It was late. The kind of humid, sticky Minnesota night where the air feels like a wet blanket, and the atmosphere inside Allianz Field was even heavier. If you were watching the partidos de club américa contra minnesota united during the 2023 Leagues Cup, you know exactly the moment everything went sideways. It wasn’t just a soccer game. It was a bizarre, VAR-fueled fever dream that left Mexican fans fuming and MLS supporters checking their watches in disbelief.
Football is usually simple. You kick the ball, you score, you win. But when Club América—the most decorated team in Mexico—traveled north to face the Loons, "simple" stayed in the locker room.
The Match That Refused to End
Most people remember the scoreline, but the scoreline is a liar. It says 2-2 in regulation, followed by a penalty shootout. What it doesn't say is how much tension was packed into those ninety minutes. Minnesota United, led by Adrian Heath at the time, wasn't supposed to dominate. Let's be real. América is a giant. They have the budget, the history, and a fan base that turns every away game into a home match.
But Minnesota didn't care.
Bongokuhle Hlongwane was a nightmare for the Águilas' defense. He found space where there shouldn't have been any. When he headed home the opener in the 17th minute, the "Loons" fans went absolutely nuclear. It set a tone. This wasn't going to be a friendly exhibition. It was a scrap. América looked sluggish, honestly. They were trying to find their rhythm under André Jardine, who was still relatively new to the bench, and the connection between the midfield and the attack felt... off. Sorta disjointed.
Then came the second half.
América woke up. They always do. Diego Valdés, who is basically a cheat code when he's on his game, started pulling strings. He scored in the 78th minute to level it, and when Julián Quiñones converted a penalty in the 81st, everyone thought: Okay, here we go. The giant has arrived. Game over.
Wrong.
💡 You might also like: What Channel is Champions League on: Where to Watch Every Game in 2026
Hassani Dotson smashed an equalizer in the 89th minute. 2-2. Pure chaos. The stadium was vibrating. No extra time in Leagues Cup—straight to the spot.
The Penalty Controversy Nobody Can Forget
This is where the partidos de club américa contra minnesota united entered the history books for all the wrong reasons. We have to talk about the VAR.
Usually, a penalty shootout is a quick burst of adrenaline. This one was a marathon. América thought they had won. Malagón, the Águilas' keeper, made what looked like the winning save against Joseph Rosales. The América players were literally celebrating. They were hugging, jumping, thinking about the next round.
Then the whistle blew again. Not for the end of the game, but for a review.
The referees decided Malagón had stepped off his line early. In the stadium, you could feel the soul being sucked out of the América contingent. It took forever. Minutes felt like hours. When the kick was ordered to be retaken, the momentum had completely evaporated for the Mexican side.
Minnesota eventually won the shootout 5-4.
The fallout was massive. Social media was a war zone for 48 hours. Fans were calling it a "robbery," while others argued that the rules are the rules. But whether you think it was fair or not, that specific moment changed the perception of the Leagues Cup for a lot of Liga MX fans. It felt like the tournament was tilted. It created a "us against them" narrative that still exists today whenever these two leagues meet.
📖 Related: Eastern Conference Finals 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
Why This Rivalry Feels Different
There’s a specific chemistry when these two clubs meet. You’ve got Minnesota, a team that prides itself on being "Wonderwall" loud and gritty. Then you have América, who carry the "Odiame Mas" (Hate me more) mantra like a badge of honor.
When you look at the tactical breakdown of these partidos de club américa contra minnesota united, you see a clash of styles that is actually quite fascinating.
- The Physicality of MLS: Minnesota leans into the transition. They want to catch you sleeping.
- The Technicality of Liga MX: América wants the ball. They want to suffocate you with possession and quick triangulations.
In that 2023 clash, Minnesota’s willingness to bypass the midfield entirely and go long to their wingers exploited América’s high line. Jardine likes his fullbacks to push up high, which is great for offense but leaves the center-backs on an island. Hlongwane and Fragapane feasted on that space.
Honestly, it’s a miracle it didn’t end 4-4.
Beyond the Scoreboard: The Cultural Impact
It's easy to dismiss these games as just another mid-season tournament fixture. But for the fans in the Twin Cities, seeing a club of América's stature show up at Allianz Field was a "we've arrived" moment. For the Águilas, it was a reminder that the gap between the two leagues is closing, or at the very least, that playing on the road in MLS is a logistical and physical grind.
We also saw the emergence of Kevin Álvarez as a key piece for América during this period. His ability to overlap was one of the few things consistently working for the visitors. On the flip side, Dayne St. Clair proved why he's one of the most underrated keepers in North America. His composure during the VAR madness was the reason Minnesota stayed in it mentally.
What to Watch for in Future Matchups
If these teams meet again—which is likely given the structure of North American competitions—the scouting reports will look a lot different. América has since solidified their defense, becoming a much more balanced unit that won the "Bicampeonato" (back-to-back titles) in Mexico. They aren't the same vulnerable team that showed up in Saint Paul that night.
👉 See also: Texas vs Oklahoma Football Game: Why the Red River Rivalry is Getting Even Weirder
Minnesota has undergone its own transformations. New coaching, new tactical setups, but the same "never say die" attitude at home.
If you're betting on a rematch, look at these three factors:
- Travel Fatigue: Mexican teams have historically struggled with the constant flying during the Leagues Cup. If the game is in Minnesota, the Loons have a 20% "hidden" advantage just from the lack of jet lag.
- The Midfield Pivot: Can Minnesota’s anchors stop Diego Valdés? If he has time to turn and face the goal, it’s lights out.
- Refereeing Consistency: After the 2023 debacle, expect the officiating to be under a microscope. Every VAR check will be met with a chorus of boos from whichever side feels slighted.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
If you're planning on watching or attending the next installment of partidos de club américa contra minnesota united, keep these things in mind to get the most out of the experience.
- Arrive Early for the Atmosphere: The pre-game "Wonderwall" at Allianz is legitimate. Even if you're a die-hard Americanista, you have to respect the noise.
- Watch the Wing-Backs: The game is won or lost in the wide channels. If América's fullbacks are pinned back, Minnesota wins. If they are crossing the ball at will, América wins.
- Prepare for Stoppage Time: These games never end at 90 minutes. Between VAR checks and tactical fouls, the "real" game often happens in the final 10 minutes of each half.
- Check the Roster Depth: In tournament play, both teams often rotate. A "B-team" América is still full of internationals, but they lack the chemistry of the starting XI. Always check the lineup 60 minutes before kickoff.
The 2023 meeting wasn't just a game; it was a catalyst for a burgeoning continental rivalry. It showed that while history favors the Mexican giants, the modern reality of the sport in North America is much more unpredictable. Whether it’s a controversial penalty or a late-game stunner, this fixture has a weird way of producing the spectacular. Don't expect the next one to be any quieter.
Next Steps for the Savvy Fan:
To really understand the tactical evolution since their last meeting, go back and watch the highlights of Club América's recent Clásico Nacional matches. Notice how they've adjusted their defensive transition to stop the exact kind of counter-attacks that Minnesota used to hurt them. For the Loons, keep an eye on their home form against high-pressing teams; it’s the best indicator of how they’ll handle a team of América's caliber in the future.