If you were scrolling through scores on August 2, 2025, you might’ve seen a 3-3 draw and figured it was just another messy mid-season tournament game. You’d be wrong. Dead wrong. The Club América vs Minnesota United clash at Shell Energy Stadium wasn't just a game; it was a fever dream of tactical blunders, red cards, and a penalty shootout that felt like it was never going to end.
Honestly, nobody expected Minnesota to walk into Houston and punch the most successful club in Mexico right in the mouth. But that’s exactly what happened. For 90 minutes, the "Loons" played like they had a personal vendetta against the Águilas.
The Night the Script Got Shredded
Most people look at the giants of Liga MX and assume they’ll steamroll MLS opposition. History usually supports that. But under the humid Texas sky, Minnesota United showed up with a low-block defense that was basically a brick wall with a bad attitude.
It took only 17 minutes for things to get weird. Tani Oluwaseyi—who has been an absolute revelation—outmuscled a defender after a surgical ball from Joaquín Pereyra. He didn't just score; he made the América backline look like they were skating on thin ice.
1-0. Silence from the yellow-clad fans.
América is usually composed, but they looked rattled. They got a lucky break in the 27th minute when a cross took a nasty deflection off Michael Boxall’s head. An own goal. It happens. But if you thought Minnesota would fold after that bit of bad luck, you haven't been watching Eric Ramsay’s squad. Just four minutes later, Bongokuhle Hlongwane silenced the stadium again. 2-1 Minnesota at the half.
✨ Don't miss: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
Why Nobody Talks About the Scouting Failure
There’s a narrative that Mexican clubs take the Leagues Cup less seriously than their domestic season. I don't buy it. André Jardine wanted this win. The problem was that Club América vs Minnesota United exposed a massive hole in the Águilas' scouting report.
They couldn't handle the counterattack. Every time América pushed high, Minnesota’s work rate—specifically from Hlongwane and Pereyra—shredded them. It was a masterclass in "let them have the ball, we’ll take the goals."
The second half was even more chaotic:
- 53rd minute: José Raúl Zúñiga equalizes for América. 2-2.
- 62nd minute: Disaster. Igor Lichnovsky picks up his second yellow. América is down to 10 men.
- 65th minute: Carlos Harvey fires a rocket into the side netting. 3-2 Minnesota.
At this point, the Loons were roughly 25 minutes away from one of the biggest upsets in their history.
The 90th-Minute Heartbreak
Soccer is a cruel sport. You can do everything right for 89 minutes and still lose the plot in the 90th. América never quits. It’s in their DNA. Even with 10 men, they threw everything forward.
🔗 Read more: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
In stoppage time, Sebastián Cáceres rose above everyone on a corner kick. A free header. The kind of mistake that haunts a defender's sleep. He buried it. 3-3.
The air went out of the Minnesota bench.
That Insane Penalty Shootout
If the game was a thriller, the shootout was a marathon. We aren't talking about a quick 5-round affair. Both teams went perfect through the first seven spot-kicks. It was clinical. It was terrifying.
Finally, in the eighth round, Luis Malagón reminded everyone why he’s one of the best keepers in the region. He guessed right on Nicolás Romero’s shot, parrying it away and sealing an 8-7 victory on penalties for the Mexican giants.
It was a "win," but barely.
💡 You might also like: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
What This Means for the Future
The Club América vs Minnesota United rivalry—if we can call it that yet—is a perfect example of how the gap between Liga MX and MLS is closing. Or, at the very least, how a disciplined MLS team can make a powerhouse look mortal.
Minnesota proved they belong on the big stage. They didn't just park the bus; they used the bus to run over América's defense for most of the night. On the other side, América showed that even on their worst day, their individual talent can bail them out of a tactical hole.
Key Takeaways for the Next Matchup
If these two meet again in the 2026 Leagues Cup, keep an eye on a few specific things:
- The Pereyra Factor: Joaquín Pereyra is the engine. If you don't mark him out of the game, he will find the passing lanes.
- América's High Line: If they continue to play that aggressive 4-2-3-1 without cover for the counter, they’ll get burned again.
- Depth: Minnesota’s bench struggled to close the game out. Staying fresh in the final 15 minutes is where they lost this one.
The next time you see Club América vs Minnesota United on the schedule, don't assume it's a blowout. It's a clash of styles that produces some of the most entertaining, heart-attack-inducing soccer in North America.
If you’re a Minnesota fan, keep an eye on the 2026 preseason schedule. The club just announced that after Eric Ramsay's departure for West Brom, Cameron Knowles is stepping up. How he handles high-pressure continental games compared to Ramsay's disciplined low-block will be the story of the summer. For América fans, the focus remains on domestic dominance, but these Leagues Cup scares are becoming a bit too common for comfort.
Keep your eyes on the transfer portal this month; both clubs are looking to shore up their backlines before the next tournament cycle begins. If Minnesota can find a veteran center-back to pair with Boxall, they might not let that 90th-minute header slip next time.