You’ve probably seen the amber-colored bottles sitting on your grandma's kitchen counter or tucked away in the "wellness" aisle of your local grocery store. People swear by it. They talk about it like it’s a liquid miracle for joints, brain health, and immunity. But here’s the thing—it isn’t just "fish oil." Cod liver oil is a different beast entirely because it's pressed from the actual livers of Pacific or Atlantic cod. That sounds like a minor detail. It’s not. Because it comes from the liver, it’s packed with fat-soluble vitamins that can actually cause problems if you aren't careful.
Cod liver oil side effects aren't always dramatic, but they are real. Most people think "more is better" when it comes to supplements. With this stuff? That logic will get you into trouble fast.
The Vitamin A Trap Nobody Warns You About
Most fish oils are just omega-3 fatty acids. Cod liver oil is basically a vitamin A and D supplement that happens to have omega-3s attached. This is where the risk starts. Vitamin A is fat-soluble. That means your body doesn't just pee out the extra like it does with Vitamin C. It stores it in your liver. If you're taking a high-dose supplement and eating a lot of vitamin-rich foods, you can hit toxicity levels.
Chronic vitamin A toxicity—clinicians call it hypervitaminosis A—is nasty. We aren't talking about a simple stomach ache. It can lead to blurry vision, bone pain, and even skin peeling. There’s a reason Arctic explorers used to warn against eating polar bear liver; the vitamin A concentration was so high it was literally lethal. While your bottle of Nordic Naturals isn't polar bear liver, the principle remains.
👉 See also: The Real 1000 Yard Stare: Why That Blank Look is More Than Just a Meme
If you're pregnant, this becomes a much more serious conversation. Excessive vitamin A intake has been linked to birth defects. Most OB-GYNs will tell you to skip the cod liver oil and stick to a purified DHA supplement instead. It’s just safer.
Why Your Stomach Might Hate You
Let's be honest: fish burps are the worst. It’s the number one complaint. You take your dose, go about your day, and suddenly you’re tasting a harbor at lunch. This happens because the oil is sitting on top of your stomach contents.
- Some people get "liquid fire" heartburn.
- Others deal with loose stools or even straight-up diarrhea if they take too much at once.
- Bloating is a common, though less discussed, annoyance.
Basically, if your digestion is already sensitive, dumping a tablespoon of oil into it might not go well. To mitigate this, some people freeze their capsules or take them right in the middle of a heavy meal. It helps, but it’s not a guarantee.
Thinning the Blood: The Omega-3 Factor
Omega-3 fatty acids are natural anticoagulants. They make your blood less "sticky." Generally, that’s great for heart health. It prevents clots. But there is a flip side. If you are already taking blood thinners like Warfarin (Coumadin), Clopidogrel, or even just high-dose aspirin, adding cod liver oil can increase your risk of bleeding.
I’m talking about easy bruising. Maybe a nosebleed that won't stop as fast as it should. If you have surgery scheduled, surgeons will almost always tell you to stop all fish oils at least two weeks before you go under the knife. They don't want any surprises with your blood's ability to clot while they're working.
The Vitamin D Overdose Mystery
Vitamin D is the "sunshine vitamin," and most of us are deficient. Cod liver oil is a fantastic source. However, just like Vitamin A, Vitamin D is fat-soluble. Taking massive amounts of cod liver oil—especially if you're also taking a dedicated D3 supplement—can lead to hypercalcemia.
What does that look like? Your body starts pulling too much calcium into the blood. You might feel fatigued, confused, or find yourself running to the bathroom to pee every twenty minutes. In extreme cases, it can cause kidney stones. Nobody wants kidney stones. They are arguably one of the most painful "minor" medical issues a human can experience.
Purity, Rancidity, and "The Smell"
Here is something the marketing teams won't tell you: fish oil goes bad. Fast.
When oil oxidizes, it becomes rancid. Rancid oil doesn't just taste bad; it can actually cause inflammation, which is the exact opposite of why you’re taking it in the first place. If your oil smells intensely "fishy" or sour, it’s probably oxidized. Fresh cod liver oil should have a very mild, almost neutral scent, or perhaps a light lemon scent if it’s been flavored.
There’s also the heavy metal issue. We’ve done a number on our oceans. Mercury, PCBs, and dioxins concentrate in the fat and livers of fish. High-quality brands use molecular distillation to strip these out, but the cheap stuff at the discount warehouse might not be as clean as you’d hope.
Real World Nuance: It’s Not All Bad
I’m not saying cod liver oil is poison. Far from it. For someone living in a northern climate with zero sun in January, it can be a lifesaver for mood and bone density. The trick is the dose.
The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) and the NIH in the States have different "upper limits," but generally, you want to stay under 3,000mg of combined EPA and DHA per day from all sources unless a doctor says otherwise. For cod liver oil specifically, you usually hit your Vitamin A limit long before you hit your Omega-3 limit.
- Check your labels. Look for the "IU" (International Units) of Vitamin A.
- Don't double dip. If your multivitamin already has 100% of your Vitamin A, maybe skip the cod liver oil.
- Listen to your gut. If you’re getting rashes or stomach pain, stop. Your body is a pretty good communicator if you actually pay attention.
What You Should Actually Do Now
If you’re currently staring at a bottle of cod liver oil wondering if you should toss it, don't panic. For the average healthy person, a standard dose is perfectly fine. But to be smart about it, do these three things:
First, get a blood test. Ask your doctor to check your Vitamin D and Vitamin A levels. It’s the only way to know if you actually need a supplement. Most people are guessing, and guessing with fat-soluble vitamins is a bad game.
Second, switch to a high-quality, third-party tested brand. Look for a seal from IFOS (International Fish Oil Standards). This ensures that what’s on the label is actually in the bottle and that the mercury levels are below safety thresholds.
Third, take it with a meal that contains other fats. This helps with absorption and significantly reduces the "burp" factor. If you still have issues, consider a fermented version or just switch to a standard krill or fish oil that doesn't have the high Vitamin A content.
Wellness is about balance, not just loading up on every supplement you hear about on a podcast. Keep the dose low, keep the quality high, and keep your doctor in the loop.