five" darling gets crushed like that, the coaches show zero mercy. They were out before the highlights even finished airing on SportsCenter.
What about the Quarterbacks?
We can’t discuss the college football coaches poll after week 1 without mentioning the signal-callers. This poll is basically a referendum on QB play.
✨ Don't miss: Tonya Johnson: The Real Story Behind Saquon Barkley's Mom and His NFL Journey
Dante Moore looked smooth for Oregon. Gunner Stockton did exactly what he needed to do for Georgia. But then you look at Arch Manning at Texas or Cade Klubnik at Clemson. They struggled. When the faces of the franchise struggle, the team’s ranking usually follows them down the slide.
Carson Beck’s transition to Miami is probably the most "pro" thing we saw all weekend. He threw for 205 yards and two scores in a hostile environment against a Top 10 Notre Dame team. That win didn't just move Miami up three spots; it changed the entire ceiling for the ACC.
Why This Poll Actually Matters (For Once)
In previous years, Week 1 rankings were mostly for show. With a four-team playoff, you could lose early and still climb back. But in 2025-2026, with 12 teams getting in, the seeding starts now.
The coaches are looking at "body of work" from the jump. A loss like Alabama’s isn't just a blow to the ego—it’s a massive weight on their playoff resume that they’ll be carrying until November. If the Tide doesn't run the table, that 12-spot drop in the college football coaches poll after week 1 might be the moment we look back on as the beginning of the end for their season.
Honestly, the "others receiving votes" section is just as interesting right now. Utah is lurking with 117 votes. Missouri and Louisville are right there too. One bad Saturday for a team in the 15-25 range, and we’re going to see a whole new crop of teams entering the conversation.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans:
- Watch the Lines: Keep an eye on the betting spreads for Week 2. Often, Vegas reacts differently than the coaches. If a team like Alabama is still a heavy favorite next week, the "coaches' panic" might be overblown.
- Track the SEC/Big Ten Balance: Currently, the top of the poll is a tug-of-war between these two conferences. How many spots each conference holds in the Top 12 will dictate the playoff seeding.
- Don't Overreact (Too Much): Remember that Florida State jumped 28 spots. That kind of volatility usually stabilizes by Week 4. If you're a Texas fan, don't sell your season tickets yet—the path to the playoff is wider than ever.
The college football coaches poll after week 1 is a snapshot of a sport in transition. It’s messy, it’s biased, and it’s a total blast to argue about.