You're standing in front of Noco or maybe that creepy fellow Grour. Your inventory is looking a bit thin, and you see those tempting, locked items at the bottom of the shop menu. Then you see it: the option to fight. It looks like a trap. Honestly, in most RPGs, attacking the guy who sells you potions is a one-way ticket to a "Game Over" screen or, at the very least, getting permanently banned from the shop. But Clair Obscur Expedition 33 fight the merchant bad choice isn't exactly what it seems on the surface.
A lot of players hesitate. They think, "If I swing on this guy, am I locking myself out of the best gear in the game?" It’s a fair worry. Sandfall Interactive loves to play with your head in this Belle Époque world.
The Merchant Fight: Risk vs. Reward
Let’s get one thing straight: fighting a merchant in Expedition 33 is not a "bad choice" in the traditional sense. It's actually a built-in progression mechanic. You aren't murdering a helpless old man; you're challenging a powerful entity to prove you're worthy of their "secret stash."
When you initiate a fight—usually by holding down the interaction button on a locked item until the "paint" fills the meter—you enter a boss-level encounter. These aren't pushovers. If you go in under-leveled, you’ll get flattened. That’s where the "bad choice" label comes from. People try to take on Noco or Grour way too early and end up staring at a death screen wondering where it all went wrong.
What actually happens if you win?
- Locked Items Unlock: Those grayed-out weapons and high-level Pictos suddenly become available for purchase.
- Massive XP Gains: Some merchants, like Grour in Renoir’s Drafts, are legendary for their XP drops. We’re talking upwards of 2 million XP if you handle the fight perfectly.
- No Permanent Penalties: Unlike Dark Souls or Elder Scrolls, the merchant doesn't hold a grudge. You beat them, they respect you, and you keep on trading.
Why Some Call It a Bad Choice
The nuance here is timing. If you’re playing on a higher difficulty or haven't mastered the parry system yet, clicking that fight button is a death sentence. The merchants often have unique mechanics that regular Nevrons don't.
👉 See also: Grand Theft Auto Games Timeline: Why the Chronology is a Beautiful Mess
For example, the merchant in Renoir’s Drafts often comes with two "helpers" that can stun-lock your team if you aren't careful. If you waste your Action Points (AP) on the wrong target, you're toast. I've seen players lose an hour of progress because they thought they could "cheese" the fight with basic attacks.
In Expedition 33, parrying is everything. If you can't hit those tight windows, the merchant will counter-attack for half your health bar. So, is it a bad choice? Only if you're unprepared.
Best Strategies for Surviving the Encounter
If you’re determined to unlock those secret wares, you need a plan. Don't just rush in with Gustave and hope for the best.
- Stack Your Lumina: Use damage-boosting Lumina. If you have Maelle in your party, stack her with everything that increases her "Virtuoso" stacks.
- The "Glass Cannon" Tactic: Some players use the "First Offensive" and "Glass Cannon" Pictos to try and one-shot the merchant. It's risky. If you miss the kill, you’re defenseless.
- Wait for the Right Level: There is no shame in coming back later. The items will still be there. Most veteran players recommend being at least level 50 before tackling the mid-game merchants.
Honestly, the real "bad choice" is ignoring the fight entirely. You’ll miss out on some of the most powerful gear in the game, including Sciel’s top-tier weapons and unique character Tints that you can't get anywhere else.
✨ Don't miss: Among Us Spider-Man: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessed With These Mods
Misconceptions About the Merchant Choice
There’s a rumor floating around that fighting merchants affects your ending. That is false. The narrative in Expedition 33 is largely driven by specific choices made in the final act, particularly the one right before the Paintress encounter. Punching a shopkeeper in Chapter 3 isn't going to turn Gustave into a villain or change the fate of Lumière.
Another big mistake? Thinking you can only fight them once. While the initial "unlock" fight is the main event, some players have reported being able to refight certain merchants in NG+ for even higher rewards.
How to Handle the "Gommage" Pressure
The game constantly reminds you that time is running out. The Paintress is coming. This pressure makes players feel like they need to be optimal every second. This leads to the "fear of the bad choice."
Relax. Expedition 33 is surprisingly forgiving with its save system. If you take a swing at a merchant and get your teeth kicked in, the game usually autosaves right before the interaction. You can just reload, buy some standard potions, and go on your way.
🔗 Read more: Why the Among the Sleep Mom is Still Gaming's Most Uncomfortable Horror Twist
Quick Checklist Before You Fight:
- Did you save recently? (Change your wardrobe to force an autosave).
- Is your parry rhythm on point today?
- Do you have enough currency to actually buy the items once you unlock them? (Nothing sucks more than winning the fight and being too broke to buy the prize).
Basically, the merchant fight is a skill check. It's the game asking, "Are you actually getting better at the mechanics, or are you just grinding levels?"
If you want to maximize your run, you have to do it. Just don't do it blindly. Equip your best Pictos, set your Tints, and make sure your team synergy is tight.
Next Steps for Your Expedition:
Check your current level and head to the nearest merchant in the Flying Waters or Renoir’s Drafts. If you’re above level 55, try initiating the fight with a focus on parrying every single incoming attack to trigger a free counter-attack. This is the fastest way to clear the encounter and secure that high-level gear before the next major boss.